![]() |
|
Flyline/Leader Connection Question
Planning on using some mono to connect flyline
to leader, using a nail knot. What pound test mono should I use? 4 weight flyline. This rod will be used for bluegills. Thanks in advance for the help. Skip |
Flyline/Leader Connection Question
Skip Summer wrote:
Planning on using some mono to connect flyline to leader, using a nail knot. What pound test mono should I use? 4 weight flyline. This rod will be used for bluegills. Thanks in advance for the help. Skip I use store bought "continuous taper" leaders, 7.5' 3X. Depending on the brand the thick end is between .019 and ..021, which translates to like 20lb. mono. The tipppet end is .008, of course, about a 4 or 5lb test. -- Ken Fortenberry |
Flyline/Leader Connection Question
"Skip Summer" wrote in message om... Planning on using some mono to connect flyline to leader, using a nail knot. What pound test mono should I use? Look at the diameter of the large end of the leader and purchase butt section that is the same or just a little larger in diameter. Least this is what I do... ymmv, JT |
Flyline/Leader Connection Question
Skip Summer wrote:
Planning on using some mono to connect flyline to leader, using a nail knot. What pound test mono should I use? 4 weight flyline. This rod will be used for bluegills. Thanks in advance for the help. Skip Use a braided loop (floating or sinking depending on your line type). This kind of connection is much stronger than the nailknot. |
Flyline/Leader Connection Question
"Svend Tang-Petersen" wrote in message ... Skip Summer wrote: Planning on using some mono to connect flyline to leader, using a nail knot. What pound test mono should I use? 4 weight flyline. This rod will be used for bluegills. Thanks in advance for the help. Skip Use a braided loop (floating or sinking depending on your line type). This kind of connection is much stronger than the nailknot. Granted Skip is talking about a 4 weight and the braided loop is probably fine for that application, personally not my preference. If you are fishing for pike, steelhead, salmon, large species, I would suggest a nail knot connection... I know of a couple guys that fish pike allot and they went away from the braided loop after having pike jerk the loop off the fly line. I tried the braided loop when they came out and found the end of a floating line will sink. ymmv. JT |
Flyline/Leader Connection Question
Svend Tang-Petersen wrote:
Skip Summer wrote: Planning on using some mono to connect flyline to leader, using a nail knot. What pound test mono should I use? 4 weight flyline. This rod will be used for bluegills. Thanks in advance for the help. Use a braided loop (floating or sinking depending on your line type). This kind of connection is much stronger than the nailknot. I think that's both bad advice and misinformation. I've seen braided loops pull off and a fly line will break long before a well tied nail knot will fail. If it's the loop you're after I'd recommend a nail knot and a small perfection loop instead of a braided loop and super glue. -- Ken Fortenberry |
Flyline/Leader Connection Question
Ken Fortenberry wrote:
If it's the loop you're after I'd recommend a nail knot and a small perfection loop instead of a braided loop and super glue. The most elegant solution, if you want a loop connection for your leader, is a whipped loop. It's easy to tie. You'll need a razor blade, thread, a bobbin, and some head cement. See: http://www.flyfishinsalt.com/article...&categoryID=69 -- Cut "to the chase" for my email address. |
Flyline/Leader Connection Question
Ken Fortenberry wrote:
I think that's both bad advice and misinformation. I've seen braided loops pull off and a fly line will break long before a well tied nail knot will fail. I've used both but I use the braided loop exclusively now. The only time I have had one fail is when it goes hard, it doesn't do it's chinese finger compresion, after it has been on the line for a few years. Getting snagged on the bottom doesn't even pull it off, the tippet breaks first. I even had a braided salmon leader break while using a twenty pound tippet and the loop was still holding. If it's the loop you're after I'd recommend a nail knot and a small perfection loop instead of a braided loop and super glue. I don't use super glue, never have, it makes the braid go hard and it doesn't tighten on the fly line. I just use the piece of sleeve that comes with the loop. I make my own loops now from braided backing, much cheaper :) -- E-Mail:- Website:- http://www.ftscotland.co.uk Looking for a webhost? Try http://www.1and1.co.uk/?k_id=2966019 |
Flyline/Leader Connection Question
On Wed, 16 Jun 2004 16:11:45 -0600, rw
wrote: The most elegant solution, if you want a loop connection for your leader, is a whipped loop. It's easy to tie. You'll need a razor blade, thread, a bobbin, and some head cement. I used to do all my lines that way, now I use a braided loop but I whip finish where the sleeve would go and coat the thread with Aquaseal. -- Charlie... |
Flyline/Leader Connection Question
|
Flyline/Leader Connection Question
None of the below. Its the result of actual mechanical testing.
I think that's both bad advice and misinformation. I've seen braided loops pull off and a fly line will break long before a well tied nail knot will fail. If it's the loop you're after I'd recommend a nail knot and a small perfection loop instead of a braided loop and super glue. -- Ken Fortenberry |
Flyline/Leader Connection Question
Svend Tang-Petersen wrote:
None of the below. Its the result of actual mechanical testing. There are "mechanical tests" that prove a braided loop is a stronger connection than a nail knot ? That doesn't jibe with my experience but I'd be interested to read the actual study. -- Ken Fortenberry |
Flyline/Leader Connection Question
Our club does a knots and leader seminar once or twice a year. Its held
by a retired NASA mechanical engineer who brings along a stress testing device. (Imagine a big spring you can attach your line too. As you pull on the line the spring expands and pushes an indicator along a scale measuring basically force applied (spring: F=k*expansion). When the knot/line breaks the indicator stays at the max expansion so you can read at what force the line broke). He has tested all sorts of knots, leader systems, leader materials (some have less breaking strength if you spit on the leader when you thighten the knot) etc.. I think the nailknot breaks at 80% of line strength, where as a properly done braid is close to 100%. The man problem with the nailknot is that it basically strips off the coating of your flyline. If you think about a nailknot only grips your flyline over a length of roughly 1/12 inch, but a braid is usually 2.5 - 3 inches long so its gripping the flyline over a significantly larger area. Its weak point it the loop, and if your braids slip they weren't done properly. He (Bill Nash)has a nice little booklet showing various line system and knot strengths and did an in-class test that was very illustrative using a standart line and leader setup as is usually recommended but the line manufacturers. He does a lot of striper fishing which is what got him into the testing. Ill see if I can get a copy of his booklet for you. (mail my with your address). |
Flyline/Leader Connection Question
Ken Fortenberry wrote:
Svend Tang-Petersen wrote: None of the below. Its the result of actual mechanical testing. There are "mechanical tests" that prove a braided loop is a stronger connection than a nail knot ? That doesn't jibe with my experience but I'd be interested to read the actual study. The question is moot. Even a poorly tied nail knot or braided loop or perfection loop in heavy mono will be far stronger than the tippet, unless you're doing something very wrong. I dislike loop-to-loop connections whenever delicacy of presentation is an issue. For sal****er fishing, steelhead fishing, shooting heads, etc. they can be handy, but I still think being able to tie on a butt section with a nail knot, and a leader to that with a blood knot, is the best combination. -- Cut "to the chase" for my email address. |
Flyline/Leader Connection Question
|
Flyline/Leader Connection Question
yes and no. If you are using 4pound tippet and a knot that is only 80% your tippet strength is effectively 3.6 pounds. So tying proper knots will allow you to use thinner materials and thus a more delicate presentation. The question is moot. Even a poorly tied nail knot or braided loop or perfection loop in heavy mono will be far stronger than the tippet, unless you're doing something very wrong. I dislike loop-to-loop connections whenever delicacy of presentation is an issue. For sal****er fishing, steelhead fishing, shooting heads, etc. they can be handy, but I still think being able to tie on a butt section with a nail knot, and a leader to that with a blood knot, is the best combination. -- Cut "to the chase" for my email address. |
Flyline/Leader Connection Question
Svend Tang-Petersen wrote:
http://hometown.aol.com/billsknots/ Nice link. Thanks, Svend. -- Ken Fortenberry |
Flyline/Leader Connection Question
Svend Tang-Petersen wrote:
yes and no. If you are using 4pound tippet and a knot that is only 80% your tippet strength is effectively 3.6 pounds. So tying proper knots will allow you to use thinner materials and thus a more delicate presentation. I entirely agree that good knots are important, but I thought we were talking about flyline/leader connections, where the breaking tension is maybe 50 pounds. If you use an 80% knot, you're down to 40 pounds, and your 4-pound tippet is still an order of magnitude weaker. I prefer a flyline/leader connection that slips easily through the guides, presents the least possible wind resistance, turns over the leader, and lands quietly on the water. If I want to change leaders, which I very rarely do, I can tie a blood knot to the butt section about as fast as I can change a loop-to-loop connection. -- Cut "to the chase" for my email address. |
Flyline/Leader Connection Question
"Skip Summer" wrote in message om... Planning on using some mono to connect flyline to leader, using a nail knot. What pound test mono should I use? 4 weight flyline. This rod will be used for bluegills. Thanks in advance for the help. The # test you will be using is irrelevant, you want the diameter of the mono attached to the fly line to be 2/3 rd's of the diameter of the fly line. . |
Flyline/Leader Connection Question
Sure, but you can apply the argument backwards:
If your fly breaks off you use a better knot. The next thing that gives is you bloodknot (if you make your own leaders), so you improve that. Ultimately what you want is a leader system where things break at the strenght they are supposed to and not at 50-60% of that. Off course at some point you have improved each section such that the thing that breaks is your tippet, without having to improve the butt and line connection. As long as you know how your leader is designed and that it does what you wanted, then fine. Wrt the leader/line connection the nailknot is between 70-80% of leader butt strength, but the braid is 100%. |
Flyline/Leader Connection Question
This is getting off the original topic a bit, but --
Do you find that having a loop connection decreases your ability to turnover the leader? I have troubles turning over my leader, at times, probably because I'm still working on my casting. I'd heard that loop-to-loop can cause some difficulty in that area, and for that reason I've just stuck with the nail knot. But, if all y'all experts use loop-to-loops, I'd be happy to do so myself, as it seems a lot easier. (Um, that brings up one more question: do you just attach your leaders with the loop the manufacturer has already tied at the end, or do you tie a better one?) Because I do find it convenient to have a loop at the end of the line, I nail-knot a short section of .017" mono to the line, with a perfection loop at the end. Costs less than five cents, plus a little bit of my time, and will probably outlast the fly line. Besides, nail knots "build character." |
Flyline/Leader Connection Question
"Tim G" wrote in message om... This is getting off the original topic a bit, but -- Do you find that having a loop connection decreases your ability to turnover the leader? I have troubles turning over my leader, at times, probably because I'm still working on my casting. I'd heard that loop-to-loop can cause some difficulty in that area, and for that reason I've just stuck with the nail knot. But, if all y'all experts use loop-to-loops, I'd be happy to do so myself, as it seems a lot easier. (Um, that brings up one more question: do you just attach your leaders with the loop the manufacturer has already tied at the end, or do you tie a better one?) I use a "nail-less" nail knot. Easy to tie, and works well. I went away from the loop-to-loop connections a number of years ago, for the very reason you mention. As far I am concerned, the fewer knots, bumps, loops, connections, and monofilament hangnails the better. The leaders I use don't have a loop on the end. Tim Lysyk |
Flyline/Leader Connection Question
"Ken Fortenberry" wrote: I think that's both bad advice and misinformation. I've seen braided loops pull off and a fly line will break long before a well tied nail knot will fail. I agree. I have never had a nail knot fail, and properly tied, you won't even feel it going through the guides. On *most* new fly lines, I use a nail knot to tie on a butt section of red Amnesia mono (I think it's about 25 lb test). I use a barrel knot to tie the leader to the Amnesia; so whenever I need to tie on a new leader, the butt section (and not the fly line) loses a half inch. |
Flyline/Leader Connection Question
Hi skip,
The old rule of thumb was to have the butt section 2/3 the diameter of the end of the fly line. Another approach is to have the butt section at least the same diameter of the large end of your knotless tapered leader. I think that a 7 1/2' 2x leader would be fine. Usually the larger pound test knotless tapered leaders have a larger butt diameter for turning over bigger flies.. -- Bill Kiene Kiene's Fly Shop Sacramento, CA, USA Web site: www.kiene.com "Skip Summer" wrote in message om... Planning on using some mono to connect flyline to leader, using a nail knot. What pound test mono should I use? 4 weight flyline. This rod will be used for bluegills. Thanks in advance for the help. Skip |
Flyline/Leader Connection Question
On Wed, 16 Jun 2004 19:18:24 -0600, rw
wrote: I prefer a flyline/leader connection that slips easily through the guides, presents the least possible wind resistance, turns over the leader, and lands quietly on the water. I've found that loop to loop connections go through the guides smoother than nail knots, and have not found any difference in turning over the leader or quiet landing. I've never considered the wind resistance issue. -- Charlie... |
Flyline/Leader Connection Question
"rw" wrote in message m... ...I prefer a flyline/leader connection that slips easily through the guides, Leader link presents the least possible wind resistance, Leader link. turns over the leader, Leader link. and lands quietly on the water. Leader link. If I want to change leaders... Leader link. Wolfgang some debates, while easy enough to follow, are nevertheless impossible to understand. |
Flyline/Leader Connection Question
"Svend Tang-Petersen" wrote in message ... Our club does a knots and leader seminar once or twice a year. Its held by a retired NASA mechanical engineer who brings along a stress testing device. (Imagine a big spring you can attach your line too. As you pull on the line the spring expands and pushes an indicator along a scale measuring basically force applied (spring: F=k*expansion). When the knot/line breaks the indicator stays at the max expansion so you can read at what force the line broke). He has tested all sorts of knots, leader systems, leader materials (some have less breaking strength if you spit on the leader when you thighten the knot) etc.. How did the "no knot" eyelets fair in these tests, if they were tested. I used these for years without problems. Of course my main quarry was panfish and such when I was a kid. I am just now getting back into flyfishing after a 20 year absence. lou |
Flyline/Leader Connection Question
"Lou W" wrote in message news:HthAc.1340$5t2.450@fed1read01... "Svend Tang-Petersen" wrote in message ... Our club does a knots and leader seminar once or twice a year. Its held by a retired NASA mechanical engineer who brings along a stress testing device. (Imagine a big spring you can attach your line too. As you pull on the line the spring expands and pushes an indicator along a scale measuring basically force applied (spring: F=k*expansion). When the knot/line breaks the indicator stays at the max expansion so you can read at what force the line broke). He has tested all sorts of knots, leader systems, leader materials (some have less breaking strength if you spit on the leader when you thighten the knot) etc.. How did the "no knot" eyelets fair in these tests, if they were tested. I used these for years without problems. Of course my main quarry was panfish and such when I was a kid. I am just now getting back into flyfishing after a 20 year absence. Don't know about any formal tests done with them, but there are a several problems. In the first place, they are a bit of a pain in the ass to get into the end of the fly line. They are made of steel.....that makes them heavy. As small as they are, they will sink the end of the fly line. You still have to knot the leader to the eye. This necessarily means the leader is tied to a surface perpendicular to its own length.....a more or less perfect hinge. Being made of steel, they WILL rust. This results in a pitted surface that saws through the leader knot pretty efficiently as it hinges. They rely on barbs, much like those on hooks, to remain fastened to the line. The barbs have fairly sharp edges which eventually cut the line. I've tried them myself and know a number of others who have also. I don't know anyone who has used them for long. Wolfgang |
Flyline/Leader Connection Question
Wolfgang wrote:
"rw" wrote in message m... ...I prefer a flyline/leader connection that slips easily through the guides, Leader link I like Leader Links as well, but I have had them break before. I've only had them break on one side to I didn't lose my leader or fly but it did require me to replace the Leader Link. Russell |
Flyline/Leader Connection Question
"Russell" wrote in message ... Wolfgang wrote: "rw" wrote in message m... ...I prefer a flyline/leader connection that slips easily through the guides, Leader link I like Leader Links as well, but I have had them break before. I've only had them break on one side to I didn't lose my leader or fly but it did require me to replace the Leader Link. We've seen several reports of breakage here over the last few years. Like you, I've had one break on one side, but never completely. I fished the half broken one for several weeks before replacing it. I don't remember for sure, but I suspect this one was very old. I've got three or four reels strung up with various lines for my 7 wt. All of the lines and leader links on these are at least ten years old. No problems. Wolfgang |
Flyline/Leader Connection Question
http://www.flyanglersonline.com/
SA has a new L2L system on the market. I will be part of a field test group. If you're interested, contact me offlist. -- Stev Lenon 91B20 '68-'69 Drowning flies to Dark Star http://web.tampabay.rr.com/stevglo/i...age92kword.htm |
Flyline/Leader Connection Question
I have to admit I have never considered a Leader Link. I think Ernie
Harrison uses them and I found this article that seemed pretty informative: http://www.hotspotfishing.com/public...s/fish-254.asp Chris 'padishar creel' Fanning "Wolfgang" wrote in message ... "rw" wrote in message m... ...I prefer a flyline/leader connection that slips easily through the guides, Leader link presents the least possible wind resistance, Leader link. turns over the leader, Leader link. and lands quietly on the water. Leader link. If I want to change leaders... Leader link. Wolfgang some debates, while easy enough to follow, are nevertheless impossible to understand. |
Flyline/Leader Connection Question
"Padishar Creel" wrote in message ... I have to admit I have never considered a Leader Link. Try it. You'll like it. Wolfgang |
Flyline/Leader Connection Question
Padishar Creel wrote:
I have to admit I have never considered a Leader Link. I think Ernie Harrison uses them and I found this article that seemed pretty informative: I use them, too, and I think they work well, but I'm not dogmatic about them. A nail knot works just as well. A needle knot is even better. -- Cut "to the chase" for my email address. |
Flyline/Leader Connection Question
Wolfgang wrote:
["no-knot" eyelets] Don't know about any formal tests done with them, but there are a several problems. In the first place, they are a bit of a pain in the ass to get into the end of the fly line. They are made of steel.....that makes them heavy. As small as they are, they will sink the end of the fly line. You still have to knot the leader to the eye. This necessarily means the leader is tied to a surface perpendicular to its own length.....a more or less perfect hinge. Being made of steel, they WILL rust. This results in a pitted surface that saws through the leader knot pretty efficiently as it hinges. They rely on barbs, much like those on hooks, to remain fastened to the line. The barbs have fairly sharp edges which eventually cut the line. I've tried them myself and know a number of others who have also. I don't know anyone who has used them for long. I remember when I first started flyfishing back in the early 80's, I tried them thinking that it would be nice to be able to avoid tying nailknots, etc. (funny how things never really change). They were horrible. Worst of all was the hinging you describe above, as the knot would swivel at the tie-point with each false cast. And I don't know if it was just my lack of knot-tying skills, but I remember it simply being a pain to knot the leader to the eye. When I picked up the sport again I found a few of them sitting at the bottom of a box with my old tackle. Even twenty years later the image of trying to use the things was fresh. Since getting back into it again, I mostly played around with nailknots and loop-to-loop connections, but after reading various threads about leader links, I finally decided to give them a try. And frankly, I haven't had any problems with them whatsoever, as long as I make sure to test the knots for slippage after they are inserted in the links. I assume they have a somewhat limited life and could distort or crack over time, but it's easy enough to replace them every so often to avoid that. I know it's not considered the "proper" connection by some, but aside from aesthetics, I can't really think of any reason not to use them. I'll use a nailknot for attaching backing to line, but now I rarely bother with it for line to leader connections. Chuck Vance (just call me lazy) |
Flyline/Leader Connection Question
Charlie Wilson wrote: "Ken Fortenberry" wrote: I think that's both bad advice and misinformation. I've seen braided loops pull off and a fly line will break long before a well tied nail knot will fail. I agree. I have never had a nail knot fail, and properly tied, you won't even feel it going through the guides. On *most* new fly lines, I use a nail knot to tie on a butt section of red Amnesia mono (I think it's about 25 lb test). I use a barrel knot to tie the leader to the Amnesia; so whenever I need to tie on a new leader, the butt section (and not the fly line) loses a half inch. That's what I do too (except for the red Amnesia). The butts section lasts at least a season even with alot of fishing. Willi |
Flyline/Leader Connection Question
Granted Skip is talking about a 4 weight and the braided loop is probably fine for that application, personally not my preference. If you are fishing for pike, steelhead, salmon, large species, I would suggest a nail knot connection... I know of a couple guys that fish pike allot and they went away from the braided loop after having pike jerk the loop off the fly line. I tried the braided loop when they came out and found the end of a floating line will sink. ymmv. JT There are two kinds of materials used for braids. The one commonly sold will sink, but there's also a floating version. |
Flyline/Leader Connection Question
"Svend Tang-Petersen" wrote in message ... Granted Skip is talking about a 4 weight and the braided loop is probably fine for that application, personally not my preference. If you are fishing for pike, steelhead, salmon, large species, I would suggest a nail knot connection... I know of a couple guys that fish pike allot and they went away from the braided loop after having pike jerk the loop off the fly line. I tried the braided loop when they came out and found the end of a floating line will sink. ymmv. JT There are two kinds of materials used for braids. The one commonly sold will sink, but there's also a floating version. The only braided loops that I have used are the braided loops that came with the Cortland fly lines I have used. Last year I purchased a floating 444 (peach, my favorite) and I can't remember if it came with a loop or not, so I don't know if they still send the loops with their lines? However, the floating Lazer Lines that I bought in the previous years had them and I had trouble with the tip of my Lazers sinking... I figured, Cortland would send the floating version with a floating line... Do you know if the loops sent with a floating Cortland Series fly line are the floating version? I must have a 1/2 dozen of them in my leader pouch, not sure why I have hung on to them? JT |
Flyline/Leader Connection Question
All of the sal****er fishermen that I have had contact with use the braided
loop with two nail knots close together towards the top of the braid. The braid below the lowest knot will hold like a chinese finger puzzle. This is important in lines that do not crush. Most trout lines are made using a woven core that is hollow and wil crush when a knot is drawn tight. the woven core does a great job of holding the plastic /PVC in place. Many sal****er lines are now made with a woven core that is not hollow or a mono solid core that will not crush. Neither is great at holding the plastic/PVC in place. IF you use a single nail knot and a mono loop, there is the possiblility that a large fish will just strip off all of the plastic/PVC below the knot. -- --------------------------------------------------------------------- "Are you still wasting your time with spam?... There is a solution!" Protected by GIANT Company's Spam Inspector The most powerful anti-spam software available. http://mail.spaminspector.com "Skip Summer" wrote in message om... Planning on using some mono to connect flyline to leader, using a nail knot. What pound test mono should I use? 4 weight flyline. This rod will be used for bluegills. Thanks in advance for the help. Skip |
All times are GMT +1. The time now is 04:04 AM. |
|
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2006 FishingBanter