FishingBanter

FishingBanter (http://www.fishingbanter.com/index.php)
-   Fly Fishing (http://www.fishingbanter.com/forumdisplay.php?f=6)
-   -   Need help identifying a mayfly (http://www.fishingbanter.com/showthread.php?t=4280)

Jeff Miller May 5th, 2004 01:35 PM

Need help identifying a mayfly
 


Warren wrote:

wrote...

I googled "March Brown" under google images. Are these the same animal?



To be honest with you, I am still up in the air about this. The
link that Chas provided was very helpful and according to it wayno
pretty much nailed the ID. I followed the "tutorial" kind of thing
to ID bugs and it spit out Epeorus and Western Quill Gordon. It
wasn't an Epeorus albertae (yellow quill) as wayno suggested, but he
nailed two out of the three (props to uncle wayno!). According to
the site, a March Brown has three tails (one of the traits I was
taught) and so the insect that I took the pic of could not possibly
be a March Brown.


hmm...rhithrogena morrisoni, rhithrogena hageni (western march brown) -
my book says two tails. i thought it was a march brown too...but i
wouldn't know an epeorus from a stenonema.

I am still waiting to hear back from the
entomologist though. I am wondering if I ever will hear back from
him and would understand if I never do, but I still doubt that what
I learned originally is correct. I have received a couple of emails
from people that agreed with wayno and so that is comforting. At
least I have some sort of consensus to fall back on. ;-)


my li'l bug book says epeorus albertae (calls it a slate cream dun) is a
western secondary hatch in faster waters at lower altitudes, occurring
between july and mid-august, emerging at dusk with spinner fall in
mornings and evenings.

jeff


William Claspy May 5th, 2004 02:41 PM

Need help identifying a mayfly
 
On 5/5/04 3:08 AM, in article ,
"Warren" wrote:

My trip to the library was uneventful and I found myself easily
distracted by numerous other topics. Those damn libraries **** me
off! It is like going to a buffet that serves everything that you
have ever liked eating and would love to eat again, but they serve
it all at the same time!


:-)

I'm going to print that quote out and put it on my office wall.

While our collection likely doesn't come close to the angling collection at
MSU, I'm putting together a display of some very nice late 19th and early
20th century volumes on the subject. I've found it mandatory to read each
before putting them in the display, just to be sure.

I'll put together a virtual version of the display, including a short
annotated bibliography, and let y'all know when it is up and ready.

Libraries R Us,
Bill


Wolfgang May 5th, 2004 04:55 PM

Need help identifying a mayfly
 

"William Claspy" wrote in message
...
On 5/5/04 3:08 AM, in article

,
"Warren" wrote:

My trip to the library was uneventful and I found myself easily
distracted by numerous other topics. Those damn libraries **** me
off! It is like going to a buffet that serves everything that you
have ever liked eating and would love to eat again, but they serve
it all at the same time!


:-)

I'm going to print that quote out and put it on my office wall.

While our collection likely doesn't come close to the angling

collection at
MSU, I'm putting together a display of some very nice late 19th and

early
20th century volumes on the subject. I've found it mandatory to

read each
before putting them in the display, just to be sure.

I'll put together a virtual version of the display, including a

short
annotated bibliography, and let y'all know when it is up and ready.


Cool. Looking forward to it.

Libraries R Us,
Bill


Willi thinks you're sexy. :)

Wolfgang



Kevin Vang May 5th, 2004 04:55 PM

Need help identifying a mayfly
 
In article ,
says...
net wrote...
Having

an actual pic of each would be, to quote a North Dakotan, "the
sheep's ass." g



Just for the record, I have never said that, or even heard anybody
else say that...


Warren (who is wondering when Kevin Vang is coming out this way so
that he can be sure to be on vacation and far away during the same
period)



Hah! I'm on to your sorry plan. I saw in another thread that
you are headed out to Spokane, and I will be in the area -- Post
Falls, ID, at about the same time. Current plans are to be in
ID from about May 16-20 or so, and then we will be heading back
to Butte to fish the Big Hole from the 21 to the 25th, give or
take. Drop me an email if you want to hook up and do some fishing.

Kevin,
whose only contact with sheep lately was roasting a leg of lamb
for Easter dinner.

William Claspy May 5th, 2004 05:04 PM

Need help identifying a mayfly
 
On 5/5/04 11:55 AM, in article ,
"Wolfgang" wrote:

Cool. Looking forward to it.


You can see it in person next week, if you'd like...

Libraries R Us,
Bill


Willi thinks you're sexy. :)


I printed that one out too :-)

Bill


Wolfgang May 5th, 2004 05:16 PM

Need help identifying a mayfly
 

"William Claspy" wrote in message
...
On 5/5/04 11:55 AM, in article

,
"Wolfgang" wrote:

Cool. Looking forward to it.


You can see it in person next week, if you'd like...


I haven't decided on a specific route yet. Coming out your way is a
definite possiblity.....and the pot just got sweeter. How do I find
you?

Libraries R Us,
Bill


Willi thinks you're sexy. :)


I printed that one out too :-)


Ah.....documentation!.....good idea. :)

Wolfgang



Warren May 6th, 2004 02:47 AM

Need help identifying a mayfly
 
wrote...
Just for the record, I have never said that, or even heard anybody
else say that...


:-)

Hah! I'm on to your sorry plan. I saw in another thread that
you are headed out to Spokane, and I will be in the area -- Post
Falls, ID, at about the same time. Current plans are to be in
ID from about May 16-20 or so, and then we will be heading back
to Butte to fish the Big Hole from the 21 to the 25th, give or
take. Drop me an email if you want to hook up and do some fishing.


Will do.
--
Warren
(use troutbum_mt on either yahoo or earthlink to respond via email)


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 03:46 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2006 FishingBanter