Fishing - Merry Christmas!

FishingBanter (http://www.fishingbanter.com/index.php)

- Fly Fishing (http://www.fishingbanter.com/forumdisplay.php?f=6)

- - Merry Christmas! (http://www.fishingbanter.com/showthread.php?t=20278)

Merry Christmas!

"David Snedeker" schrieb im Newsbeitrag
. ..
SNIP
Dave
If Roman historical reference had anything to do with what the main
Christian holiday would be, setting fires in apartment houses might rank
pretty high.

At least one has the consolation that the powers that be are always
fiddling.

TL
MC

Merry Christmas!

Wolfgang wrote:
"Karl S" wrote in message
...

Stan Gula wrote:

I call bull****.
Here's some details:
http://www.simpletoremember.com/vita...eRealStory.htm

The Roman Saturnalia celebration predates Christianity, and the Romans
actually stole (errr, adopted) the idea from the Greeks who called it
Sacaea. And the Greeks stole it from Babylon where it was called Zagmuk.
The solstice was celebrated in Babylon 4,000 years before Christ and a
lot
of the 'Christmas traditions' have been handed down from the ancient
past.
Note that Zagmuk is very similar to Zagnut, a wicked fine candy bar,
which
has been made for over 75 years which predates most of us. Not that that
relates to Christmas at all, except that if somebody wanted to buy me a
reasonable priced candy bar for a present, well, hint, hint, wink, wink.

Gonna open a nice bottle of port tomorrow to toast "Longer Days!".

I said "widely popular holidays", Stan.

What percentage of the world today celebrates Saturnalia? Sacaea? Zagmuk?
The Solstice? The most popular runner-up would be Chanukah or Hanukkah,
whichever spelling you prefer, but that is a rather minor celebration of
the Jewish faith which is widely recognized only because it occurs in the
same part of the year as Christmas.
Forgotten celebrations to dead religions really don't count as a basis for
a holiday season.
It doesn't even really matter that Christmas is near the solstice.
If Christmas happened in July, the holiday season would be in July.
And December would be only a time of waiting for New Year's Day.

You sort of missed the point, Karl. Christmas couldn't happen in
July......the winter solstice......get it? Most of the world pays attention
to the winter solstice in one way or another, and celebrates Saturnalia,
Sacaea, Zagmuk, Christmas, Chanukah or whatever.......and has since
antiquity.....they just change the name and the idols periodically. The
Christians merely borrowed from a variety of creation myths (as did the
Jews.....and the Romans......and others.....before them) and stuck some of
their own window dressing on it. Their major problem was that they weren't
real good with calendars........or at making up their minds for that matter.
They missed the solstice.....and they still can't decide whether or not they
like the vernal equinox (about the timing of which they are equally
uncertain).....the whole death and rebirth (resurrection, blah, blah....you
know, Easter) better than the solstice. See, the old year dies.....cosmic
significance and all that.....right? But when does it begin anew?
Hm......is it when they days start to get longer?......or is it when the
grass starts to grow again? Well, what the hell......let's start it both
times! Can't lose! :)

Wolfgang
i mean, does ANYBODY really still believe that december 25th marks an
important birthday?

I'm sorry Wolfgang, but you are not missing - but rather, ignoring - the
point.

Christmas could indeed be any time of the year, because it seems nobody
really knows the exact date of Jesus' birth. That it was set in December
was a slightly shameful political decision taken a long time ago, that
is true. Mankind, even well-meaning scholarly types, can get political.

However, Christmas is in fact the celebration of the birth of Jesus, the
Christ. The salvation of mankind is worth celebrating.

You will of course continue to ignore this, for the sheer malicious fun
of it. By all means do so, for this time of year is the hatching season
for Christ-haters, if that is how you celebrate the winter solstice.
By the way, celebrate it today.

Not on the 25th. That's Christmas.

Karl S.

Merry Christmas!

Karl S wrote:

However, Christmas is in fact the celebration of the birth of Jesus, the
Christ. The salvation of mankind is worth celebrating.

Where do Santa Claus and the reindeer (including Rudolph) and the elves
and Mrs. Santa Claus fit into this Jesus thing?

Easter is the preeminent Christian holiday (although the Easter Bunny is
gaining ground). One Christian holiday is quite enough for me to ignore.
Christmas belongs to pop culture.

--
Cut "to the chase" for my email address.

Merry Christmas!

"Karl S" wrote in message
t...

I'm sorry Wolfgang,

Well, I don't believe that, but let's see where you go with it, shall we?

but you are not missing - but rather, ignoring - the point.

I'm doing neither.....but DO go on.

Christmas could indeed be any time of the year, because it seems nobody
really knows the exact date of Jesus' birth.

Nope. You may rest assured that the Church fathers got the point. That's
why Christmas HAS TO be at the winter solstice.....or the vernal equinox.
Well, somewhere in the general neighborhood, anyway. :)

That it was set in December was a slightly shameful political decision
taken a long time ago, that is true.

No, that is not true. There's nothing shameful about it. It's a time
honored tradition.....besides making eminent good sense.

Mankind, even well-meaning scholarly types, can get political.

No, they don't GET political.....they ARE political......as you are, albeit
with little success.

However, Christmas is in fact the celebration of the birth of Jesus, the
Christ.

You can call it whatever you please. Makes no difference to me.

The salvation of mankind is worth celebrating.

Indeed. Would that we might see it someday. Don't hold your breath,
though.

You will of course continue to ignore this, for the sheer malicious fun of
it. By all means do so, for this time of year is the hatching season for
Christ-haters, if that is how you celebrate the winter solstice.

There is nothing at all malicious about my examination or understanding of
Christian mythology....any more than there is about the mythologies of the
Muslims, the Jews, the Hindus, the Buddhists or any other religious group
I've looked at. Nor do I consider it worth my time to bother with hating
Gilgamesh, Jesus, Beowulf, or Huck Finn. You're going to have to find
someone else to wear that badge. However, if you're really all that serious
about courting martyrdom......well, you HAVE come to the right place.
:)

By the way, celebrate it today.

I'll celebrate whatever I please whenever I choose to.

Not on the 25th. That's Christmas.

Well......gosh......why wasn't I informed?

Wolfgang

Merry Christmas!

"Karl S" wrote ...

snip

By all means do so, for this time of year is the hatching season for
Christ-haters

Karl S.

Christ-haters? Oh my.

Seems Mr. S. hath consumed a bit of the Kool-Aid.

Dan

Merry Christmas!

"rw" wrote in message
k.net...
...Easter is the preeminent Christian holiday...

Varies from one cult to another.

Wolfgang
common knowledge.

Merry Christmas!