Penn Internationnal travel rods 2 + slammer reels ?

[Philtix]

Hi,

I would like to constitute me a travel fishing combo that target tarpons
(medium size, until 50 or 60 kilos) and lures fishing in general. What
choice you advice me?

Rods:

Penn Internationnal II spinb travel rod 8 lbs
Penn Internationnal II spinb travel rod 12 lbs
Penn Internationnal II spinb travel rod 16 lbs (need to replace rings and
handle)
Sage spinning rod GSP 8-17 lbs
Sage spinning rod GSP 10-20 lbs

Reels:

Penn Slammer 460
Penn Slammer 560
other?

Did you experience one of these tackles?

Thanks by advance,

Philippe

[[email protected]]

The Sage 570-3 or G Loomis LR 844-3S would be the best choices, even better
would be the Loomis LR 844-3C and a good sal****er casting reel.
Easier to pack and store in a smaller package. The Shimano CTE- 401 would be
a good reel if your right handed.

[Philtix]

> The Sage 570-3 or G Loomis LR 844-3S would be the best choices, even
better
> would be the Loomis LR 844-3C and a good sal****er casting reel.
> Easier to pack and store in a smaller package. The Shimano CTE- 401 would
be
> a good reel if your right handed.


Thanks for your answer. What do you reproach to Penn rods? When I read the
data sheet of the G Loomis LR 844-3S, I am not sure that this rod will allow
to tackle 80 pounds tarpons, what do you think?

Philippe

[[email protected]]

Have nothing against Penn rods or especially their reels but they are
historically overbuilt with glass/graphite construction that are a little
"clunky" feeling. If everyone made a 7' 6" 3 piece 5 or 6 power rod that
would be better, but your kind of restricted by what sells, no one spends
the money designing rods that few people will buy, thats why most travel rod
blanks are popping rod action in sal****er blanks. Live bait blanks usually
are the rods between popping rods and the full on sal****er rods, the last
of the light, handy, versatile rods. Tarpon have tough mouths and you need
heavy light and hooks, a casting rod has for me always been a better choice
in lines exceeding 15 lb test. Have caught lots of Tarpon on the Loomis L905
blank the eAngler custom rods are built on them, don't see why the L844-3
wouldn't also do the job, have caught Tarpon on my 4 power popping rods, and
it will easily fit in a 2 to 2 1/2 inch rod tube, the big guides on
spinning rods are harder and more expensive usually to protect. Quality rod
bags, etc. are also easier to come by.
If you think about snapper and grouper fishing or combat snook in the
mangoves or anywhere you take this rod where balance and sensitivity could
be important the casting rod will be superior hands down, if for nothing
else the superior drags on most casting reels, their toughness and their
inherent reliability.
Good luck.

[Philtix]

Hello,

I thank you for all the informations you gave me about the choice of a
traveling combo targetting tarpons.

I believe that loomis rods are perfect but they are a bit out of
budget for the moment. So I still hesitate betwwen Penn Inter II 16lb
or 20lb (if you have to choose between these 2 rods wich one you
take?) and some BassPro rods (ocean master 3 pieces (10-20 or
12-25lbs) or similar in cabelas. What do you advice me? other?

Thanks by advance.

Philippe

wrote in message et>...
> Have nothing against Penn rods or especially their reels but they are
> historically overbuilt with glass/graphite construction that are a little
> "clunky" feeling. If everyone made a 7' 6" 3 piece 5 or 6 power rod that
> would be better, but your kind of restricted by what sells, no one spends
> the money designing rods that few people will buy, thats why most travel rod
> blanks are popping rod action in sal****er blanks. Live bait blanks usually
> are the rods between popping rods and the full on sal****er rods, the last
> of the light, handy, versatile rods. Tarpon have tough mouths and you need
> heavy light and hooks, a casting rod has for me always been a better choice
> in lines exceeding 15 lb test. Have caught lots of Tarpon on the Loomis L905
> blank the eAngler custom rods are built on them, don't see why the L844-3
> wouldn't also do the job, have caught Tarpon on my 4 power popping rods, and
> it will easily fit in a 2 to 2 1/2 inch rod tube, the big guides on
> spinning rods are harder and more expensive usually to protect. Quality rod
> bags, etc. are also easier to come by.
> If you think about snapper and grouper fishing or combat snook in the
> mangoves or anywhere you take this rod where balance and sensitivity could
> be important the casting rod will be superior hands down, if for nothing
> else the superior drags on most casting reels, their toughness and their
> inherent reliability.
> Good luck.

[joe]

In article >,
(Philtix) wrote:

> So I still hesitate betwwen Penn Inter II 16lb
> or 20lb (if you have to choose between these 2 rods wich one you
> take?) and some BassPro rods (ocean master 3 pieces (10-20 or
> 12-25lbs) or similar in cabelas. What do you advice me? other?

I would suggest the 12 - 25 lb line class rods for tarpon of 80 - 120+
pounds.

As for the BassPro rods (and likely the Cabelas) I have had great
service from those I use. I would like to be able to spend the kind of
money to have a high end Loomis or even St. Croix rod but I can't.

I started out with a single outfit, a two piece actually and it is a
'fresh' water model if there is any difference. This was the $50 range
Bionic Blade (medium heavy and light actions). The guides have held up
very well as also the cork handles. The blanks are usually pretty good
and come from a name brand source but the guides and such may not be the
same quality as more expensive brands.

All but one (a Falcon) of my 10 outfits (conventional and fly) are
BassPro models.

Other good brands are available (I will have to refresh my thoughts on
the brand that my Tampa freinds have had good use).
--
"Atlanta Joe" aka Joe Webb
Flats fishing is Flat Fun!
Visit my site at http://flatsfisher.com