FishingBanter

FishingBanter (http://www.fishingbanter.com/index.php)
-   Fly Fishing (http://www.fishingbanter.com/forumdisplay.php?f=6)
-   -   OT Muir journal collection digitized (http://www.fishingbanter.com/showthread.php?t=29807)

[email protected] November 30th, 2007 03:01 PM

OT Muir journal collection digitized
 
For those of you who enjoy such things:

The library of the University of the Pacific has some fantastic
digitized items from their special collections. In particular, I'd
like to point out their large collection of John Muir's journals and
sketches and photographs of Muir. Having looked through a small
portion of what they have made available, there is some fascinating
stuff. I looked through his notes from his stay in the Toulomne
meadows area of Yosemite, page after page of his notes and sketches.

In addition, they have a collection of Dave Brubeck items (oral
histories and photographs) and a very interesting collection of
primary materials relating to the WWII era Japanese-American
internment camps.

So if you are so inclined and have some time to spare, here is the
link.

http://library.pacific.edu/ha/digital/index.asp

Cheers,
Bill

Tom Nakashima November 30th, 2007 03:19 PM

OT Muir journal collection digitized
 

wrote in message
...
For those of you who enjoy such things:

The library of the University of the Pacific has some fantastic
digitized items from their special collections. In particular, I'd
like to point out their large collection of John Muir's journals and
sketches and photographs of Muir. Having looked through a small
portion of what they have made available, there is some fascinating
stuff. I looked through his notes from his stay in the Toulomne
meadows area of Yosemite, page after page of his notes and sketches.

In addition, they have a collection of Dave Brubeck items (oral
histories and photographs) and a very interesting collection of
primary materials relating to the WWII era Japanese-American
internment camps.

So if you are so inclined and have some time to spare, here is the
link.

http://library.pacific.edu/ha/digital/index.asp

Cheers,
Bill


Excellent, good stuff!
I was just looking over the Japanese-American interment camp collections.
Interesting letters and stories.
My Dad was put in Manzanar (CA) and my Mom was located to the Heart
Mountain (WY) relocation center during the war. They were teenagers at the
time so it was a lot of fun to them, but my grandparents too it pretty hard.

Big fan of Brubeck, I'll have to look over his section when I have more
time.

Also spent a lot of time in Yosemite and the Muir trails, sounds like an
interesting read of his journals.
-tom



Dave LaCourse November 30th, 2007 04:28 PM

OT Muir journal collection digitized
 
On Fri, 30 Nov 2007 07:01:38 -0800 (PST), wrote:

In addition, they have a collection of Dave Brubeck items (oral
histories and photographs)


Thanks for that, Bill. Very interesting. I've listened to two and
will find time to listen to the rest. A great man. A great composer
and musician.

Dave


Wolfgang November 30th, 2007 05:06 PM

OT Muir journal collection digitized
 

wrote in message
...
For those of you who enjoy such things:

The library of the University of the Pacific has some fantastic
digitized items from their special collections. In particular, I'd
like to point out their large collection of John Muir's journals and
sketches and photographs of Muir. Having looked through a small
portion of what they have made available, there is some fascinating
stuff. I looked through his notes from his stay in the Toulomne
meadows area of Yosemite, page after page of his notes and sketches.

In addition, they have a collection of Dave Brubeck items (oral
histories and photographs) and a very interesting collection of
primary materials relating to the WWII era Japanese-American
internment camps.

So if you are so inclined and have some time to spare, here is the
link.

http://library.pacific.edu/ha/digital/index.asp


Cool stuff, Bill. Thanks.

Wolfgang



Larry L November 30th, 2007 05:37 PM

OT Muir journal collection digitized
 

wrote

So if you are so inclined and have some time to spare, here is the
link.

http://library.pacific.edu/ha/digital/index.asp

Cheers,
Bill



UOP also has my kid as a student ... I consider THAT to be their high point
G



Tim J. November 30th, 2007 06:07 PM

OT Muir journal collection digitized
 
Tom Nakashima typed:
wrote in message
...
For those of you who enjoy such things:

The library of the University of the Pacific has some fantastic
digitized items from their special collections. In particular, I'd
like to point out their large collection of John Muir's journals and
sketches and photographs of Muir. Having looked through a small
portion of what they have made available, there is some fascinating
stuff. I looked through his notes from his stay in the Toulomne
meadows area of Yosemite, page after page of his notes and sketches.

In addition, they have a collection of Dave Brubeck items (oral
histories and photographs) and a very interesting collection of
primary materials relating to the WWII era Japanese-American
internment camps.

So if you are so inclined and have some time to spare, here is the
link.

http://library.pacific.edu/ha/digital/index.asp


Cool, Bill - thanks.

Excellent, good stuff!
I was just looking over the Japanese-American interment camp
collections. Interesting letters and stories.
My Dad was put in Manzanar (CA) and my Mom was located to the Heart
Mountain (WY) relocation center during the war. They were teenagers
at the time so it was a lot of fun to them, but my grandparents too
it pretty hard.


I think Bill has seen this before, but I never made it public. My wife's
great uncle (Durham White Stevens) was an ambassador to Japan during the
Russo-Japanese War and ended up with some pretty incredible artifacts,
including these propaganda posters. Unfortunately, he was also later made
ambassador to Korea during the time that Japan was attempting to annex
Korea, and was assasinated in San Francisco by some Korean nationists who
felt he was still loyal to the Japanese.

http://css.sbcma.com/timj/Russo-Japanese-Posters/

.. . . and, no, I have no idea about what the messages state on the posters.
I also have no idea what any of this has to do with Bill or Tom's posts, but
this is where the train of thought took me. :)
--
TL,
Tim
-------------------------
http://css.sbcma.com/timj



Tom Nakashima November 30th, 2007 06:24 PM

OT Muir journal collection digitized
 

"Tim J." wrote in message
...

I think Bill has seen this before, but I never made it public. My wife's
great uncle (Durham White Stevens) was an ambassador to Japan during the
Russo-Japanese War and ended up with some pretty incredible artifacts,
including these propaganda posters. Unfortunately, he was also later made
ambassador to Korea during the time that Japan was attempting to annex
Korea, and was assasinated in San Francisco by some Korean nationists who
felt he was still loyal to the Japanese.

http://css.sbcma.com/timj/Russo-Japanese-Posters/

. . . and, no, I have no idea about what the messages state on the
posters. I also have no idea what any of this has to do with Bill or Tom's
posts, but this is where the train of thought took me. :)
Tim



Quite an interesting story about the assassination of Durham White Stevens;
http://www.koreanamericanheritage.com/kna.htm
-tom



Tim J. November 30th, 2007 07:16 PM

OT Muir journal collection digitized
 
Tom Nakashima typed:
"Tim J." wrote in message
...

I think Bill has seen this before, but I never made it public. My
wife's great uncle (Durham White Stevens) was an ambassador to Japan
during the Russo-Japanese War and ended up with some pretty
incredible artifacts, including these propaganda posters.
Unfortunately, he was also later made ambassador to Korea during the
time that Japan was attempting to annex Korea, and was assasinated
in San Francisco by some Korean nationists who felt he was still
loyal to the Japanese. http://css.sbcma.com/timj/Russo-Japanese-Posters/

. . . and, no, I have no idea about what the messages state on the
posters. I also have no idea what any of this has to do with Bill or
Tom's posts, but this is where the train of thought took me. :)
Tim



Quite an interesting story about the assassination of Durham White
Stevens; http://www.koreanamericanheritage.com/kna.htm


Yeah, I've read that version, which, of course, could be just slightly
slanted to the Korean POV. That said, it's about the only history on the man
I could find online. I guess I'll have to break down and go to ugh! *the
library*. Oh, well. That'll give me a good reason to visit Boston on one of
these cold winter days. I mean, how expensive could it be to park in Boston,
anyway . . . ;-)
--
TL,
Tim
-------------------------
http://css.sbcma.com/timj



Wolfgang November 30th, 2007 07:23 PM

OT Muir journal collection digitized
 

"Tim J." wrote in message
...

I guess I'll have to break down and go to ugh! *the library*.


Uh oh.

Wolfgang
well, so much for the warm and fuzzy mood that has hovered over this place
for so long.



Tom Nakashima November 30th, 2007 07:30 PM

OT Muir journal collection digitized
 

"Tim J." wrote in message
...
.. I guess I'll have to break down and go to ugh! *the
library*. Oh, well. That'll give me a good reason to visit Boston on one
of these cold winter days. I mean, how expensive could it be to park in
Boston, anyway . . . ;-)
Tim


Wear your hoddie and you could probably get library valet.
-tom



Tim J. November 30th, 2007 07:47 PM

OT Muir journal collection digitized
 
Wolfgang typed:
"Tim J." wrote in message
...

I guess I'll have to break down and go to ugh! *the library*.


Uh oh.

Wolfgang
well, so much for the warm and fuzzy mood that has hovered over this
place for so long.


Actually, (and I really hate to say this) the main Boston Public Library is
awesome. If you visit Boston, it's one of the "must see" stops, IMO.
--
TL,
Tim
-------------------------
http://css.sbcma.com/timj



Frank Reid[_2_] November 30th, 2007 08:11 PM

OT Muir journal collection digitized
 
Quite an interesting story about the assassination of Durham White
Stevens;http://www.koreanamericanheritage.com/kna.htm


Yeah, I've read that version, which, of course, could be just slightly
slanted to the Korean POV. That said, it's about the only history on the man
I could find online. I guess I'll have to break down and go to ugh! *the
library*. Oh, well. That'll give me a good reason to visit Boston on one of
these cold winter days. I mean, how expensive could it be to park in Boston,
anyway . . . ;-)


Go to Google Scholar and type in "Durham White Stevens" (remember the
quotation marks). There's about twelve more references to him there.
Probably would find more with some differing search strings.
Frank Reid

Wolfgang November 30th, 2007 08:12 PM

OT Muir journal collection digitized
 

"Tim J." wrote in message
...
Wolfgang typed:
"Tim J." wrote in message
...

I guess I'll have to break down and go to ugh! *the library*.


Uh oh.

Wolfgang
well, so much for the warm and fuzzy mood that has hovered over this
place for so long.


Actually, (and I really hate to say this) the main Boston Public Library
is awesome. If you visit Boston, it's one of the "must see" stops, IMO.


Smooth.....very smooth recovery. :)

Let's just hope it was in time to forestall the launch of M-LIST.*

If I ever get there, I'll be sure to stop in.

Wolfgang
*multiple librarian impelled sharp things. :(



Tim J. November 30th, 2007 10:00 PM

OT Muir journal collection digitized
 
Wolfgang typed:
"Tim J." wrote in message
...
Wolfgang typed:
"Tim J." wrote in message
...

I guess I'll have to break down and go to ugh! *the library*.

Uh oh.

Wolfgang
well, so much for the warm and fuzzy mood that has hovered over this
place for so long.


Actually, (and I really hate to say this) the main Boston Public
Library is awesome. If you visit Boston, it's one of the "must see"
stops, IMO.


Smooth.....very smooth recovery.


Well, okay - if you say so. However, my keyboard is soaking wet from the
sweat dripping from my brow.

Seriously, that's one of the nicest libraries I've ever seen (all two of
'em.) The reading room is spectacular. Now, if I could just learn to read.
Oh, well. They have nice pitures in some of them books. %-)
--
TL,
Tim
-------------------------
http://css.sbcma.com/timj



Tim J. November 30th, 2007 10:01 PM

OT Muir journal collection digitized
 
Frank Reid typed:
Quite an interesting story about the assassination of Durham White
Stevens;http://www.koreanamericanheritage.com/kna.htm


Yeah, I've read that version, which, of course, could be just
slightly slanted to the Korean POV. That said, it's about the only
history on the man I could find online. I guess I'll have to break
down and go to ugh! *the library*. Oh, well. That'll give me a
good reason to visit Boston on one of these cold winter days. I
mean, how expensive could it be to park in Boston, anyway . . . ;-)


Go to Google Scholar and type in "Durham White Stevens" (remember the
quotation marks). There's about twelve more references to him there.
Probably would find more with some differing search strings.
Frank Reid


WooooHOOOO! We don't need no steenkin libraries!
--
TL,
Tim
-------------------------
http://css.sbcma.com/timj



Frank Reid[_2_] December 1st, 2007 04:47 AM

OT Muir journal collection digitized
 
Yeah, I've read that version, which, of course, could be just
slightly slanted to the Korean POV. That said, it's about the only
history on the man I could find online. I guess I'll have to break
down and go to ugh! *the library*. Oh, well. That'll give me a
good reason to visit Boston on one of these cold winter days. I
mean, how expensive could it be to park in Boston, anyway . . . ;-)


Go to Google Scholar and type in "Durham White Stevens" (remember the
quotation marks). There's about twelve more references to him there.
Probably would find more with some differing search strings.
Frank Reid


WooooHOOOO! We don't need no steenkin libraries!


Got my masters degree without setting foot in the library (well, did
have to use their copy machine).
Frank Reid

[email protected] December 1st, 2007 01:49 PM

OT Muir journal collection digitized
 
On Nov 30, 5:01 pm, "Tim J."
wrote:
Frank Reid typed:


Go to Google Scholar and type in "Durham White Stevens" (remember the
quotation marks). There's about twelve more references to him there.
Probably would find more with some differing search strings.
Frank Reid


WooooHOOOO! We don't need no steenkin libraries!


Google Scholar (and ...Books, do the same search there, Tim) are sweet
finding aids.

But note that most of the links to those items you find on Scholar
lead to licensed content (JSTOR, copyrighted books). Want to read
'em? Head for the library! Same with Google Books, you'll get
tantalizing tidbits ("snippets" I believe is the term they use) of
many books that have copyright but for the whole shebang, we've
already bought the book for you, just come on in. Google Books has a
link that says "find it in a library" to help you figure out which of
my brethren will loan it to you. We've already paid for this stuff
for you, all you have to do is ask and we'll get it to you!

I know you know most of this but I just couldn't help but rise to the
bait.

As to Frank not stepping foot inside the library while studying for
his masters, well, there's a story behind that. He was banned. We
couldn't afford the insurance. :-)

Bill

[email protected] December 1st, 2007 01:52 PM

OT Muir journal collection digitized
 
On Nov 30, 12:37 pm, "Larry L" wrote:
wrote



So if you are so inclined and have some time to spare, here is the
link.


http://library.pacific.edu/ha/digital/index.asp


Cheers,
Bill


UOP also has my kid as a student ... I consider THAT to be their high point
G


Lucky kid! UOP appears to have an excellent library. At our place,
we get far too many students who make the odd boast of never having
set foot in the library for four years. I hope your kid takes
advantage of the riches at the UOP libraries! Those special
collections librarians would probably love it if he/she came to see
them and asked to see the Muir journals!

Bill

Willi December 1st, 2007 04:24 PM

OT Muir journal collection digitized
 
When is everything at a library going to be digitized and available to
patrons online?

Our libraries in Colorado have made a bit of progress in this regard,
they have a good selection of audio books available (2000+ titles) for
download with a time limit and copy protection. I think is great. You
download the book and transfer it to a MP3 player (but not an IPOD) or
listen to it on your computer for a two week period.

There are also some ebooks available, but they are very limited.
Personally, what I'd especially like to see are the online availability
of scientific journals.

Willi

rw December 1st, 2007 04:42 PM

OT Muir journal collection digitized
 
Willi wrote:
When is everything at a library going to be digitized and available to
patrons online?


Google is trying to do this, not just for one library but for *everything*:

http://books.google.com/googlebooks/library.html

What's causing them problems is copyright.

Our libraries in Colorado have made a bit of progress in this regard,
they have a good selection of audio books available (2000+ titles) for
download with a time limit and copy protection. I think is great. You
download the book and transfer it to a MP3 player (but not an IPOD) or
listen to it on your computer for a two week period.

There are also some ebooks available, but they are very limited.
Personally, what I'd especially like to see are the online availability
of scientific journals.


A lot of scientific journals are online, but you have to pay. For
example, look at http://prl.aps.org/.

Scientists were among the first to take advantage of the Web by making
preprints available, and these are typically free. For example,
http://arxiv.org/. The main reason they do this is that it takes so long
to get a paper published in journal form. Printed scientific journals
are nearly obsolete -- very expensive and out-of-date.

--
Cut "to the chase" for my email address.

Willi December 1st, 2007 05:06 PM

OT Muir journal collection digitized
 
rw wrote:
Willi wrote:

When is everything at a library going to be digitized and available to
patrons online?



Google is trying to do this, not just for one library but for *everything*:

http://books.google.com/googlebooks/library.html

What's causing them problems is copyright.



I don't see how this is different from borrowing books from the library
if they are "loaned" online with copy protection and time limits.

Willi

rw December 1st, 2007 05:20 PM

OT Muir journal collection digitized
 
Willi wrote:
rw wrote:

Willi wrote:

When is everything at a library going to be digitized and available
to patrons online?




Google is trying to do this, not just for one library but for
*everything*:

http://books.google.com/googlebooks/library.html

What's causing them problems is copyright.




I don't see how this is different from borrowing books from the library
if they are "loaned" online with copy protection and time limits.

Willi


I don't think publishers particularly like lending libraries, nor do
they like used book sales. They want a way to monetize their content.

--
Cut "to the chase" for my email address.

~^ beancounter ~^ December 1st, 2007 06:34 PM

OT Muir journal collection digitized
 
nice......



On Nov 30, 10:06 am, "Wolfgang" wrote:
wrote in message

...





For those of you who enjoy such things:


The library of the University of the Pacific has some fantastic
digitized items from their special collections. In particular, I'd
like to point out their large collection of John Muir's journals and
sketches and photographs of Muir. Having looked through a small
portion of what they have made available, there is some fascinating
stuff. I looked through his notes from his stay in the Toulomne
meadows area of Yosemite, page after page of his notes and sketches.


In addition, they have a collection of Dave Brubeck items (oral
histories and photographs) and a very interesting collection of
primary materials relating to the WWII era Japanese-American
internment camps.


So if you are so inclined and have some time to spare, here is the
link.


http://library.pacific.edu/ha/digital/index.asp


Cool stuff, Bill. Thanks.

Wolfgang- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -



Opus--Mark H. Bowen December 1st, 2007 10:09 PM

OT Muir journal collection digitized
 

"Tim J." wrote in message
...
I think Bill has seen this before, but I never made it public. My wife's
great uncle (Durham White Stevens) was an ambassador to Japan during the
Russo-Japanese War and ended up with some pretty incredible artifacts,
including these propaganda posters. Unfortunately, he was also later made
ambassador to Korea during the time that Japan was attempting to annex
Korea, and was assasinated in San Francisco by some Korean nationists who
felt he was still loyal to the Japanese.

http://css.sbcma.com/timj/Russo-Japanese-Posters/

. . . and, no, I have no idea about what the messages state on the
posters. I also have no idea what any of this has to do with Bill or Tom's
posts, but this is where the train of thought took me. :)
--
TL,
Tim


Tim,
I saw a PBS "Antiques Roadshow" the other week where a woman had a slew--400
or more-- of "English" langauge Japanese propaganda posters. The roadshow
guy estimated them in the thousands of dollars, even though he had never
seen anything like them before--IIRCC.

Op



Tim Lysyk December 2nd, 2007 04:45 AM

OT Muir journal collection digitized
 
Willi wrote:
When is everything at a library going to be digitized and available to
patrons online?

Our libraries in Colorado have made a bit of progress in this regard,
they have a good selection of audio books available (2000+ titles) for
download with a time limit and copy protection. I think is great. You
download the book and transfer it to a MP3 player (but not an IPOD) or
listen to it on your computer for a two week period.

There are also some ebooks available, but they are very limited.
Personally, what I'd especially like to see are the online availability
of scientific journals.

Willi


Hi Willi:

A lot scientific journals are available online. The series I publish in,
is, and can be found at http://esa.publisher.ingentaconnect.com/content/esa

The rub is that full access is available only to members. The general
public can usually get access to the abstract. Many authors, myself
included, will pay to have a free pdf file than anyone can download.

Also, the article only go back to about 1999. Anything older will likely
be in print, not pdf. We are working on changing that, however, but it
takes time and money to do. There are a number of services, like JSTOR
that have archives scientific journals.

There are more and more open journals, meaning they allow full access to
anyone. I haven't published in any yet, but am considering.

Tim Lysyk

[email protected] December 2nd, 2007 01:59 PM

OT Muir journal collection digitized
 
On Dec 1, 11:24 am, Willi wrote:
When is everything at a library going to be digitized and available to
patrons online?


Everything? Never. See this excellent article (online! :-) by
Anthony Grafton from a recent New Yorker:

http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2...a_fact_grafton

(he also has an online-only selection of his favorite web resources
he

http://www.newyorker.com/online/2007...neonly_grafton)

I usually shy away from words like "never" but even Google hasn't (and
probably won't) put a dent in digitizing the printed record, let alone
keep up with what is currently published (and "published"). Let alone
usefully make it available. (I do, however, think Google Books is a
pretty cool idea.)

Our libraries in Colorado have made a bit of progress in this regard,
they have a good selection of audio books available (2000+ titles) for
download with a time limit and copy protection. I think is great. You
download the book and transfer it to a MP3 player (but not an IPOD) or
listen to it on your computer for a two week period.


DRM at work. They don't work on iPods because they use Windows DRM.
I've never actually used any of those from my public library because
the restrictions are just so foolish.

There are also some ebooks available, but they are very limited.
Personally, what I'd especially like to see are the online availability
of scientific journals.


Most are, including deep archives, but if you mean "online
availability of scientific journals from my living room" then the
answer is economics won't allow it, at least not now. Tim has pointed
out some of the issues. You should be able to access many online if
you darken the doorway of the library at Colorado State. We see
independent researchers at our place every day.

Bill


Willi December 2nd, 2007 04:04 PM

OT Muir journal collection digitized
 
wrote:
On Dec 1, 11:24 am, Willi wrote:

When is everything at a library going to be digitized and available to
patrons online?



Everything? Never. See this excellent article (online! :-) by
Anthony Grafton from a recent New Yorker:

http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2...a_fact_grafton

(he also has an online-only selection of his favorite web resources
he

http://www.newyorker.com/online/2007...neonly_grafton)

I usually shy away from words like "never" but even Google hasn't (and
probably won't) put a dent in digitizing the printed record, let alone
keep up with what is currently published (and "published"). Let alone
usefully make it available. (I do, however, think Google Books is a
pretty cool idea.)


When I said "everything", I didn't mean EVERYTHING. I understand the
immensity of digitizing all the printed books in the world, but it seems
to me that all new works could easily be made available in digital form.


It's a much easier task to create, hold and distribute an electronic
copy, than print, house and distribute a printed book. Today "all"
books/articles etc. are written on a computer and are already in some
digital format of one type or another. Converting them into a PDF or
some other adopted standard would be extremely easy. It would be far
easier and cheaper to maintain and distribute digital information than
maintaining a brick library or if held by a brick and mortar library, it
could be done with little extra cost.



DRM at work. They don't work on iPods because they use Windows DRM.
I've never actually used any of those from my public library because
the restrictions are just so foolish.



(I understand DRM. My comment was a just dig at IPODS, and Microsoft)
Maybe the specific protection scheme is cumbersome, but I don't
understand why you think it is foolish. It is a system for information
that is covered by copywrite. You don't own the information you
download, you just "borrow" it, like you do now when you check out a
book at a library.


I figure it's resistance from authors, publishers etc that keeps this
from happening. The music industry, with alot of kicking and screaming,
has made/is making this transition. IMO, this change has expanded the
variety of music available instead of relying on "the industry" to pick,
not the best music, but the music they feel will make them the most
money. I think it's a logical step for the "printed" word. The only
reason that this change hasn't been "forced" by the public (like it was
with music) is that there isn't YET a way to read these digitized words
that is as easy and satisfying as using printed media.


That's how I look at it but I'm sure I'm missing some salient points.

Willi

Willi December 2nd, 2007 04:28 PM

OT Muir journal collection digitized
 
wrote:

Most are, including deep archives, but if you mean "online
availability of scientific journals from my living room" then the
answer is economics won't allow it, at least not now. Tim has pointed
out some of the issues. You should be able to access many online if
you darken the doorway of the library at Colorado State. We see
independent researchers at our place every day.



But why should I have to go there?

I would think that it costs more for a library to offer the physical
facilities and equipment to provide online access to the journals at the
library than it would to provide it for home use.

What am I missing here?

Willi

rw December 2nd, 2007 05:53 PM

OT Muir journal collection digitized
 
Willi wrote:

I figure it's resistance from authors, publishers etc that keeps this
from happening. The music industry, with alot of kicking and screaming,
has made/is making this transition. IMO, this change has expanded the
variety of music available instead of relying on "the industry" to pick,
not the best music, but the music they feel will make them the most
money. I think it's a logical step for the "printed" word. The only
reason that this change hasn't been "forced" by the public (like it was
with music) is that there isn't YET a way to read these digitized words
that is as easy and satisfying as using printed media.


That's how I look at it but I'm sure I'm missing some salient points.


Publishers and authors in all the various media are always suspicious
and fearful of change, and for good reason. It threatens to dilute the
value of their intellectual property. Whether they're justified in these
fears or not, the fact is that their interests as producers and owners
of content aren't congruent with your interests as a consumer of content.

--
Cut "to the chase" for my email address.

Wolfgang December 3rd, 2007 02:03 PM

OT Muir journal collection digitized
 

"Willi" wrote in message
...
wrote:

Most are, including deep archives, but if you mean "online
availability of scientific journals from my living room" then the
answer is economics won't allow it, at least not now. Tim has pointed
out some of the issues. You should be able to access many online if
you darken the doorway of the library at Colorado State. We see
independent researchers at our place every day.



But why should I have to go there?

I would think that it costs more for a library to offer the physical
facilities and equipment to provide online access to the journals at the
library than it would to provide it for home use.

What am I missing here?


Control issues. There is a lot of money at stake here. E-texts are, by
their very nature, easier to copy, reproduce, and distribute than old
fashioned printed materials. Anybody with a computer can do it.

Wolfgang



[email protected] December 3rd, 2007 02:11 PM

OT Muir journal collection digitized
 
On Sun, 2 Dec 2007 05:59:32 -0800 (PST), wrote:

On Dec 1, 11:24 am, Willi wrote:
When is everything at a library going to be digitized and available to
patrons online?


Everything? Never. See this excellent article (online! :-) by
Anthony Grafton from a recent New Yorker:

http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2...a_fact_grafton

(he also has an online-only selection of his favorite web resources
he

http://www.newyorker.com/online/2007...neonly_grafton)

I usually shy away from words like "never" but even Google hasn't (and
probably won't) put a dent in digitizing the printed record, let alone
keep up with what is currently published (and "published"). Let alone
usefully make it available. (I do, however, think Google Books is a
pretty cool idea.)


How close do you think it'll come, including legal and extra-legal
scanning and "ebooking?" It would seem that between it all (Project
Gutenberg, the Carnegie Mellon thing, Athens, JSTOR, Knovel,
Thompson/Gale, ebookers, etc.) there is already a fair amount of books,
manuals, articles, etc., plus with libraries scanning their "papers"
collections, there is a growing pile of stuff in electronic form now.
I'd offer that the biggest problem might be creating a central catalog
to it all and figuring out how to add the extra-legal stuff, but ???

TC,
R

Our libraries in Colorado have made a bit of progress in this regard,
they have a good selection of audio books available (2000+ titles) for
download with a time limit and copy protection. I think is great. You
download the book and transfer it to a MP3 player (but not an IPOD) or
listen to it on your computer for a two week period.


DRM at work. They don't work on iPods because they use Windows DRM.
I've never actually used any of those from my public library because
the restrictions are just so foolish.

There are also some ebooks available, but they are very limited.
Personally, what I'd especially like to see are the online availability
of scientific journals.


Most are, including deep archives, but if you mean "online
availability of scientific journals from my living room" then the
answer is economics won't allow it, at least not now. Tim has pointed
out some of the issues. You should be able to access many online if
you darken the doorway of the library at Colorado State. We see
independent researchers at our place every day.

Bill


Wolfgang December 3rd, 2007 02:20 PM

OT Muir journal collection digitized
 

"Willi" wrote in message
...
wrote:
On Dec 1, 11:24 am, Willi wrote:

When is everything at a library going to be digitized and available to
patrons online?



Everything? Never. See this excellent article (online! :-) by
Anthony Grafton from a recent New Yorker:

http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2...a_fact_grafton

(he also has an online-only selection of his favorite web resources
he

http://www.newyorker.com/online/2007...neonly_grafton)

I usually shy away from words like "never" but even Google hasn't (and
probably won't) put a dent in digitizing the printed record, let alone
keep up with what is currently published (and "published"). Let alone
usefully make it available. (I do, however, think Google Books is a
pretty cool idea.)


When I said "everything", I didn't mean EVERYTHING....


Right, not EVERYTHING, but there is already a stupefying quantity of free
stuff available. The trouble is cataloguing......finding what you're
interested in. There is no single comprehensive source of information on
what's available......or, none that I'm aware of, anyway. However, there
are a number of GOOD sources. Among the best I've found a

The Internet Public Library;

http://www.ipl.org/

The Online Books Page;

http://onlinebooks.library.upenn.edu/

and The Internet Archive;

http://www.archive.org/index.php

All three of these will direct you to other sources. There are many of them
out there. I have links to 50 or 60 (most of which I rarely check because
of their limited scope) that I'll be happy to send to anyone interested, but
it's easy enough to search them (and countless others) out via Google.

Wolfgang




[email protected] December 3rd, 2007 02:34 PM

OT Muir journal collection digitized
 
On Dec 2, 11:28 am, Willi wrote:
wrote:
Most are, including deep archives, but if you mean "online
availability of scientific journals from my living room" then the
answer is economics won't allow it, at least not now. Tim has pointed
out some of the issues. You should be able to access many online if
you darken the doorway of the library at Colorado State. We see
independent researchers at our place every day.


But why should I have to go there?

I would think that it costs more for a library to offer the physical
facilities and equipment to provide online access to the journals at the
library than it would to provide it for home use.

What am I missing here?


This is where the economics comes in.

Colorado State, as with all academic/research libraries spends a lot
of dollars (a LOT) to procure access to the online versions of
research journals. And to the indexing tools that provide researchers
the interface they need to find the bits from within these journals
that they need for their work. Most content providers have licensing
agreements that libraries sign when they purchase these collections
(or when they purchase the right to access these collections.) These
agreements- some more strict than others- usually allow access to the
content by university (or licensee) affiliated users. So to access
the content from home, users have to authenticate. So the CSU grad
student or professor who lives next door to you can access the good
stuff from his living room, while you (and I'm assuming you are not
CSU affiliated here) cannot.

Most (not all) agreements state that walk-in library users are allowed
to access content regardless of affiliation, which is why I mentioned
it to you as a possibility. And I'm primarily talking about
scientific content, since that is what I assume you are interested
in. The Knovels, IEEExplores, Nature, ACS, Elseviers out there (and
for non-sciences, JSTOR, Proquest, Gale, etc.) are dedicated to
providing online access to historic and current content, but they also
have a vested economic interest as well and I can tell you that big
dollars change hands!

Note that there are major public library systems that are providing
more and more access to this kind (online, remote access) of content
as well, akin to the e-books you've already noticed. I wouldn't hold
your breath for them to give you access to Nature any time soon
though :-)

I know that you are probably thinking "yes, but tax dollars go to the
NSF and the NIH which pays for the research, so I should have access
to the results" and/or "Colorado State is a public institution so I
should have access to the materials to which they subscribe" and I'll
nod and smile and won't be able to explain why the answer is, simply,
"sorry!"

Cheers!
Bill

[email protected] December 3rd, 2007 02:40 PM

OT Muir journal collection digitized
 
On Dec 2, 11:04 am, Willi wrote:
wrote:


DRM at work. They don't work on iPods because they use Windows DRM.
I've never actually used any of those from my public library because
the restrictions are just so foolish.


(I understand DRM. My comment was a just dig at IPODS, and Microsoft)
Maybe the specific protection scheme is cumbersome, but I don't
understand why you think it is foolish. It is a system for information
that is covered by copywrite. You don't own the information you
download, you just "borrow" it, like you do now when you check out a
book at a library.


(Copyright)

Foolish was a hasty choice of adjective. I like your "cumbersome"
much better, and in my case also a dig at Microsoft, and as a Windows
resistant Mac user, I bristle when I see content that is labeled
"Windows only." Yeh, I know I can run Windows on my MacBook, I just
don't want to.

Bill


[email protected] December 3rd, 2007 03:00 PM

OT Muir journal collection digitized
 
On Dec 3, 9:11 am, wrote:
On Sun, 2 Dec 2007 05:59:32 -0800 (PST), wrote:
On Dec 1, 11:24 am, Willi wrote:
When is everything at a library going to be digitized and available to
patrons online?


Everything? Never. See this excellent article (online! :-) by
Anthony Grafton from a recent New Yorker:


http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2...a_fact_grafton


(he also has an online-only selection of his favorite web resources
he


http://www.newyorker.com/online/2007...neonly_grafton)


I usually shy away from words like "never" but even Google hasn't (and
probably won't) put a dent in digitizing the printed record, let alone
keep up with what is currently published (and "published"). Let alone
usefully make it available. (I do, however, think Google Books is a
pretty cool idea.)


How close do you think it'll come, including legal and extra-legal
scanning and "ebooking?" It would seem that between it all (Project
Gutenberg, the Carnegie Mellon thing, Athens, JSTOR, Knovel,
Thompson/Gale, ebookers, etc.) there is already a fair amount of books,
manuals, articles, etc., plus with libraries scanning their "papers"
collections, there is a growing pile of stuff in electronic form now.
I'd offer that the biggest problem might be creating a central catalog
to it all and figuring out how to add the extra-legal stuff, but ???


This is where it gets tricky, and I'll point you again to the Grafton
article. He says it way more eloquently than I can. In particular,
if you start looking at the notion of a universal library of
EVERYTHING, things get dicey. Grafton points out that the U.S.
National Archives alone has approximately 9 billion items. That's a
lot of scanning. Or that in the Google Library project, they are
scanning 1 million books from the NYPL- that is a drop in the
proverbial bucket compared to the NYPL's total holdings. And as you
hint at, the problem isn't just the scanning- consider the work that
goes into creating a useful, searchable collection of materials.

Have a peek, for example, at the nice work the UOP library folks did
on that Muir collection- each page is indexed and tagged. That takes
some time, and expertise! And sure, its easy to say "well, of course
you'd take the time and effort for Muir" but who draws the line on
what is important and what is not? Perhaps one day Settlesworth's
morning notes to his employer will be deemed equally important!

I'll also point out that of the providers you mention above, at least
three of them are subscription-based.

How close to "everything" will we get? Hard to say. But I hope that
despite the embarrassment of riches provided by the likes of Google
Books and so on (and quite seriously, the amount of information- and
maybe even knowledge!- that is available freely to those with online
access is MUCH larger now than it ever has been), that folks don't
think "I'm searching EVERYTHING!" Because they aren't. Not that
being exhaustive is always the goal, but still...

Bill
(see, I told you, push the right button and I can go on, and on, and
on.... :-)

Tom Nakashima December 3rd, 2007 03:17 PM

OT Muir journal collection digitized
 

"Opus--Mark H. Bowen" wrote in message
...

I saw a PBS "Antiques Roadshow" the other week where a woman had a
slew--400 or more-- of "English" langauge Japanese propaganda posters.
The roadshow guy estimated them in the thousands of dollars, even though
he had never seen anything like them before--IIRCC.
Op


I'm not amazed at the popularity of antiques.
In the early 90's my mom wanted a garage sale before they moved.
I guess they needed to lighten their load, sort of clean house. It was our
very first garage sale, so a few days before I advertised in the local
newspaper as 1st garage sale in 50 years. I also listed a few items, many
from the Japanese Interment Camp. Gave the address and the starting time of
9:00am that Saturday morning.

As it turned out, we had people knocking on our door before Saturday wanting
to view items we had. I finally had to put a note on our front door that the
sale will start 9am on Saturday, please do not bother us before then. That
morning, we had people camped out on our lawn at 5am. My Dad got up around
8am and said; "What the Hell's going on out there?" By then it looked like
we were throwing a rock concert. I guess one of the neighbors who didn't
know what was happening, called the police, and a good thing as the police
had to take control of the crowd.

I asked, "Hey Dad, is this what camp life was like?"
He just shook his head and said; "Don't sell any of my fishing gear!"
-tom






[email protected] December 3rd, 2007 03:25 PM

OT Muir journal collection digitized
 
On Dec 2, 11:04 am, Willi wrote:
wrote:


DRM at work. They don't work on iPods because they use Windows DRM.
I've never actually used any of those from my public library because
the restrictions are just so foolish.


(I understand DRM. My comment was a just dig at IPODS, and Microsoft)
Maybe the specific protection scheme is cumbersome, but I don't
understand why you think it is foolish. It is a system for information
that is covered by copywrite. You don't own the information you
download, you just "borrow" it, like you do now when you check out a
book at a library.


OK, I thought of an analogy. You rightly point out that you are
borrowing the e-book (or audiobook) when you download it, and that,
not unlike borrowing a book, you should not expect to keep the copy
indefinitely. However, when you check out a print book, do they only
check it out to you if you meet certain restrictions? Does the book
disappear if you keep it longer than x-number of weeks? Do they first
make sure you don't own a photocopier or scanner? This is what I was
thinking about when I used the term "foolish". And I think that
rather than fight these restrictions, libraries have given in to the
publishers who insist on the restrictions so that they (the library)
can provide a service- it may not be a perfect service, but it is a
service, one in which both the client and the vendor are getting
something.

I figure it's resistance from authors, publishers etc that keeps this
from happening. The music industry, with alot of kicking and screaming,
has made/is making this transition. IMO, this change has expanded the
variety of music available instead of relying on "the industry" to pick,
not the best music, but the music they feel will make them the most
money. I think it's a logical step for the "printed" word. The only
reason that this change hasn't been "forced" by the public (like it was
with music) is that there isn't YET a way to read these digitized words
that is as easy and satisfying as using printed media.


It will be interesting to see if anyone (eg. the new Kindle) can
breathe life into the e-book reader concept. That market has
floundered for as many years as it has been extant. Although I *do*
know a few people who actually prefer to read on a screen (and in
these cases [three people] the screen is a PDA.) Of course, here we
are talking about books that one would read, not reference materials
or short articles, etc.

I like how you used the word "satisfying". There is something
satisfying about the book as an item, and reading a book as a process,
is there not? However, I would wager that a very large percentage of
the books I have read over the past several years (and an even higher
percentage of articles), I "discovered" by some digital means (reviews
found and read online, through personal contacts made online, etc.)
Even Wolfgang's "Forgotten Treasures" I usually end up digging out the
original, rather than reading on the screen (or printing out.) We are
lucky, no?

Bill

Wolfgang December 3rd, 2007 04:38 PM

OT Muir journal collection digitized
 

wrote in message
...

...its easy to say "well, of course
you'd take the time and effort for Muir"....


Um......who dat?

Most people, or so it seems to me anyway, on hearing a faint bell ringing,
will either shake their heads until it goes away or turn up the volume to
drown it out. Here in southern Curdistan the name "Muir" crops up all over
the landscape.....not so surprisingly. References to eponymy (I've tried
this on the John Muir trail in the Kettle Moraine State forest about thirty
miles west of here) usually elicit blank stares.

You'd be amazed how easy it is to lead folks into a discussion of the role
played by Frank and Lloyd Wright in the development of heavier than air
flight. :)

Wolfgang
but then, references to eponymy, regardless of context, generally result in
something ranging from blank stares to outright belligerence.



[email protected] December 3rd, 2007 08:08 PM

OT Muir journal collection digitized
 
On Mon, 3 Dec 2007 06:34:55 -0800 (PST), wrote:

On Dec 2, 11:28 am, Willi wrote:
wrote:
Most are, including deep archives, but if you mean "online
availability of scientific journals from my living room" then the
answer is economics won't allow it, at least not now. Tim has pointed
out some of the issues. You should be able to access many online if
you darken the doorway of the library at Colorado State. We see
independent researchers at our place every day.


But why should I have to go there?

I would think that it costs more for a library to offer the physical
facilities and equipment to provide online access to the journals at the
library than it would to provide it for home use.

What am I missing here?


This is where the economics comes in.

Colorado State, as with all academic/research libraries spends a lot
of dollars (a LOT) to procure access to the online versions of
research journals. And to the indexing tools that provide researchers
the interface they need to find the bits from within these journals
that they need for their work. Most content providers have licensing
agreements that libraries sign when they purchase these collections
(or when they purchase the right to access these collections.) These
agreements- some more strict than others- usually allow access to the
content by university (or licensee) affiliated users. So to access
the content from home, users have to authenticate. So the CSU grad
student or professor who lives next door to you can access the good
stuff from his living room, while you (and I'm assuming you are not
CSU affiliated here) cannot.

Most (not all) agreements state that walk-in library users are allowed
to access content regardless of affiliation, which is why I mentioned
it to you as a possibility. And I'm primarily talking about
scientific content, since that is what I assume you are interested
in. The Knovels, IEEExplores, Nature, ACS, Elseviers out there (and
for non-sciences, JSTOR, Proquest, Gale, etc.) are dedicated to
providing online access to historic and current content, but they also
have a vested economic interest as well and I can tell you that big
dollars change hands!

Note that there are major public library systems that are providing
more and more access to this kind (online, remote access) of content
as well, akin to the e-books you've already noticed. I wouldn't hold
your breath for them to give you access to Nature any time soon
though :-)

I know that you are probably thinking "yes, but tax dollars go to the
NSF and the NIH which pays for the research, so I should have access
to the results" and/or "Colorado State is a public institution so I
should have access to the materials to which they subscribe" and I'll
nod and smile and won't be able to explain why the answer is, simply,
"sorry!"

Cheers!
Bill



And I haven't seen mention of the economics of scale and the "HOLY
****!" method of pricing (where the price is set ridiculously high and
is lowered a fraction at a time until buyers quit saying "HOLY....") in
"academic" materials.

Granted, the economics of scale argument is somewhat legit - if a
publisher knows that there is a finite and small market for such things
as a full-color-plated masterwork on the reproductive system of the
lower eastern Poontang Creek partially-blind snaildarting spotted owl
(there's supposedly 12 of them in the wild, and that's roughly twice the
number of folks who are interested in spending $597.45USD on Dr.
Pencilneck's treatise on them), then they've got to charge a rather
larger amount per copy than Tom Clancy's latest schlock. Then there is
the whole issue of library sales and what they pay.

OTOH, I know that much of the what is charged for such stuff is at least
partially due to the greatly over-inflated "monetary value" many
academics place on this stuff, and publishers are only happy to oblige
helping them rape each other of tax and "advancement" dollars, for the
standard vig, of course. I mean, in a real business model, most of the
"academic" papers would be on the on special offer, slow-moving stock
clearance area. This is not to say they aren't contextually-valuable to
a _VERY_ limited number of people, but in the new, electronic real
world, that dog won't hunt and until the folks that price this stuff
realizes that it's a lot better to sell 100 e-copies of a 30-page
article a year at $.50 then it is to sell 2 copies a millennium for $19,
the shocking prices carried over from print academia are likely to
continue.

TC,
R

Wolfgang December 3rd, 2007 08:50 PM

OT Muir journal collection digitized
 

wrote in message
...
On Mon, 3 Dec 2007 06:34:55 -0800 (PST), wrote:

On Dec 2, 11:28 am, Willi wrote:
wrote:
Most are, including deep archives, but if you mean "online
availability of scientific journals from my living room" then the
answer is economics won't allow it, at least not now. Tim has pointed
out some of the issues. You should be able to access many online if
you darken the doorway of the library at Colorado State. We see
independent researchers at our place every day.

But why should I have to go there?

I would think that it costs more for a library to offer the physical
facilities and equipment to provide online access to the journals at the
library than it would to provide it for home use.

What am I missing here?


This is where the economics comes in.

Colorado State, as with all academic/research libraries spends a lot
of dollars (a LOT) to procure access to the online versions of
research journals. And to the indexing tools that provide researchers
the interface they need to find the bits from within these journals
that they need for their work. Most content providers have licensing
agreements that libraries sign when they purchase these collections
(or when they purchase the right to access these collections.) These
agreements- some more strict than others- usually allow access to the
content by university (or licensee) affiliated users. So to access
the content from home, users have to authenticate. So the CSU grad
student or professor who lives next door to you can access the good
stuff from his living room, while you (and I'm assuming you are not
CSU affiliated here) cannot.

Most (not all) agreements state that walk-in library users are allowed
to access content regardless of affiliation, which is why I mentioned
it to you as a possibility. And I'm primarily talking about
scientific content, since that is what I assume you are interested
in. The Knovels, IEEExplores, Nature, ACS, Elseviers out there (and
for non-sciences, JSTOR, Proquest, Gale, etc.) are dedicated to
providing online access to historic and current content, but they also
have a vested economic interest as well and I can tell you that big
dollars change hands!

Note that there are major public library systems that are providing
more and more access to this kind (online, remote access) of content
as well, akin to the e-books you've already noticed. I wouldn't hold
your breath for them to give you access to Nature any time soon
though :-)

I know that you are probably thinking "yes, but tax dollars go to the
NSF and the NIH which pays for the research, so I should have access
to the results" and/or "Colorado State is a public institution so I
should have access to the materials to which they subscribe" and I'll
nod and smile and won't be able to explain why the answer is, simply,
"sorry!"

Cheers!
Bill



And I haven't seen mention of the economics of scale and the "HOLY
****!" method of pricing (where the price is set ridiculously high and
is lowered a fraction at a time until buyers quit saying "HOLY....") in
"academic" materials.

Granted, the economics of scale argument is somewhat legit - if a
publisher knows that there is a finite and small market for such things
as a full-color-plated masterwork on the reproductive system of the
lower eastern Poontang Creek partially-blind snaildarting spotted owl
(there's supposedly 12 of them in the wild, and that's roughly twice the
number of folks who are interested in spending $597.45USD on Dr.
Pencilneck's treatise on them), then they've got to charge a rather
larger amount per copy than Tom Clancy's latest schlock. Then there is
the whole issue of library sales and what they pay.

OTOH, I know that much of the what is charged for such stuff is at least
partially due to the greatly over-inflated "monetary value" many
academics place on this stuff, and publishers are only happy to oblige
helping them rape each other of tax and "advancement" dollars, for the
standard vig, of course. I mean, in a real business model, most of the
"academic" papers would be on the on special offer, slow-moving stock
clearance area. This is not to say they aren't contextually-valuable to
a _VERY_ limited number of people, but in the new, electronic real
world, that dog won't hunt and until the folks that price this stuff
realizes that it's a lot better to sell 100 e-copies of a 30-page
article a year at $.50 then it is to sell 2 copies a millennium for $19,
the shocking prices carried over from print academia are likely to
continue.


Uh huh. I see. O.k., now explain why it is that when the price of oil
skyrocketed up to about $50 a barrel I paid a measly $3.59 for a gallon of
gas, and recently, when the price of oil plummeted to a pitiful $100 per
barrel, I was raped to the tune of $2.83 for the gas.

Wolfgang
who just LOVES these little exercises in the intricacies of real-ekonomiks!
:)




All times are GMT +1. The time now is 06:26 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2006 FishingBanter