FishingBanter

FishingBanter (http://www.fishingbanter.com/index.php)
-   Fly Fishing (http://www.fishingbanter.com/forumdisplay.php?f=6)
-   -   fly fishers as elitists (http://www.fishingbanter.com/showthread.php?t=4628)

snakefiddler June 12th, 2004 03:29 AM

fly fishers as elitists
 
so the guys i work with in the campus library have been teasing me about fly
fishin, saying that now i won't hang out with the "regular" fisherman
anymore, and that i'll start fishin with the upper echelon of the
university, and will start wearing tweed........ and other **** like that.

what gives? ya'll got a reputation or somethin? ;-)

snakefiddler



Ken Fortenberry June 12th, 2004 04:12 AM

fly fishers as elitists
 
snakefiddler wrote:
so the guys i work with in the campus library have been teasing me about fly
fishin, saying that now i won't hang out with the "regular" fisherman
anymore, and that i'll start fishin with the upper echelon of the
university, and will start wearing tweed.......


You'd better stay away from the tweed and stick to dildos,
thongs and bikinis if you want to keep these old lechers
interested in your tyro escapades.

--
Ken Fortenberry


Wayne Knight June 12th, 2004 04:17 AM

fly fishers as elitists
 

"snakefiddler" wrote in message
...

what gives? ya'll got a reputation or somethin? ;-)


only me and kenny, we're elititists, the rest of y'all are just average joes
and joesephines.





rw June 12th, 2004 06:11 AM

fly fishers as elitists
 
Ken Fortenberry wrote:
snakefiddler wrote:

so the guys i work with in the campus library have been teasing me
about fly
fishin, saying that now i won't hang out with the "regular" fisherman
anymore, and that i'll start fishin with the upper echelon of the
university, and will start wearing tweed.......



You'd better stay away from the tweed and stick to dildos,
thongs and bikinis if you want to keep these old lechers
interested in your tyro escapades.


As you know, Ken, I loathe you, but I have to admit that's pretty good.

--
Cut "to the chase" for my email address.

Particle Salad June 12th, 2004 06:25 AM

fly fishers as elitists
 
Hell yea. It's actually not so bad here, but 8 times out of 10 I walk into
any of my local flyshops... sheesh.

what gives? ya'll got a reputation or somethin? ;-)

snakefiddler





rw June 12th, 2004 06:58 AM

fly fishers as elitists
 
I'll tell you what, snakefiddler: Catching fish is pretty easy when you
will stoop to any damn method -- worms, power bait, minnows, roe sacks,
spinners, dynamite, bleach, whatever it takes. Flyfishing is altogether
different. After you've put in your dues, which takes years, you'll
sometimes outfish the lower classes and always have more fun and
satisfaction in the doing. Until you understand that, you are not a
flyfisherwoman. Tell your poaching, meat fishing, bait slinging
coworkers to go **** themselves. :-)

--
Cut "to the chase" for my email address.

Chas Wade June 12th, 2004 07:14 AM

fly fishers as elitists
 
rw wrote:
I'll tell you what, snakefiddler: Catching fish is pretty easy when
you
will stoop to any damn method -- worms, power bait, minnows, roe
sacks,
spinners, dynamite, bleach, whatever it takes. Flyfishing is
altogether
different. After you've put in your dues, which takes years, you'll
sometimes outfish the lower classes and always have more fun and
satisfaction in the doing. Until you understand that, you are not a
flyfisherwoman. Tell your poaching, meat fishing, bait slinging
coworkers to go **** themselves. :-)


Well said.

Chas
remove fly fish to reply
http://home.comcast.net/~chas.wade/w...ome.html-.html
San Juan Pictures at:
http://home.comcast.net/~chasepike/wsb/index.html



snakefiddler June 12th, 2004 12:55 PM

fly fishers as elitists
 

"Chas Wade" wrote in message
news:9bxyc.85348$Ly.17518@attbi_s01...
rw wrote:
I'll tell you what, snakefiddler: Catching fish is pretty easy when
you
will stoop to any damn method -- worms, power bait, minnows, roe
sacks,
spinners, dynamite, bleach, whatever it takes. Flyfishing is
altogether
different.


of this i have no doubt.



After you've put in your dues, which takes years,

glad i got a lot of em ahead


you'll
sometimes outfish the lower classes and always have more fun and
satisfaction in the doing. Until you understand that,


having already experienced the challenge of the basics, i can understand why
you would make that statement- and i look forward to the day that i can
boast competency, much less great skill. meanwhile i will take my
satisfaction in the learning process, the occasional catch, and the
wonderful experiences surrounding the activity.



you are not a
flyfisherwoman.


ah, have no doubt, r.w.- i'm on my way


Tell your poaching, meat fishing, bait slinging
coworkers to go **** themselves. :-)


snakefiddler



http://home.comcast.net/~chas.wade/w...ome.html-.html
San Juan Pictures at:
http://home.comcast.net/~chasepike/wsb/index.html





snakefiddler June 12th, 2004 01:03 PM

fly fishers as elitists
 

"Ken Fortenberry" wrote in message
.. .
snakefiddler wrote:
so the guys i work with in the campus library have been teasing me about

fly
fishin, saying that now i won't hang out with the "regular" fisherman
anymore, and that i'll start fishin with the upper echelon of the
university, and will start wearing tweed.......



You'd better stay away from the tweed and stick to dildos,
thongs and bikinis if you want to keep these old lechers
interested in your tyro escapades.


come on forty- give the rest of the guys more credit than you give
yourself.........

hey, kennie, will i get a chance to fish with you in october? i'll looking
forward as HELL to meeting you...... you know, one of those morbid curiosity
things :)

snakaefiddler




--
Ken Fortenberry




Ken Fortenberry June 12th, 2004 02:18 PM

fly fishers as elitists
 
rw wrote:

I'll tell you what, snakefiddler: Catching fish is pretty easy when you
will stoop to any damn method -- worms, power bait, minnows, roe sacks,
spinners, dynamite, bleach, whatever it takes. Flyfishing is altogether
different. After you've put in your dues, which takes years, you'll
sometimes outfish the lower classes and always have more fun and
satisfaction in the doing. Until you understand that, you are not a
flyfisherwoman. Tell your poaching, meat fishing, bait slinging
coworkers to go **** themselves. :-)


As you know, Steve, I loathe you, but I have to admit that's pretty good.

--
Ken Fortenberry


Asadi June 13th, 2004 03:33 AM

fly fishers as elitists
 

"snakefiddler"
what gives? ya'll got a reputation or somethin? ;-)

snakefiddler



kinda.....but I've been trying to keep a low profile and hope it would go
away.

john



snakefiddler June 13th, 2004 03:50 AM

fly fishers as elitists
 

"Asadi" wrote in message
link.net...

"snakefiddler"
what gives? ya'll got a reputation or somethin? ;-)

snakefiddler



kinda.....but I've been trying to keep a low profile and hope it would go
away.

john



yeah, me too ;-)
snake



Salmo Bytes June 13th, 2004 02:10 PM

fly fishers as elitists
 
rw wrote in message om...
...
After you've put in your dues, which takes years, you'll
sometimes outfish the lower classes and always have more fun and
satisfaction in the doing.


Actually, after you've really put in your dues, you eventually
get over the rooky impulse to regard anything not
fly fishing as somehow inferior. The mature fisherman
is a master of all techniques, who chooses, at any given
moment, the technique of his (her?) choice.

For instance, just yesterday I drifted a stretch brown-colored
canyon water, swollen and roilly after three weeks of cold
weather and heavy rain. The river was almost empty...most fly
fishermen assumed it was hopeless, perhaps.

I fished it from a driftboat, using an 8wt rod with a 12' leader
with a 40lb butt,
attached to a soft, flexible, molded plastic sculpin, a Carolina-rig
worm hook, a plastic bead and a Colorado Spinner blade,
attached to a plastic clevis. I didn't knock'em dead, but
I did catch some very nice fish, casting with pin-point
accuracy to obvious eddies and runs....and I did it
with a fly rod. One important disadvantage of a spinning
rod--in situations like that--is the need to reel the lure
all the way back to the rod tip between casts. With the flyrod
you can pick the lure up and throw it back down at a distance,
so you can pick off each good looking eddy as drift along.

It takes experience and mastery to know how to do that.
And a lack of silly, irrelevant, immature predudice. :-)

jim crawford June 14th, 2004 05:46 PM

tweed my good man?
 
and what is wrong with tweed may I ask
from Edinburgh Scotland

"snakefiddler" wrote in message
...
so the guys i work with in the campus library have been teasing me about

fly
fishin, saying that now i won't hang out with the "regular" fisherman
anymore, and that i'll start fishin with the upper echelon of the
university, and will start wearing tweed........ and other **** like that.

what gives? ya'll got a reputation or somethin? ;-)

snakefiddler





Uncle Mac June 14th, 2004 06:24 PM

tweed my good man?
 

"jim crawford" wrote in message
...
and what is wrong with tweed may I ask
from Edinburgh Scotland

Nothing wrong with tweed, good fellow, as long as it's Harris. BTW, the
'fiddler is of the female gender and resides in North Carolina. That, you
recall, was the refuge for Flora McDonald in hard times.

Uncle Mac McCaskill
Proud Scot until the Highland Clearances ;-).



snakefiddler June 14th, 2004 07:44 PM

tweed my good man?
 

"Uncle Mac" wrote in message
hlink.net...

"jim crawford" wrote in message
...
and what is wrong with tweed may I ask
from Edinburgh Scotland

Nothing wrong with tweed, good fellow, as long as it's Harris. BTW, the
'fiddler is of the female gender and resides in North Carolina. That,

you
recall, was the refuge for Flora McDonald in hard times.

Uncle Mac McCaskill




Proud Scot until the Highland Clearances ;-).

most excellent tag line ;-)
snakefiddler




Jeff June 14th, 2004 08:41 PM

tweed my good man?
 


Uncle Mac wrote:


Uncle Mac McCaskill
Proud Scot until the Highland Clearances ;-).


are you any relation to the McCaskills from Troy, Alabama?

jeff (1st wife was a mccaskill - as fine a family as i've ever known)




Uncle Mac June 14th, 2004 09:43 PM

tweed my good man?
 

"Jeff" wrote in message are you any relation to the
McCaskills from Troy, Alabama?

jeff (1st wife was a mccaskill - as fine a family as i've ever known)

All McCaskills were a sub clan of the McLeods of Skye. Some are still

there. Others were dispersed during the clearances to North Carolina,
Georgia, Nova Scotia, Australia, and anywhere refugees could settle. I
assume Alabama, severly needing "new blood" for breeding purposes, offered
several tax advantages for the penniless immigrants ;-). We may be related
to the Alabama clan, just several generations removed.





Lazarus Cooke June 15th, 2004 10:59 PM

tweed my good man?
 
In article k.net,
Uncle Mac wrote:

Nothing wrong with tweed, good fellow, as long as it's Harris.


What's wrong with Donegal?

Lazarus

--
Remover the rock from the email address

Uncle Mac June 16th, 2004 02:40 AM

tweed my good man?
 

"Lazarus Cooke" wrote in message
om...

What's wrong with Donegal?


May I get back with you on that? It appears as if I must take a trip to the
County Donegal to investigate. BTW, how's the trout fishing in Donegal? I
really have to have another reason for going, you know.



Lazarus Cooke June 16th, 2004 11:05 PM

tweed my good man?
 
In article . net,
Uncle Mac wrote:

"Lazarus Cooke" wrote in message
om...

What's wrong with Donegal?


May I get back with you on that? It appears as if I must take a trip to the
County Donegal to investigate. BTW, how's the trout fishing in Donegal? I
really have to have another reason for going, you know.

For white trout it's not as good as it was (celebrated in 'A man may
fish' and Hugh Falkus's 'Sea trout fishing') , but for summer salmon
there's no equal. The river Finn must be one of the most prolific
grilse rivers in the British Isles. It also rises in the Bluestack
Mountains, one of most deserted and beautiful bits of the island, where
I would normally expect people in a bar to be speaking Irish rather
than English. don't know why riverman went to Wales.

Lazarus.

--
Remover the rock from the email address

Tim Carter June 17th, 2004 04:29 AM

WAS tweed my good man? NOW: Is the bet still on???
 

"Lazarus Cooke" wrote in message
om...
In article . net,
Uncle Mac wrote:

"Lazarus Cooke" wrote in message
om...

What's wrong with Donegal?


May I get back with you on that? It appears as if I must take a trip to

the
County Donegal to investigate. BTW, how's the trout fishing in Donegal?

I
really have to have another reason for going, you know.

For white trout it's not as good as it was (celebrated in 'A man may
fish' and Hugh Falkus's 'Sea trout fishing') , but for summer salmon
there's no equal. The river Finn must be one of the most prolific
grilse rivers in the British Isles. It also rises in the Bluestack
Mountains, one of most deserted and beautiful bits of the island, where
I would normally expect people in a bar to be speaking Irish rather
than English. don't know why riverman went to Wales.

Lazarus


How's Penn's Creek sound end of May next year? November is fast approaching
and no sign of Mr. bin Laden yet........



riverman June 20th, 2004 04:43 PM

tweed my good man?
 

"Lazarus Cooke" wrote in message
om...
don't know why riverman went to Wales.


Well, there's always next year! I just hope the Donnegalians aren't as
possessive about their salmon fishing as the Welch (not you, Bill). I saw
some tremendous rises on the river Wye, but after spending an unsuccessful
hour trying to find the owner of the water, I had to give up trying to get
permission to fish there. A local store owner told me that I wouldn't have
meet their rod length/gear restrictions, or dress code anyway!

--riverman



Lazarus Cooke June 21st, 2004 03:45 PM

tweed my good man?
 
In article , riverman
wrote:

Well, there's always next year! I just hope the Donnegalians aren't as
possessive about their salmon fishing as the Welch (not you, Bill). I saw
some tremendous rises on the river Wye, but after spending an unsuccessful
hour trying to find the owner of the water, I had to give up trying to get
permission to fish there. A local store owner told me that I wouldn't have
meet their rod length/gear restrictions, or dress code anyway!


My favourite Donegal river, the Finn, forms the border between Northern
Ireland (British) & Southern Ireland (Republic) for much of its length.
A few wealthy types thought of buying up the rights, but when they
realised the political ramifications, decided against. One of the
reasons I prefer the fishing in Ireland is that it totally lacks this
bloody class distinction of England & Scotland (don't know about
Wales).

There is no dress code apart from 'wrap up warm and dry' and 'make sure
there's a flask of whiskey in your pocket'.

Don't forget they book I suggested - 'The Spawning run'. You'll enjoy
it even more now you've been to wales.

Lazarus

--
Remover the rock from the email address

Willi June 21st, 2004 03:54 PM

tweed my good man?
 


Lazarus Cooke wrote:

There is no dress code apart from 'wrap up warm and dry' and 'make sure
there's a flask of whiskey in your pocket'.



I thought your dress code remark was a joke! What type of dress code(s)
are there?

Willi




riverman June 21st, 2004 05:36 PM

tweed my good man?
 

"Willi" wrote in message
...


Lazarus Cooke wrote:

There is no dress code apart from 'wrap up warm and dry' and 'make sure
there's a flask of whiskey in your pocket'.



I thought your dress code remark was a joke! What type of dress code(s)
are there?


The guy I saw fishing there had on Wellingtons ('mud boots' to us
Ammericuns), knee length pants, a tweed jacket, a tie, one of those NY
cabbie hats and a pipe. I asked the store owner if they minded someone
dressed in more modern outdoor clothing, and he looked at me (dressed in
fishing shirt, pile vest, baseball cap and hiking shoes) and said "Well, the
owner of that particular stretch of water prefers folks to dress in the
'traditional' style...."

Then I mentioned that I was going to use a 9-foot 8wt rod, and he said "Oh,
no, then. It simply must be a two-handed rod, at least 12 feet in length if
you want to fish their water.."

--riverman



Lazarus Cooke June 21st, 2004 10:31 PM

tweed my good man?
 
In article , riverman
wrote:

(dressed in
fishing shirt, pile vest, baseball cap and hiking shoes)


My cousin Alice bought me one of those baseball caps from a fishing
store in Colorado as a Christmas present. I tried it, but couldn't see
the point.

a) it didn't keep the rain off - it was made of cotton.
b) it particularly didn't keep the rain off the back of my neck
c) It didn't keep salmon flies blown off course from hitting the back
of my neck.

So I'm still using the technologically superior fur felt hat with a
brim all round - or maybe a donegal tweed hat.

Those pile jackets are easy to wash, and they'r ehard wearing, but
they're not nearly as warm, weight for weight, as wool.

So I'm not going to do any dressing up in fancy gear to go fishing.
I'll stick with my tweed knickerbockers, jacket, and my felt hat, -
maybe a silk tie or cravat to keep my neck warm - and let the yuppies
and the fashion vicitms wear their baseball caps and pile vests.

Lazarus

--
Remover the rock from the email address

Wolfgang June 21st, 2004 11:55 PM

tweed my good man?
 

"Lazarus Cooke" wrote in message
om...
In article , riverman
wrote:

(dressed in
fishing shirt, pile vest, baseball cap and hiking shoes)


My cousin Alice bought me one of those baseball caps from a fishing
store in Colorado as a Christmas present. I tried it, but couldn't see
the point.

a) it didn't keep the rain off - it was made of cotton.


No hat is the best solution for rain......you want a waterproof jacket with
an integral hood for that job.

b) it particularly didn't keep the rain off the back of my neck


See above....in spades.

c) It didn't keep salmon flies blown off course from hitting the back
of my neck.


Technique is a better solution than technology for this ill. Improved
technique also results in other....um...less tangible....benefits.

So I'm still using the technologically superior fur felt hat with a
brim all round - or maybe a donegal tweed hat.


The presumed fact that one item does a particular job better than another
doesn't necessarily make it technologically superior. A claw hammer will
not shorten a board as cleanly or efficiently as a crosscut saw. A claw
hammer is not technologiaclly inferior to a crosscut saw; it's simply less
suitable for performing a task it wasn't designed for than is an implement
that WAS designed for that task......try driving nails with a crosscut saw
some time.

I've worn many hats throughout my life. All of them were more suitable for
some things than for others. Some of them did nothing well. Others did
several things well. I have yet to find anything better suited to the
combined tasks of shading the eyes....especially against a low lying
sun...., staying on the head in a brisk breeze, and remaining comfortable in
warm weather than a good fitting, long billed cotton ball cap.

Those pile jackets are easy to wash, and they'r ehard wearing, but
they're not nearly as warm, weight for weight, as wool.

So I'm not going to do any dressing up in fancy gear to go fishing.
I'll stick with my tweed knickerbockers, jacket, and my felt hat, -
maybe a silk tie or cravat to keep my neck warm - and let the yuppies
and the fashion vicitms wear their baseball caps and pile vests.


Throughout my adult life I've experienced a good deal of social angst over
the fact that I appeared to be the only person left in the world without a
legitimate claim to victimhood. It is good to know that I have, at long
last, arrived. Thank you.

Wolfgang



Willi June 23rd, 2004 12:02 AM

tweed my good man?
 


riverman wrote:



The guy I saw fishing there had on Wellingtons ('mud boots' to us
Ammericuns), knee length pants, a tweed jacket, a tie, one of those NY
cabbie hats and a pipe. I asked the store owner if they minded someone
dressed in more modern outdoor clothing, and he looked at me (dressed in
fishing shirt, pile vest, baseball cap and hiking shoes) and said "Well, the
owner of that particular stretch of water prefers folks to dress in the
'traditional' style...."

Then I mentioned that I was going to use a 9-foot 8wt rod, and he said "Oh,
no, then. It simply must be a two-handed rod, at least 12 feet in length if
you want to fish their water.."



That's a different world!

It does make you appreciate the amount of public lands and water we have
here in the States. It's something we tend to take for granted.

Willi





Lazarus Cooke June 28th, 2004 10:44 AM

tweed my good man?
 
In article , Willi
wrote:

It does make you appreciate the amount of public lands and water we have
here in the States. It's something we tend to take for granted.


Socialist fishing, private medicine in the states. Other way round in
Wales.

Why can't those dam Welsh see that fishing is a right, while medicine
is a privilege?

L

--
Remover the rock from the email address


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 06:11 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2006 FishingBanter