FishingBanter

FishingBanter (http://www.fishingbanter.com/index.php)
-   General Discussion (http://www.fishingbanter.com/forumdisplay.php?f=4)
-   -   Gill Netting For Salmon (http://www.fishingbanter.com/showthread.php?t=23030)

fishy1 July 23rd, 2006 10:34 PM

Gill Netting For Salmon
 
I bought a fair bit (300 yardsX5feet) of 5" gill net. Can I catch
salmon with this on a fairly big river with salmon running up it? I
was thinking of stringing 100lb mono through the top of the net, and
tying the mono to each bank. I have made about 40 leads, each about
4oz. Will this arrangement work? I'm thinking of leaving it out for a
day, will it be packed full of salmon? Would my arrangement and net
size hold all the salmon? The salmon which run up the river go up to
about 30lb normally. Would that size of salmn be capable of ripping
the net apart? The line in the net is 0.7mm, that's about 15lb
strenght. Also, when I empty the net, will most of the salmon be dead?

Thanks, I've googled this alot, but I could not find much of any use.

By the way, gill netting is legal where I am, but no-one does it
anymore.


fishy1 July 23rd, 2006 10:40 PM

Gill Netting For Salmon
 
I also thought if I tensioned the line enough by pulling it, I wouldn't
need floats. I can improvise floats out of pipe insulation if
neccesary however.


George July 24th, 2006 09:36 PM

Gill Netting For Salmon
 
You need to check your state laws. I would be surprised if you would be
allowed to net spawning salmon. You would devastate the returning
population.
George in Las Vegas



Ben July 25th, 2006 03:46 PM

Gill Netting For Salmon
 

George wrote:
You need to check your state laws. I would be surprised if you would be
allowed to net spawning salmon. You would devastate the returning
population.
George in Las Vegas


I thought that gill netting was only for population count reasons. Is
it also used for fishing ?


David July 27th, 2006 12:20 AM

Gill Netting For Salmon
 

fishy1 wrote:
I bought a fair bit (300 yardsX5feet) of 5" gill net. Can I catch
salmon with this on a fairly big river with salmon running up it? I
was thinking of stringing 100lb mono through the top of the net, and
tying the mono to each bank. I have made about 40 leads, each about
4oz. Will this arrangement work? I'm thinking of leaving it out for a
day, will it be packed full of salmon? Would my arrangement and net
size hold all the salmon? The salmon which run up the river go up to
about 30lb normally. Would that size of salmn be capable of ripping
the net apart? The line in the net is 0.7mm, that's about 15lb
strenght. Also, when I empty the net, will most of the salmon be dead?

Thanks, I've googled this alot, but I could not find much of any use.

By the way, gill netting is legal where I am, but no-one does it
anymore.


Why gill nets? I'd think blasting caps or using det cord would prove
more cost and time effective?

David N.


I Like Pike July 27th, 2006 11:13 PM

Gill Netting For Salmon
 

This guy lives in the UK so who knows about their laws, I know no where
in the states could you get away with this


CalifBill July 28th, 2006 05:32 AM

Gill Netting For Salmon
 

"I Like Pike" wrote in message
oups.com...

This guy lives in the UK so who knows about their laws, I know no where
in the states could you get away with this


The Native Americans / First Nation people are allowed on some rivers in
the West to gill net. If you strung the net across a navigable river, do
not expect it to be there when you return. Or at least in one piece.



CMaster July 30th, 2006 04:07 PM

Gill Netting For Salmon
 

CalifBill wrote:
"I Like Pike" wrote in message
oups.com...

This guy lives in the UK so who knows about their laws, I know no where
in the states could you get away with this


The Native Americans / First Nation people are allowed on some rivers in
the West to gill net. If you strung the net across a navigable river, do
not expect it to be there when you return. Or at least in one piece.


Great Post! That was quite common here for awhile then the Indians
decided it was best to drift with their nets. The next thing you know
their boats started sinking during the night for some unknown reason so
they started pulling their boats at night. It wasn't long after that
they were hit with shotgun pellets. Now, it is pretty rare to see a net
outside of the reservation, imagine that. I guess some people just
don't like others who net the rivers, maybe the OP should have realized
that before posting.
BTW, to the OP, your rigging will not work, that is not how it's done.
I've hung enough gillnet in my time to get a good chuckle out of your
plan. Don't bother to email me because I'm not going to tell you how
either.

Terry
--
Crayfishing Made Easy
World's Leader in Crayfish Traps
Everyone Is Doing It. Are You?
http://www.terrybullard.com/CrawfishMain.html


fishy1 July 31st, 2006 05:22 PM

Gill Netting For Salmon
 

CMaster wrote:
CalifBill wrote:
"I Like Pike" wrote in message
oups.com...

This guy lives in the UK so who knows about their laws, I know no where
in the states could you get away with this


The Native Americans / First Nation people are allowed on some rivers in
the West to gill net. If you strung the net across a navigable river, do
not expect it to be there when you return. Or at least in one piece.


Great Post! That was quite common here for awhile then the Indians
decided it was best to drift with their nets. The next thing you know
their boats started sinking during the night for some unknown reason so
they started pulling their boats at night. It wasn't long after that
they were hit with shotgun pellets. Now, it is pretty rare to see a net
outside of the reservation, imagine that. I guess some people just
don't like others who net the rivers, maybe the OP should have realized
that before posting.
BTW, to the OP, your rigging will not work, that is not how it's done.
I've hung enough gillnet in my time to get a good chuckle out of your
plan. Don't bother to email me because I'm not going to tell you how
either.

Terry
--
Crayfishing Made Easy
World's Leader in Crayfish Traps
Everyone Is Doing It. Are You?
http://www.terrybullard.com/CrawfishMain.html


This stretch of river is not navegatible. I'm not a native or non
native american. I don't live in a reservation. I don't have a boat
on the river. No-one shoots other people's boats where I live.
Perhaps this is acceptable behaviour where you live when you disagree
with them, but here, shotguns are not used to shoot boats.

"I guess some people just
don't like others who net the rivers, maybe the OP should have realized
that before posting."


I did realise that before posting, however, people where I live do not
mind netting of rivers. I really don't care what someone across the
atlantic's opinion of gill netting is. BTW, it shows you don't have a
mature attitude when you laugh at someone's idea. I don't intend to
email someone like you. Go do some metal detecting.


CMaster July 31st, 2006 09:19 PM

Gill Netting For Salmon
 

fishy1 wrote:

This stretch of river is not navegatible. I'm not a native or non
native american. I don't live in a reservation. I don't have a boat
on the river. No-one shoots other people's boats where I live.
Perhaps this is acceptable behaviour where you live when you disagree
with them, but here, shotguns are not used to shoot boats.


Acceptable behaviour? Perhaps not but it happens all the time. I was
just talking about the sportsman point of view here. You should see
what happens when the commercial guys mix it up. They don't call it the
Wild West here for nothing, LMAO.


"I guess some people just
don't like others who net the rivers, maybe the OP should have realized
that before posting."


I did realise that before posting, however, people where I live do not
mind netting of rivers. I really don't care what someone across the
atlantic's opinion of gill netting is. BTW, it shows you don't have a
mature attitude when you laugh at someone's idea. I don't intend to
email someone like you. Go do some metal detecting.


I never stated there was anything wrong with gillnetting, I may have
hinted that your ethics of gillnetting any river for personal gain is
definitely out of balance and nonsporting or perhaps I was just telling
you what happens in my neck of the woods. If you don't care for
opinions of your actions from people across the Atlantic then post to
some local group who's sporting ethics are the same as yours, just like
the people you say who do not mind netting of rivers. I'm sure I
wouldn't laugh at your idea if your idea was mature, which it is not. I
do have a suggestion, catch only your share of the salmon and not
everyone elses.

Terry
--
Crayfishing Made Easy
World's Leader in Crayfish Traps
Everyone Is Doing It. Are You?
http://www.terrybullard.com/CrawfishMain.html



All times are GMT +1. The time now is 08:13 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2006 FishingBanter