![]() |
Airport Security and Travel Rods
I'm planning on taking a trip in '04 to do some fly fishing, and I was
wanting to get a good 4 pc. rod for that and future trips. However, with airport security being what it is these days, I did not know if it is permissible to carry-on your fly rod. I would not want to have to check it, as it would be too expensive an item to just get lost in the luggage abyss. Has anyone had experience this year with fly rods, reels, and other fly fishing gear as carry-ons and airport security? Are policies consistent from airport to airport, or are they hit and miss? Thanks for any help. Robert Brinson |
Airport Security and Travel Rods
Robert Brinson writes:
snippage Has anyone had experience this year with fly rods, reels, and other fly fishing gear as carry-ons and airport security? Are policies consistent from airport to airport, or are they hit and miss? Thanks for any help. I flew from Boston to Billings this year and Boston to Bozeman last year and experienced no problems with carrying my three piece Winston aboard. I also had reels packed in my carry-on. Flies are another thing. Don't try to get through security with them With intermediate stops at Minniapolis one year and Cincinnati the next, I observed lots of fly fishermen with carry-on roads, some even with two piece (long tubes). Of course, ymmv. Dave http://hometown.aol.com/davplac/myhomepage/index.html |
Airport Security and Travel Rods
My experience mirrors Daves. I must look like some kind of terrorist,
though, because I was *not* allowed any rods on; even my reels were scrutinized way above and beyond the normal (if such a thing even exists today). I was almost made to strip off all lines--even the backing. Another Pilot came over--recognized the fly equipment--and told the screeners to let me through. I'm flying to Bozeman this coming summer--and FedExing most of my equipment out ahead of time. A pain in the ass? You bet--but not as much of a PITA as stripping all my reels. As did Dave L.; even though I wasn't allowed any rods (all 3; and 4 piece travel, by the way) on to the planes I traveled on; I saw *plenty* of guys carrying on rods--even 2 piecers. So to answer your question: NO, there is *no* standardization of rules between airports. Portland (ME.) and Logan (Boston) seem to be the worst, in my experience. Bozeman and Salt Lake seem to be the easiest, again, my experiences only. As always, YMMV. Good luck. Dave M "Robert Brinson" wrote in message om... I'm planning on taking a trip in '04 to do some fly fishing, and I was wanting to get a good 4 pc. rod for that and future trips. However, with airport security being what it is these days, I did not know if it is permissible to carry-on your fly rod. I would not want to have to check it, as it would be too expensive an item to just get lost in the luggage abyss. Has anyone had experience this year with fly rods, reels, and other fly fishing gear as carry-ons and airport security? Are policies consistent from airport to airport, or are they hit and miss? Thanks for any help. Robert Brinson |
Airport Security and Travel Rods
Dave Martel writes:
NO, there is *no* standardization of rules between airports. Portland (ME.) and Logan (Boston) seem to be the worst, in my experience. Bozeman and Salt Lake seem to be the easiest, again, my experiences only. As always, YMMV. Good luck. Dave M Any western terminal would be easiest because they see so many folks traveling there to fish. Logan is strict - I had trouble getting my fly tying equipment aboard - *before* 9/11, but they made me empty a flask of 18 year old single malt and said nothing of the weapon looking rod case I was carrying. Dave http://hometown.aol.com/davplac/myhomepage/index.html |
Airport Security and Travel Rods
I try and fish internationally a couple of times a year here is this year
report: Bozeman to Mexico: Rod, reel and flies to 1/0 no problem Mexico to Bozeman: Rod & reel- no problem Flies no go for me, my two buddies on the other hand walked right through luckily a guy at Alaskan gave me a box to check them. Bozeman to Honduras: Checked the flies and reels, carried on the rods (3 pc)- Taca looses luggage for 2 days- sucks to be me-forced to drink and watch permit for 2 days (there are worse things) Honduras to Bozeman: Checked the flies and reels , carried the rods, forgot a box of flies $100+ in my carry-on fanny pack- ended up forced to chuck $100+ flies in the San Pedro Sula trash Bozeman to Mexico: Checked Flies, carried on Rod & reel, security found one loose 2/0 clouser in one rod tube- strip searched for more- not happy, buddies think its funny Mexico to Bozeman: Checked all but rods- no problem- happy but only because of trip insurance The bottom line- I wouldn't try and carry on anything that even resembles a fish hook. The irony- Would you rather have a terrorist with a No. 14 Hopper after you or the guy with the butt section of a 12 wt.? I suspect it won't be long before rods can't be carried on. ¡Buenas Suerte! t. "Dave Martel" wrote in message t... My experience mirrors Daves. I must look like some kind of terrorist, though, because I was *not* allowed any rods on; even my reels were scrutinized way above and beyond the normal (if such a thing even exists today). I was almost made to strip off all lines--even the backing. Another Pilot came over--recognized the fly equipment--and told the screeners to let me through. I'm flying to Bozeman this coming summer--and FedExing most of my equipment out ahead of time. A pain in the ass? You bet--but not as much of a PITA as stripping all my reels. As did Dave L.; even though I wasn't allowed any rods (all 3; and 4 piece travel, by the way) on to the planes I traveled on; I saw *plenty* of guys carrying on rods--even 2 piecers. So to answer your question: NO, there is *no* standardization of rules between airports. Portland (ME.) and Logan (Boston) seem to be the worst, in my experience. Bozeman and Salt Lake seem to be the easiest, again, my experiences only. As always, YMMV. Good luck. Dave M "Robert Brinson" wrote in message om... I'm planning on taking a trip in '04 to do some fly fishing, and I was wanting to get a good 4 pc. rod for that and future trips. However, with airport security being what it is these days, I did not know if it is permissible to carry-on your fly rod. I would not want to have to check it, as it would be too expensive an item to just get lost in the luggage abyss. Has anyone had experience this year with fly rods, reels, and other fly fishing gear as carry-ons and airport security? Are policies consistent from airport to airport, or are they hit and miss? Thanks for any help. Robert Brinson |
Airport Security and Travel Rods
On Tue, 30 Dec 2003 13:02:08 -0700, "Thomas Gnauck" wrote:
[snippered] The bottom line- I wouldn't try and carry on anything that even resembles a fish hook. The irony- Would you rather have a terrorist with a No. 14 Hopper after you or the guy with the butt section of a 12 wt.? I suspect it won't be long before rods can't be carried on. Well, yeah! You could put someone's eye out with one of those ;-) /daytripper (god forbid they figure out a broken butt end would be much worse) |
Airport Security and Travel Rods
How would ya feel just traveling with a couple of doobies and no
equipment?... gotta visit ma - and ma don't share... john "Robert Brinson" wrote in message om... I'm planning on taking a trip in '04 to do some fly fishing, and I was wanting to get a good 4 pc. rod for that and future trips. However, with airport security being what it is these days, I did not know if it is permissible to carry-on your fly rod. I would not want to have to check it, as it would be too expensive an item to just get lost in the luggage abyss. Has anyone had experience this year with fly rods, reels, and other fly fishing gear as carry-ons and airport security? Are policies consistent from airport to airport, or are they hit and miss? Thanks for any help. Robert Brinson |
Airport Security and Travel Rods
I have a seven piece Redington Wayfarer, and I have been able to pack
everything I need to start fishing in my carryon ...except for flies...and have been able to get it through customs everywhere except Vancouver. They objected to the lines, leaders and tippet Re carrying rods. If the package is small, you have a very good chance of getting it on board. If you have a Sage rod case that holds 5 or 6 rods, the chance is less. the stewardesses have a bigger problem with it than security. Also, remember that most household insurance does not cover lost luggage, only stolen luggage...and they decide the difference. The best way to get insurance for lost luggage is to get a credit card that will give you up to $3000 of insurance if you pay for your tickets with the card. ATT cards have this insurance. Citibank offers it on a few types. Most cards issued in Canada and Europe have it. "Robert Brinson" wrote in message om... I'm planning on taking a trip in '04 to do some fly fishing, and I was wanting to get a good 4 pc. rod for that and future trips. However, with airport security being what it is these days, I did not know if it is permissible to carry-on your fly rod. I would not want to have to check it, as it would be too expensive an item to just get lost in the luggage abyss. Has anyone had experience this year with fly rods, reels, and other fly fishing gear as carry-ons and airport security? Are policies consistent from airport to airport, or are they hit and miss? Thanks for any help. Robert Brinson --- Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free. Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com). Version: 6.0.556 / Virus Database: 348 - Release Date: 12/26/2003 |
Airport Security and Travel Rods
Philly to Denver to Missoula this September, I packed my Winston 5 piece
6'9" w/aluminum tube *and* my little chest pack (which contains reels, tippet, flies, fisherman's friend clippers, etc.) in my carryon. No troubles. Although they did make me drink water out of my nalgene and take my boots off. |
Airport Security and Travel Rods
Thank you to everyone for providing your (humorous) airport stories. :-)
-- Robert Brinson Linux - the choice of a GNU generation! |
Airport Security and Travel Rods
Has anyone had experience this year with fly rods,
reels, and other fly fishing gear as carry-ons and airport security? Are policies consistent from airport to airport, or are they hit and miss? Thanks for any help. I took my pack rod as a carry-on during a trip this summer from Buffalo to Newark to Asheville, NC to fish the mountains and had no problem. They did open the tube at each check-in to examine it, but otherwise no problems. |
Airport Security and Travel Rods
I've been advised by airline industry people to pack my lines and flies.
USUALLY, no problem with reels (sans lines) or travel rods. DW |
Airport Security and Travel Rods
If you must bring it on the plane, I suggest just checking all fly fishing
equipment, just make sure to insure all of it, which seems to keep it safe and sound. I would also recommend shipping it ahead of time to avoid the hassle all together, if you have somewhere to ship it to (a hotel, or guide usually would not object). At one of our Penns Creek Claves someone's rods (three of them tied together) came up missing and he had to wait a few days for them to find and deliver them, so definitely insure them (I don't believe he did). If you can ship it far enough ahead of time you can even check to make sure it arrives O.K. before you leave and bring anything you forgot on the plane. It may cost a bit extra, but you'll have peace of mind. You'll still have to worry about your standard luggage, but it's also a lot less to bring back and forth from the airport. The Finn "Robert Brinson" wrote in message om... I'm planning on taking a trip in '04 to do some fly fishing, and I was wanting to get a good 4 pc. rod for that and future trips. However, with airport security being what it is these days, I did not know if it is permissible to carry-on your fly rod. I would not want to have to check it, as it would be too expensive an item to just get lost in the luggage abyss. Has anyone had experience this year with fly rods, reels, and other fly fishing gear as carry-ons and airport security? Are policies consistent from airport to airport, or are they hit and miss? Thanks for any help. Robert Brinson |
Airport Security and Travel Rods
"Mike Makela" ten.tsacmoc@alekamm wrote: I would also recommend shipping it ahead of time to avoid the hassle all together, if you have somewhere to ship it to (a hotel, or guide usually would not object). At one of our Penns Creek Claves someone's rods (three of them tied together) came up missing and he had to wait a few days for them to find and deliver them, so definitely insure them (I don't believe he did). Just to clarify the three rods were misplaced on the plane, not during shipping. |
Airport Security and Travel Rods
The key is insuring it for a hefty sum. They must hand it off with sign-off
as it travels. If you are still hesitant at doing this, ship it separately. I would more paranoid about smaller items that you leave in your luggage that you check such as reels, flies, etc. They can be stolen quite easily. I think the main problem is just that, items getting stolen. Several items have been stolen from close family and friends since 9/11, because there is increased access to our luggage, and smaller items can be pocketed. I pack all valuables separately and insure them. "Greg Pavlov" wrote in message ... On Wed, 31 Dec 2003 13:33:26 -0600, Christian Figenschou wrote: On Wed, 31 Dec 2003 14:00:07 -0500, "Mike Makela" ten.tsacmoc@alekamm wrote: If you must bring it on the plane, I suggest just checking all fly fishing equipment, just make sure to insure all of it, which seems to keep it safe and sound. Strange piece of advice, I must say.. It works for me: I've never actually lost luggage tho I've had it delivered late on two occasions. My guess is that I have checked luggage about 300 times. |
Airport Security and Travel Rods
The key is insuring it for a hefty sum. They must hand it off with sign-off
as it travels. If you are still hesitant at doing this, ship it separately. I was at Marriots Fly shop in California a couple of years ago when a guy came in with a multi-thousand dollar check from the airlines. He'd insured and they'd lost six fly rods, with all of his accompanying tackle (flies, reels...). He got a "personal shopper" to help him spend his bucks. Talk about your kid in a candy shop. Frank Reid |
Airport Security and Travel Rods
I'd hate to have to replace all of the gear, but a "personal shopper" and
thousands of dollars would be a good start. Can't hurt to insure everything for more then they are worth to help reduce the pain.. "Francis Reid" wrote in message ... The key is insuring it for a hefty sum. They must hand it off with sign-off as it travels. If you are still hesitant at doing this, ship it separately. I was at Marriots Fly shop in California a couple of years ago when a guy came in with a multi-thousand dollar check from the airlines. He'd insured and they'd lost six fly rods, with all of his accompanying tackle (flies, reels...). He got a "personal shopper" to help him spend his bucks. Talk about your kid in a candy shop. Frank Reid |
Airport Security and Travel Rods
I'd hate to have to replace all of the gear, but a "personal shopper" and
thousands of dollars would be a good start. Can't hurt to insure everything for more then they are worth to help reduce the pain.. "Francis Reid" wrote in message ... The key is insuring it for a hefty sum. They must hand it off with sign-off as it travels. If you are still hesitant at doing this, ship it separately. I was at Marriots Fly shop in California a couple of years ago when a guy came in with a multi-thousand dollar check from the airlines. He'd insured and they'd lost six fly rods, with all of his accompanying tackle (flies, reels...). He got a "personal shopper" to help him spend his bucks. Talk about your kid in a candy shop. Frank Reid |
Airport Security and Travel Rods
"Christian Figenschou" wrote in message ... On Wed, 31 Dec 2003 19:46:58 GMT, (Greg Pavlov) wrote: It works for me: I've never actually lost luggage tho I've had it delivered late on two occasions. My guess is that I have checked luggage about 300 times. But you would surely agree that the chances of it getting lost or being delayed are dramatically bigger when checked compared to lugging it on-board yourself? Sure if you can get it on board, get through the security checks without being strip searched, and not miss your flight. F.Y.I. - I usually travel with a large aresenal of rods for a big trip, and not all are travel rods. I've had to find the best way to get them there by checking them. Shipping them is safer then checking them, but checking them (w/insurance) is cheaper. |
Airport Security and Travel Rods
"Christian Figenschou" wrote in message ... On Wed, 31 Dec 2003 19:46:58 GMT, (Greg Pavlov) wrote: It works for me: I've never actually lost luggage tho I've had it delivered late on two occasions. My guess is that I have checked luggage about 300 times. But you would surely agree that the chances of it getting lost or being delayed are dramatically bigger when checked compared to lugging it on-board yourself? Sure if you can get it on board, get through the security checks without being strip searched, and not miss your flight. F.Y.I. - I usually travel with a large aresenal of rods for a big trip, and not all are travel rods. I've had to find the best way to get them there by checking them. Shipping them is safer then checking them, but checking them (w/insurance) is cheaper. |
Airport Security and Travel Rods
"Christian Figenschou" wrote in message ... On Wed, 31 Dec 2003 19:46:58 GMT, (Greg Pavlov) wrote: It works for me: I've never actually lost luggage tho I've had it delivered late on two occasions. My guess is that I have checked luggage about 300 times. But you would surely agree that the chances of it getting lost or being delayed are dramatically bigger when checked compared to lugging it on-board yourself? Sure if you can get it on board, get through the security checks without being strip searched, and not miss your flight. F.Y.I. - I usually travel with a large aresenal of rods for a big trip, and not all are travel rods. I've had to find the best way to get them there by checking them. Shipping them is safer then checking them, but checking them (w/insurance) is cheaper. |
Airport Security and Travel Rods
Christian Figenschou wrote in
: On Wed, 31 Dec 2003 19:46:58 GMT, (Greg Pavlov) wrote: It works for me: I've never actually lost luggage tho I've had it delivered late on two occasions. My guess is that I have checked luggage about 300 times. But you would surely agree that the chances of it getting lost or being delayed are dramatically bigger when checked compared to lugging it on-board yourself? Actually, you're talking about Greg here! The less time he spends handling the rod, the longer it lasts :-) Scott |
Airport Security and Travel Rods
"Greg Pavlov" wrote in message ... How could they make you drink water ? In the early days of the post 9/11 histeria and witchhunt, there was a well reported incident where the, ahem, security folks made a young mother drink her child's breast milk. |
Airport Security and Travel Rods
When I went to Sun Valley last fall. I printed out all of the below documentation
and carried the TSA's number 1-866-289-9673. I was told by one of their agents, "If you have a problem carrying it on, just give us a call and we will talk to the screener". The below info is from: http://www.tsa.gov/public/interapp/e...orial_1188.xml Fishing Rods / Poles - Fishing Rods are permitted as carry-on and checked baggage. However, please check with your air carrier to confirm that it fits within their size limitations for carry-on items. Ultimately, it is the carrier's decision as to whether or not it can be transported as carry-on baggage. Tackle Equipment - fishing equipment, including small hooks, should be placed in your checked baggage. Some tackle equipment can be considered sharp and dangerous. Complete listing below: http://www.tsa.gov/interweb/assetlib...12_18_2003.pdf -Marshall -- NOTE: Please remove "MY_WADERS" from my return Email address if you wish to reply directly. Thanks, M |
Airport Security and Travel Rods
I know there was a sign-off process pre 9/11 on American Airlines, and am
assuming that process still is in affect where sign-offs are required where the insured baggage exchanges hands (that could be a bad assumption. I'm sure some of the processes must have changed though. They may not be as concerned with the chain of custody, as they are with what is in the baggage. That's a good question for the Airline/s you use. There could definitely be a drop in service if discount airlines are used. I really don't use insurance for the money reimbursement aspect, just to ensure better handling, although Frank's shopping spree story was intriguing. In the past, when you went to baggage claim, you had to pick up insured packages from handlers. Not sure that is still in affect but asking the airline should do it for you.. I'm not really a rod and reel whore...at least not until recently. The most rods I have taken on a trip were 4 when I went to Alaska, but none of those were travel rods and that was the source of my first panic driven inquiry with the airlines as to how to ensure they would not be lost. The Finn "Christian Figenschou" wrote in message ... On Wed, 31 Dec 2003 16:24:12 -0500, "Mike Makela" ten.tsacmoc@alekamm wrote: F.Y.I. - I usually travel with a large aresenal of rods for a big trip, and not all are travel rods. I've had to find the best way to get them there by checking them. Shipping them is safer then checking them, but checking them (w/insurance) is cheaper. For obvious reasons I always try to make sure I have at least one set of gear on-board, one rod, one reel, a box of flies + other vital accessories. But then again, the most rods I've ever brought on a trip involving air-travel is three (yes, I know I am a pathetic loser..) The insurance aspect is interesting. However, equally important is whether it is treated differently by the airline or not. Do you know? Is there a coverage threshold that triggers special attention? If they simply take their chances and are prepared to pay some extra $$$ if they lose it, it doesn't really improve the odds of getting it there on time. I'm also sure many credit cards would automatically provide coverage beyond the airlines' standard liability. |
Airport Security and Travel Rods
They do take nail files away from you, and I would expect them to take
corkscrew and nitting needles too. I've lost two pair of finger nail clippers with a one inch file attached!! Remember we are not discussing what is reasonable. We are talking abut a bunch of minimum wage earners who are now bearuocrats (sp?). What you might think is reasonable, and what we may agree is not a weapon doesn't count!! We don't have the badge nor the job. I have not lost any flies, because I have not tried to carry then in my carry-on luggage. I can learn by others mistakes. "Christian Figenschou" wrote in message ... On Wed, 31 Dec 2003 06:22:46 -0800, "Sierra fisher" wrote: Whether they're on the list or not, large flies for sal****er fishing are considered possible weapons. I know a lot people who were told to check them or toss them. Well, since I have gone through with large sal****er hooks, even had them inspected twice, let's agree on they _might_ be considered possible weapons by certain TSA people. By large I mean 3-4 inches hook length, I see no reason why standard size (4-10) should be considered any more dangerous as a weapon than permitted items such as knitting needles, cork screws and nail files. And never have I had my hooks examined due to seeing them on x-ray, the search has always been warranted by spotting forceps and scissors. Do you by any chance jump up and down, yelling "I got hooks.. Big hooks, I tell ya!"? ;-) Which airports? How many experiences? --- Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free. Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com). Version: 6.0.556 / Virus Database: 348 - Release Date: 12/26/2003 |
Airport Security and Travel Rods
The next time you go through Security with some fishing gear, and they tell
you that you cannot carry it on, are you going to bring up this web page? Unfortunately, you're going to lose the argument!! "Marshall Krasser" wrote in message ... When I went to Sun Valley last fall. I printed out all of the below documentation and carried the TSA's number 1-866-289-9673. I was told by one of their agents, "If you have a problem carrying it on, just give us a call and we will talk to the screener". The below info is from: http://www.tsa.gov/public/interapp/e...orial_1188.xml Fishing Rods / Poles - Fishing Rods are permitted as carry-on and checked baggage. However, please check with your air carrier to confirm that it fits within their size limitations for carry-on items. Ultimately, it is the carrier's decision as to whether or not it can be transported as carry-on baggage. Tackle Equipment - fishing equipment, including small hooks, should be placed in your checked baggage. Some tackle equipment can be considered sharp and dangerous. Complete listing below: http://www.tsa.gov/interweb/assetlib...12_18_2003.pdf -Marshall -- NOTE: Please remove "MY_WADERS" from my return Email address if you wish to reply directly. Thanks, M --- Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free. Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com). Version: 6.0.556 / Virus Database: 348 - Release Date: 12/26/2003 |
Airport Security and Travel Rods
"Wayne Knight" wrote in message ... "Greg Pavlov" wrote in message ... How could they make you drink water ? In the early days of the post 9/11 histeria and witchhunt, there was a well reported incident where the, ahem, security folks made a young mother drink her child's breast milk. That should read made a young mother drink breast milk she had saved for her child. |
Airport Security and Travel Rods
"Sierra fisher" wrote in message ... The next time you go through Security with some fishing gear, and they tell you that you cannot carry it on, are you going to bring up this web page? Unfortunately, you're going to lose the argument!! Not if you are professional, firm, and courteous. Been there done it |
Airport Security and Travel Rods
On Wed, 31 Dec 2003 23:56:02 -0500, "Wayne Knight"
wrote: "Wayne Knight" wrote in message ... "Greg Pavlov" wrote in message ... How could they make you drink water ? In the early days of the post 9/11 histeria and witchhunt, there was a well reported incident where the, ahem, security folks made a young mother drink her child's breast milk. That should read made a young mother drink breast milk she had saved for her child. Yes, I was gonna make a crack about a whole lot of frustrated people, but I didn't ;-) /daytripper (that would have been so...wrong ;-) |
Airport Security and Travel Rods
|
Airport Security and Travel Rods
I could care less if you carry your fles on. I just hope that you have the
balls to tell this group what happens the next time you try it. "Christian Figenschou" wrote in message ... On Wed, 31 Dec 2003 20:00:30 -0800, "Sierra fisher" wrote: They do take nail files away from you, and I would expect them to take corkscrew and nitting needles too. [...] I have not lost any flies, because I have not tried to carry then in my carry-on luggage. I can learn by others mistakes. Well, I hope you don't mind if the rest of us continue bringing such items through security without incidents. I think your description of airport security is dated, based on pre-TSA, pre-specific permitted items lists, and definitely pre consistency and attitude improvements throughout 2003. --- Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free. Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com). Version: 6.0.556 / Virus Database: 348 - Release Date: 12/27/2003 |
Airport Security and Travel Rods
I have in the past, check with your airline though, the rules are changing
these days. Let me know what you find out, "Greg Pavlov" wrote in message ... On Wed, 31 Dec 2003 14:52:54 -0500, "Mike Makela" ten.tsacmoc@alekamm wrote: The key is insuring it for a hefty sum. They must hand it off with sign-off as it travels. If you are still hesitant at doing this, ship it separately. Do you insure it at the time you check it ? I didn't know that you could do that, I will look into it next time. |
All times are GMT +1. The time now is 07:31 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2006 FishingBanter