FishingBanter

FishingBanter (http://www.fishingbanter.com/index.php)
-   Fly Fishing (http://www.fishingbanter.com/forumdisplay.php?f=6)
-   -   fishing, casting, and recruiting (http://www.fishingbanter.com/showthread.php?t=8102)

snakefiddler June 27th, 2004 02:02 AM

fishing, casting, and recruiting
 
wow- what a day! hit the streams with my son, (18), who is here for the
summer. stopped in appalachian anglers first, to pick up a couple of new
flies- god, i could go nuts in there- and after inquiring as to theo, whom i
found out is in alaska, i think, we headed out to the waters of the watauga
river. there were a couple of other anglers out there, who reported little
action, and after about an hour there, with the same result, we headed to
another stream up on the parkway. you know which one i'm talkin about,
opie. nice trout waters, and beautiful scenery. hung out there for a
couple of hours during which time i fell into some fairly deep, very fast
moving water- no injury to report, and i was saved from being swept away by
the rocks that locked me in! i really thought i had good footing, and i
knew there was a little pool of deeper water there, but my efforts at
caution did nothing to help me. came out with a couple of scratches on my
leg, and that was it. actually, the water felt pretty good, but i stayed
wet the rest of the day. after that adventure, my son and i decided it was
time to eat some lunch, and so we layed out our food on a rock, and sat
down to eat. a few minutes into lunch, i noticed a prolific hatch. i got
all excited and put down my food, and picked up my rod. however, another
half an hour didn't help zero catch score for the day thus far. but my son
witnessed his first hatch, and appreciated the significance after i
explained it to him.
we then decided to head to price park, so that i could practice casting, and
while doing so, a young man came up to me, and struck a fly fishin related
conversation. turns out he is a guide who lives in michigan, and is down
here for the summer to teach fly fishin to some kids at camp. i told him i
was just learning, and so he asked me to show him my cast. he then spent
about half an hour with me, workin on my cast, and by the time he re-joined
his friends to play ball, i was casting with great confidence, and pretty
well. i heard one of his friends say to him that he was a really good
teacher, becasue he had taught me that well, that fast. (so, you were right
mark-good suggestion, only it didn't happen on campus G). anyway, my
son wanted to try it, and damned if he isn't a natural. he was casting that
line out, with nice loops, and layin it down straight, and before we left
the park, he was hooked. all the way home he kept talkin about how much he
wants a fly rod, and he wants to go back out tommorrow. he just fell right
into it. good stuff! all in all an exciting, satisfying, and exhausting
day. *and* i feel good about my casting. ;-)


snakefiddler- can't wait for october........



Frank Church June 27th, 2004 03:49 AM

fishing, casting, and recruiting
 
"snakefiddler" wrote in

.....snip an obvious fine day for ol' snake...

Good on ya Jen, you're actually moving faster at this flyfishing thing then
I imagined you would. Getting casting lessons, observing hatches (I ain't
never identified a hatch, btw) and now your son is getting the itch. You
have embarked on a long, expensive, interesting and satisfying hobby, where
will it all end? Maybe for you, the rest of your life I would hazard a
guess. See ya in Oct.

Frank Church


snakefiddler June 27th, 2004 04:31 AM

fishing, casting, and recruiting
 

"Frank Church" wrote in message
9.11...
"snakefiddler" wrote in

....snip an obvious fine day for ol' snake...

Good on ya Jen, you're actually moving faster at this flyfishing thing

then
I imagined you would.


i am *so* diggin it. i'm looking forward to doing a lot of fishing this
week, while i am between sessions for summer school.

Getting casting lessons,

folks seem to be very willing to help..

observing hatches

we saw two today, at two different locations.

(I ain't
never identified a hatch, btw) and now your son is getting the itch. You
have embarked on a long, expensive, interesting and satisfying hobby,

where
will it all end? Maybe for you, the rest of your life I would hazard a
guess.


i reckon you're right about that. this is really good stuff. and now that
i am beginning to feel good about my casting, it is even more exciting.
i found out from my aunt the other day that my great grandmother was an
avid fisherwoman- did a great deal of fishing in indiana, in the white
river. i'm sure you're familiar with it.

See ya in Oct.

lookin forward to it :-)

snake

Frank Church




B J Conner June 27th, 2004 05:20 AM

fishing, casting, and recruiting
 
Babylonian Proverb: "The gods do not deduct from man's allotted span the
hours spent in fishing."

Sounds like your gaining time.

"snakefiddler" wrote in message
...

"Frank Church" wrote in message
9.11...
"snakefiddler" wrote in

....snip an obvious fine day for ol' snake...

Good on ya Jen, you're actually moving faster at this flyfishing thing

then
I imagined you would.


i am *so* diggin it. i'm looking forward to doing a lot of fishing this
week, while i am between sessions for summer school.

Getting casting lessons,

folks seem to be very willing to help..

observing hatches

we saw two today, at two different locations.

(I ain't
never identified a hatch, btw) and now your son is getting the itch. You
have embarked on a long, expensive, interesting and satisfying hobby,

where
will it all end? Maybe for you, the rest of your life I would hazard a
guess.


i reckon you're right about that. this is really good stuff. and now

that
i am beginning to feel good about my casting, it is even more exciting.
i found out from my aunt the other day that my great grandmother was an
avid fisherwoman- did a great deal of fishing in indiana, in the white
river. i'm sure you're familiar with it.

See ya in Oct.

lookin forward to it :-)

snake

Frank Church






riverman June 27th, 2004 10:05 AM

fishing, casting, and recruiting
 

"Frank Church" wrote in message
9.11...
"snakefiddler" wrote in

....snip an obvious fine day for ol' snake...

Good on ya Jen, you're actually moving faster at this flyfishing thing

then
I imagined you would. Getting casting lessons, observing hatches (I ain't
never identified a hatch, btw)...


I was going to work this into my Wales TR, but my summer grad school seems
to dominating all my time and that TR seems to be fading, so I'll tell it
here.

I SAW A HATCH! I mean, REALLY saw a hatch!

I was fishing i Brecon, at the bottom of this pool behind a bridge abutment,
and noticed that there were a growing number of little white bugs starting
to accumulate in the 'wind eddy' behind the bridge. The fish (what few there
were) were starting to rise in the river eddy there, so I instantly
recognized that a hatch was going on. I was standing about waist deep in
fairly clear water with a grey-green bottom, and as I looked down at the
water around me, I saw the occasional 'thing' float by.....maybe one per
cubic meter of water. I gently reached down and trapped one, and bygod, it
was a nymph. An honest-to-mergatroyd nymph! I instantly realized why PTs and
GRHEs work so well...at first glance, this thing was the spitting image of a
#28 PT, but with slightly more pronounced legs in the upper half. It was
such a total A-HAH! moment that I was overjoyed. I had always imagined that,
during hatches, the water was saturated with these things, and I never had
any real understanding of how they moved, or why a fish would select my fly
instead of the real thing. But seeing these in the water made the mental
light bulbs all light up.

Two real interesting observations I had from this experience:
1) Contrary to what I have read, not one of these nymphs was floating in the
'head up' position. They were all horizontal, with the head/thorax upstream.
The shape of the body was the exact tapered shape of a well-tied PT, but
instead of rising the way the books all show them, they were rising
horizontally. This might have been because they were getting swept
downstream in the mediocre current, but the fish downstream of me were
taking them more often than the fish in the eddy upstream. That tells me a
lot about the importance of keeping some tension on your line as they drift
in the current, to keep them horizontally. This is also why they get taken
at the end of the drift, when they are sweeping upwards.

2) (this is a biggie): Every single one of the nymphs I saw was at
approximately the same depth as it floated past me. I figure that they were
all coming from the same general source (somewhere near the downstream end
of the eddy, where the current could steal them), and were rising at about
the same rate. That means that there was a very specific 'diagonal rising
zone' that they would be in; deeper down at the eddy, reaching the surface
somewhere downstream of me. If I were casting a PT in the current, it would
be very important to know where this 'rising zone' was so that I could get
my nymph into it. I imagine that a feeding fish would not be looking for a
nymph along the bottom if the naturals were inches from the surface, for
example.

Anyway, I was overjoyed to actually see this thing in action. Like so many
things that you have a rich mental image of....the real thing had absolutely
no resemblance to what I imagined it would look like.

--riverman



riverman June 27th, 2004 02:03 PM

fishing, casting, and recruiting
 

"rw" wrote in message
m...
riverman wrote:

I SAW A HATCH! I mean, REALLY saw a hatch!


Cool. Fishing a mayfly hatch is the essential flyfishing experience,
IMO. The day before yesterday I went to the Big Wood a second time for
the green drake hatch. These are big bugs -- size 12 -- and the fish go
nuts for them. It was outstanding.


Did you, or have you ever noticed what I mentioned about the 'diagonal
rising zone' of the nymphs on a stream? I always sort of figured that the
nymphs would be rising in a sort of inverted snowstorm: all going upwards at
all depths of the water column. What I saw was quite different, up by the
source eddy, there were none near the surface, and I suppose a dozen meters
downstream, there were none at the bottom.

--riverman



rw June 27th, 2004 02:49 PM

fishing, casting, and recruiting
 
riverman wrote:

I SAW A HATCH! I mean, REALLY saw a hatch!


Cool. Fishing a mayfly hatch is the essential flyfishing experience,
IMO. The day before yesterday I went to the Big Wood a second time for
the green drake hatch. These are big bugs -- size 12 -- and the fish go
nuts for them. It was outstanding.

I lost what I thought was my last green drake dry fly on a fish
(AARRGH!), so I tried a a few flies that I thought might work -- a #12
parachute adams, a very small green-bodied stimulator, and a #12 green
EHC. The fish utterly ignored them. Then I found an actual green drake
pattern in my crowded flybox and again caught fish. It brought home to
me the importance of matching the hatch under these conditions.

--
Cut "to the chase" for my email address.

riverman June 27th, 2004 03:05 PM

fishing, casting, and recruiting
 

"rw" wrote in message
m...
riverman wrote:

Did you, or have you ever noticed what I mentioned about the 'diagonal
rising zone' of the nymphs on a stream? I always sort of figured that

the
nymphs would be rising in a sort of inverted snowstorm: all going

upwards at
all depths of the water column. What I saw was quite different, up by

the
source eddy, there were none near the surface, and I suppose a dozen

meters
downstream, there were none at the bottom.


I'm not entirely sure what you mean by "diagonal rising zone." I've
never seen nymphs rising to the surface. Maybe your eyesight is better
than mine.

One thing I have noticed, and particularly in this green drake hatch, is
that the bugs weren't emerging all over the river. They appeared in a
certain type of current -- fast and deep. The river is still pretty
high, but clear. These were not places you'd normally expect to find
trout holding. The only reason they were there was to feed actively, and
they didn't have much time to nail the big duns.

One cool thing is that you could tell where the mayflies were emerging
by watching birds. Robin, blackbirds, and western tanagers would swoop
out from the back to nab duns in the air, and tree swallows would pick
them off the surface.


You can use the bird situation to model the 'diagonal rising zone'. If the
emergers were coming up at a certain spot in the river, and there was as
light breeze (say, blowing southwards), then the birds would not all be
congregating above that spot on the river, at all heights. The ones who were
feeding low to the water would be right above that spot, but the duns that
got past those birds would be blown to the south as they rose. So you'd
expect the birds at higher elevations to be farther to the south. This is
the 'diagonal rising zone' of the duns.

In the water, its the same. Imagine a deep pool of slow water, with an
outlet on the downstream side. If there are rising nymphs throughout the
water column in the deep pool, then there are nymphs getting sucked into the
outlet current at all levels. But, a few feet downstream from the pool,
there won't be any nymphs at the bottom; they will have risen a few inches,
so there will be an 'empty zone' along the bottom of the river from that
point on down. Dragging a nymph through that zone will be useless. The
'diagonal rising zone' is the diagonal zone where the nymphs are, starting
at the bottom near the pool and rising to the surface several meters
downstream, depending on the current.

In Wales, all the nymphs I saw swhere I was standing were between 1 and 2
feet below the surface: I looked deeper and never saw one go by at knee
level, and (in an effort to keep my sleeves dry) I tried to find one near
the surface to scoop up, but never saw one shallower than 1 foot deep. Also,
there were no fish rising near me, but they were rising about 10 meters
downstream from me, or in the calm pool above me. I suspect the fish near me
were eating nymphs that were 1-2 feet deep, that the fish 5 meters
downstream from me were eating nymphs that were 6 inches to 1 foot deep, and
the fish 10 meters downstream were eating nymphs on the surface.

--riverman



snakefiddler June 27th, 2004 03:24 PM

fishing, casting, and recruiting
 

"riverman" wrote in message
...

"Frank Church" wrote in message
9.11...
"snakefiddler" wrote in

....snip an obvious fine day for ol' snake...

Good on ya Jen, you're actually moving faster at this flyfishing thing

then
I imagined you would. Getting casting lessons, observing hatches (I

ain't
never identified a hatch, btw)...


I was going to work this into my Wales TR, but my summer grad school seems
to dominating all my time and that TR seems to be fading, so I'll tell it
here.

I SAW A HATCH! I mean, REALLY saw a hatch!

I was fishing i Brecon, at the bottom of this pool behind a bridge

abutment,
and noticed that there were a growing number of little white bugs starting
to accumulate in the 'wind eddy' behind the bridge. The fish (what few

there
were) were starting to rise in the river eddy there, so I instantly
recognized that a hatch was going on. I was standing about waist deep in
fairly clear water with a grey-green bottom, and as I looked down at the
water around me, I saw the occasional 'thing' float by.....maybe one per
cubic meter of water. I gently reached down and trapped one, and bygod, it
was a nymph. An honest-to-mergatroyd nymph! I instantly realized why PTs

and
GRHEs work so well...at first glance, this thing was the spitting image of

a
#28 PT, but with slightly more pronounced legs in the upper half. It was
such a total A-HAH! moment that I was overjoyed. I had always imagined

that,
during hatches, the water was saturated with these things, and I never

had
any real understanding of how they moved, or why a fish would select my

fly
instead of the real thing. But seeing these in the water made the mental
light bulbs all light up.

Two real interesting observations I had from this experience:
1) Contrary to what I have read, not one of these nymphs was floating in

the
'head up' position. They were all horizontal, with the head/thorax

upstream.
The shape of the body was the exact tapered shape of a well-tied PT, but
instead of rising the way the books all show them, they were rising
horizontally. This might have been because they were getting swept
downstream in the mediocre current, but the fish downstream of me were
taking them more often than the fish in the eddy upstream. That tells me a
lot about the importance of keeping some tension on your line as they

drift
in the current, to keep them horizontally. This is also why they get taken
at the end of the drift, when they are sweeping upwards.

2) (this is a biggie): Every single one of the nymphs I saw was at
approximately the same depth as it floated past me. I figure that they

were
all coming from the same general source (somewhere near the downstream end
of the eddy, where the current could steal them), and were rising at about
the same rate. That means that there was a very specific 'diagonal rising
zone' that they would be in; deeper down at the eddy, reaching the surface
somewhere downstream of me. If I were casting a PT in the current, it

would
be very important to know where this 'rising zone' was so that I could get
my nymph into it. I imagine that a feeding fish would not be looking for a
nymph along the bottom if the naturals were inches from the surface, for
example.

Anyway, I was overjoyed to actually see this thing in action. Like so many
things that you have a rich mental image of....the real thing had

absolutely
no resemblance to what I imagined it would look like.

--riverman



god, i got excited just reading your post, and i wasn't even there! i know
i haven't been at this very long, but i *have* figured out that an
experience like that is what fly fishermen dream about. to have all that
rich information in the water, and possess the knowledge and ability to put
it all together, *and* make it work must be thrilling.
i don't believe in an elitist society, either in the functional world nor
the leisure, but i sure can see how having the ability to understand all the
intricacies involved in fly fishing, and manipulate them to success can
instill a great deal of pride in one's fishing abilities.

great stuff-
snakefiddler



rw June 27th, 2004 03:53 PM

fishing, casting, and recruiting
 
riverman wrote:

Did you, or have you ever noticed what I mentioned about the 'diagonal
rising zone' of the nymphs on a stream? I always sort of figured that the
nymphs would be rising in a sort of inverted snowstorm: all going upwards at
all depths of the water column. What I saw was quite different, up by the
source eddy, there were none near the surface, and I suppose a dozen meters
downstream, there were none at the bottom.


I'm not entirely sure what you mean by "diagonal rising zone." I've
never seen nymphs rising to the surface. Maybe your eyesight is better
than mine.

One thing I have noticed, and particularly in this green drake hatch, is
that the bugs weren't emerging all over the river. They appeared in a
certain type of current -- fast and deep. The river is still pretty
high, but clear. These were not places you'd normally expect to find
trout holding. The only reason they were there was to feed actively, and
they didn't have much time to nail the big duns.

One cool thing is that you could tell where the mayflies were emerging
by watching birds. Robin, blackbirds, and western tanagers would swoop
out from the back to nab duns in the air, and tree swallows would pick
them off the surface.

--
Cut "to the chase" for my email address.

rw June 27th, 2004 05:40 PM

Coolest hatches (was fishing, casting, and recruiting)
 
riverman wrote:

You can use the bird situation to model the 'diagonal rising zone'. If the
emergers were coming up at a certain spot in the river, and there was as
light breeze (say, blowing southwards), then the birds would not all be
congregating above that spot on the river, at all heights. The ones who were
feeding low to the water would be right above that spot, but the duns that
got past those birds would be blown to the south as they rose. So you'd
expect the birds at higher elevations to be farther to the south. This is
the 'diagonal rising zone' of the duns.

In the water, its the same. Imagine a deep pool of slow water, with an
outlet on the downstream side. If there are rising nymphs throughout the
water column in the deep pool, then there are nymphs getting sucked into the
outlet current at all levels. But, a few feet downstream from the pool,
there won't be any nymphs at the bottom; they will have risen a few inches,
so there will be an 'empty zone' along the bottom of the river from that
point on down. Dragging a nymph through that zone will be useless. The
'diagonal rising zone' is the diagonal zone where the nymphs are, starting
at the bottom near the pool and rising to the surface several meters
downstream, depending on the current.


That clears it up. As I understand what you're saying, the current is
taking the emerging nymphs downstream as they rise through the water
column, so you find them at different depths depending on how far
downstream they are from the bottom.

Fishing emergers is something that's mostly beyond my experience. I've
had some success with midge emergers on the San Juan, but I mostly try
to dead-drift nymphs near the bottom. Willi is the by far the best
emerger flyfisher I've ever seen. I've watched him catch some big fish
that way, when everyone else was getting frustrated fishing dry flies.
It seems to me like something that has to be learned with much
experience and great attention to what's going on with the bugs and the
fish.

I'm going to offer a question for ROFF: What are the coolest hatches
you've ever seen? Here's my list:

- Brown Drakes on Silver Creek, Idaho. These huge mayflies (#8) make a
phenomenal spinner fall in the evening, and continue through the night.
You can catch fish in the pitch black of night, striking by ear.

- Morning Tricos on Silver Creek. Another spinner fall. It requires a
dead calm, or the tiny bugs are blown off the water. The fish feed on
pods, hoovering in rafts of bugs. You fish downstream, aiming your fly
into a mouth.

- Salmonflies on Marsh Creek and the Middle Fork of the Salmon. Huge
gyrocopter-like bugs that always look on the verge of crashing.

- Black caddis on the Bighorn. Keep your mouth closed.

- Green drakes on the Big Wood.

--
Cut "to the chase" for my email address.

Mark H. Bowen June 27th, 2004 08:06 PM

Coolest hatches (was fishing, casting, and recruiting)
 
I'm not sure of the insect type, as it was early in my ff experience but I
saw a hatch on Wilson Creek one time. The bugs were comin' to the top of
the water and looked like popcorn poppin'--HONESTLY. Their wings would
unfold (?), they would float with the current momentarily and then fly off.
It was really neat, as I had never seen anything like it, and I wasn't sure
what was happenin' at first. Finally it dawned on me what was taking place.
I had only read about hatches, in books, at that time.

I have since seen many bugs emerge in numbers, but never like my first
experience.

Mark
"rw" wrote in message
m...
riverman wrote:

You can use the bird situation to model the 'diagonal rising zone'. If

the
emergers were coming up at a certain spot in the river, and there was as
light breeze (say, blowing southwards), then the birds would not all be
congregating above that spot on the river, at all heights. The ones who

were
feeding low to the water would be right above that spot, but the duns

that
got past those birds would be blown to the south as they rose. So you'd
expect the birds at higher elevations to be farther to the south. This

is
the 'diagonal rising zone' of the duns.

In the water, its the same. Imagine a deep pool of slow water, with an
outlet on the downstream side. If there are rising nymphs throughout the
water column in the deep pool, then there are nymphs getting sucked into

the
outlet current at all levels. But, a few feet downstream from the pool,
there won't be any nymphs at the bottom; they will have risen a few

inches,
so there will be an 'empty zone' along the bottom of the river from that
point on down. Dragging a nymph through that zone will be useless. The
'diagonal rising zone' is the diagonal zone where the nymphs are,

starting
at the bottom near the pool and rising to the surface several meters
downstream, depending on the current.


That clears it up. As I understand what you're saying, the current is
taking the emerging nymphs downstream as they rise through the water
column, so you find them at different depths depending on how far
downstream they are from the bottom.

Fishing emergers is something that's mostly beyond my experience. I've
had some success with midge emergers on the San Juan, but I mostly try
to dead-drift nymphs near the bottom. Willi is the by far the best
emerger flyfisher I've ever seen. I've watched him catch some big fish
that way, when everyone else was getting frustrated fishing dry flies.
It seems to me like something that has to be learned with much
experience and great attention to what's going on with the bugs and the
fish.

I'm going to offer a question for ROFF: What are the coolest hatches
you've ever seen? Here's my list:

- Brown Drakes on Silver Creek, Idaho. These huge mayflies (#8) make a
phenomenal spinner fall in the evening, and continue through the night.
You can catch fish in the pitch black of night, striking by ear.

- Morning Tricos on Silver Creek. Another spinner fall. It requires a
dead calm, or the tiny bugs are blown off the water. The fish feed on
pods, hoovering in rafts of bugs. You fish downstream, aiming your fly
into a mouth.

- Salmonflies on Marsh Creek and the Middle Fork of the Salmon. Huge
gyrocopter-like bugs that always look on the verge of crashing.

- Black caddis on the Bighorn. Keep your mouth closed.

- Green drakes on the Big Wood.

--
Cut "to the chase" for my email address.




George Adams June 27th, 2004 08:40 PM

Coolest hatches (was fishing, casting, and recruiting)
 
From: rw


I'm going to offer a question for ROFF: What are the coolest hatches
you've ever seen? Here's my list:


- Brown Drakes on Silver Creek, Idaho. These huge mayflies (#8) make a
phenomenal spinner fall in the evening, and continue through the night.
You can catch fish in the pitch black of night, striking by ear.


- Morning Tricos on Silver Creek. Another spinner fall. It requires a
dead calm, or the tiny bugs are blown off the water. The fish feed on
pods, hoovering in rafts of bugs. You fish downstream, aiming your fly
into a mouth.



- Salmonflies on Marsh Creek and the Middle Fork of the Salmon. Huge
gyrocopter-like bugs that always look on the verge of crashing.


- Black caddis on the Bighorn. Keep your mouth closed.


- Green drakes on the Big Wood.


Siphlonurus Alternatus on the Swift in MA. The spinner fall rather than the
hatch. The big size 10 spinners drop right at dark, and sometimes in such
numbers that attempting to fish it is useless. Sadly, this hatch seems to be
disappearing on this river for no apparent reason.

Trico spinner fall on the Battenkill. Same as you described on Silver Creek.
The Eastern Tricos are *small*, 26 and 28 toward the end of the hatch. I used
to tie a "double" fly on an 18 or 20 so I could use a decent sized hook. Worked
to an extent, but was far from perfect.

Hendrickson/Red Quill hatch on the Farmington River in CT. Here again sometimes
so heavy at it's peak it is nearly impossible to fish.


George Adams

"All good fishermen stay young until they die, for fishing is the only dream of
youth that doth not grow stale with age."
---- J.W Muller


riverman June 27th, 2004 08:43 PM

Coolest hatches (was fishing, casting, and recruiting)
 

"Jeff Miller" wrote in message
news:RBFDc.5744$mN3.1637@lakeread06...
the only true "hatch" i've experienced was penns creek 2000, march
browns, sulphurs, black caddis, and grey caddis. a blizzard of bugs
that excited the fish for hours throughout the day, not just minutes
near dark. it's caused me to return each year since, but i've not seen
it repeated. this year, for about 20 minutes around dark was
close...even saw my first green drake.


I remember my first green drake, at least I think thats what it was. I
posted on roff about it. My overwhelming thought was of recognition from all
the pictures I had seen. It was an amazing feeling.

--riverman



Jeff Miller June 27th, 2004 08:51 PM

Coolest hatches (was fishing, casting, and recruiting)
 
the only true "hatch" i've experienced was penns creek 2000, march
browns, sulphurs, black caddis, and grey caddis. a blizzard of bugs
that excited the fish for hours throughout the day, not just minutes
near dark. it's caused me to return each year since, but i've not seen
it repeated. this year, for about 20 minutes around dark was
close...even saw my first green drake.

the waters, wildlife, and scenery of montana and idaho, not the hatches
(so far), have seduced me as well... maybe this year the bugs will sing
the sirens' song, eh?

jeff

rw wrote:

I'm going to offer a question for ROFF: What are the coolest hatches
you've ever seen? Here's my list:

- Brown Drakes on Silver Creek, Idaho. These huge mayflies (#8) make a
phenomenal spinner fall in the evening, and continue through the night.
You can catch fish in the pitch black of night, striking by ear.

- Morning Tricos on Silver Creek. Another spinner fall. It requires a
dead calm, or the tiny bugs are blown off the water. The fish feed on
pods, hoovering in rafts of bugs. You fish downstream, aiming your fly
into a mouth.

- Salmonflies on Marsh Creek and the Middle Fork of the Salmon. Huge
gyrocopter-like bugs that always look on the verge of crashing.

- Black caddis on the Bighorn. Keep your mouth closed.

- Green drakes on the Big Wood.



Wayne Harrison June 27th, 2004 09:42 PM

Coolest hatches (was fishing, casting, and recruiting)
 

"Mark H. Bowen" wrote in message
...
I'm not sure of the insect type, as it was early in my ff experience but I
saw a hatch on Wilson Creek one time.


i have only seen a literal handful of hatches (as might be classicly
considered) in the carolina appalachians. first time was on hazel, on one
of the few times we were on the creek near dark. they were creamy, probably
sulphurs, based on what i saw described as such on penns. fish rose
everywhere, we would catch the odd riser, but nothing spectacular.
then, about ten years ago, at snowbird, during the first weekend in
april, a sort of reverse drizzle of little blue duns just went on for a
couple hours or more; i can honestly say that, for the first time in my
north carolina experience, i truly "matched the hatch" with the smallest
adams para in my box, and actually caught more fish than with a standard
attractor.
couple years after that, there was a green drake hatch on lower hazel
that only lasted about 30 mins. i didn't see the first fish rise. the duns
looked like little toys, bouncing down the riffles.
i've probably forgotten a couple more events, but you get the drift.

yfitons
wayno



Tom Littleton June 28th, 2004 12:09 AM

Coolest hatches (was fishing, casting, and recruiting)
 
rw asks:
I'm going to offer a question for ROFF: What are the coolest hatches
you've ever seen?


1. Green Drakes at peak of hatch on Penn's(trestle pool). Literally, millions
of
extremely large white spinners, fish going berserk.

2.Sulfurs on Big Fishing Creek, three different species of duns hatching, two
species of spinners in the air. No clue what each fish wanted, and each
individual wanted something different. Put 20 different flies on that night.

3.First Penn's clave, March Brown spinner fall. These buggers are in the air a
lot of nights, but never fall. They did, in Poe Paddy, and yielded a few nice
fish, and one really nice fish. So disoriented, I got Handyman lost getting out
of Poe Paddy...

4.Penn's again, April 2003, Grannom Caddis. Hatching adults were clustered so
thick on my wader legs(brown neoprene, maybe they thought I was a tree?) that
Makela easily scooped two handfuls off the back of my right leg(about 500 bugs)
and didn't make a dent in the total, and that was just the few who clambered
onto me.

5. Hendricksons on Little Schuyllkill River.
Breezy day, heavy hatch was blown all over the creek. Fish went nuts chasing
blown-over and drowned adults. This went on for nearly 3 hours.









Tim J. June 28th, 2004 03:08 AM

Coolest hatches (was fishing, casting, and recruiting)
 

"rw" wrote...
snip

I'm going to offer a question for ROFF: What are the coolest hatches
you've ever seen?


Besides seeing some minor hatches, I ended up in the middle of a massive sulphur
hatch on the Swift River in Massachusetts a few years ago that was phenomenal. I
almost forgot to fish, I was so taken by the event.
--
TL,
Tim
http://css.sbcma.com/timj



Frank Reid June 28th, 2004 03:13 AM

Coolest hatches (was fishing, casting, and recruiting)
 
1. Green Drakes at peak of hatch on Penn's
2.Sulfurs on Big Fishing Creek,
3.First Penn's clave, March Brown spinner fall.
4.Penn's again, April 2003, Grannom Caddis.
5. Hendricksons on Little Schuyllkill River.


I'll see your 5 and raise you the white miller hatch on either the Potomac
or the Rappahannock River. I have caught it in both places. 30 feet out
from shore, you loose track of where you are. You can no longer see the
shore. You need a scarf or settle on coughing up bugs for the next week,
'cause they're so thick you can't breath.
I think the one on the Rappahnnock was the most intense as you added
darkness into the picture. In both cases, if you had anything white on the
end of your line, it wasn't on the water for more than 30 seconds.
Smallies, bluegill, carp, chub, anything in the water were all on the
surface feeding.



a-happy-up-yours June 28th, 2004 03:53 AM

Coolest hatches (was fishing, casting, and recruiting)
 
Frank Reid wrote:

1. Green Drakes at peak of hatch on Penn's
2.Sulfurs on Big Fishing Creek,
3.First Penn's clave, March Brown spinner fall.
4.Penn's again, April 2003, Grannom Caddis.
5. Hendricksons on Little Schuyllkill River.



I'll see your 5 and raise you the white miller hatch on either the Potomac
or the Rappahannock River. I have caught it in both places. 30 feet out
from shore, you loose track of where you are. You can no longer see the
shore. You need a scarf or settle on coughing up bugs for the next week,
'cause they're so thick you can't breath.
I think the one on the Rappahnnock was the most intense as you added
darkness into the picture. In both cases, if you had anything white on the
end of your line, it wasn't on the water for more than 30 seconds.
Smallies, bluegill, carp, chub, anything in the water were all on the
surface feeding.




First, I'm not easily surprised/amazed/puzzled.....

.....First Penns Clave (2000), first day - Saturday, about 5 PM. I stepped off the
island behind the Cherry Run cabin and I thought, for a few seconds, that I was
having a TIE. There was a step function from daylight to near-total darkness. March
Brown hatch all around me. Absolutely astounding. Never before or after have I seen
any such concentration of insects. Had to be a hundred thousand big flys involved,
at least. By the time I realized what had occurred, spit out all of the bugs and
fumbled through my fly boxes, searching for the March Brown imitations that were
still in the cabin, the event was concluded.

In the Carolinas, "hatches" are seldom seen, if they occur. This was a halcyon
moment, for me and an event I'll never forget.

Tom

n4tab at earthlink dot net

Mike June 28th, 2004 04:16 AM

fishing, casting, and recruiting
 
There is nothing like being on the water looking up and seeing millions of bugs
Green Drakes June of 95 or 96 standing on the trestle bridge on Penns Creek
what an awe inspiring site you do not want to stand there slack-jaw or your
mouth will be full.......April 03 grannom caddis hatch Penns Creek so many bugs
they blocked out the sun.......May 03 sulpur spinner fall Big Fishing Creek got
arm weary pulling in fish and i was not the only one.....May 04 another sulpur
hatch Penns Creek several days to be exact.....I have proberly seen many more
hatch in the 5 decades + years i have been fortunate enough to be on this
planet we call earth but never thought much of them untill i got the flyfishing
bug..... I have always been respectful of nature but stop and think what it
takes to make a fishery like Penns The Gunpowder The Madison Yellowstone or you
local trickle......... Mother Nature at her finest.........


Handyman Mike
Standing in a river waving a stick


Wayne Harrison June 28th, 2004 04:29 AM

fishing, casting, and recruiting
 

"Mike" wrote

I have always been respectful of nature but stop and think what it
takes to make a fishery like Penns The Gunpowder The Madison Yellowstone

or you
local trickle......... Mother Nature at her finest.........


i can dig it, mike. i have often just sat on a rock in a pretty run on
hazel creek, and just let the water run through my legs, thanking god for
the chance that i found the place.

yfitons
wayno



Mike June 28th, 2004 04:39 AM

fishing, casting, and recruiting
 
here here done the same thing many times


Handyman Mike
Standing in a river waving a stick


Jeff Miller June 28th, 2004 11:28 AM

Coolest hatches (was fishing, casting, and recruiting)
 


riverman wrote:





I remember my first green drake, at least I think thats what it was. I
posted on roff about it. My overwhelming thought was of recognition from all
the pictures I had seen. It was an amazing feeling.


if i hadn't the good fortune to be fishing with mike makela at the time,
i never would have known the bug was a green drake. it was tan in color
and not as huge as i was expecting, and because of the near dark, its
green tint in the wings couldn't be seen. makela nabbed it from a nearby
tree leaf. we then fished using a huge green drake fly...both of us
hooked up. my fish, a brown, was about 14 to 15", the last fish hooked
on that day, and it went wildly airborne. on the second leap, it threw
the hook. pretty neat stuff...

jeff


Joe McIntosh June 28th, 2004 01:13 PM

Coolest hatches (was fishing, casting, and recruiting)
 
Indian Joe has told the story many times of his vision of a trico hatch on
Silver Creek. I was in the campground the first evening and everyone said
the hatch would be about 9:30 the next morning. One guy who came to fish the
hatch each year showed me his fly box--size 20 male trico's- female trico's-
wounded trico's-size 22 trico's with the same assortment. . He shared a
couple of flies and helped me pick out a good spot on the creek the next
morning. There were around ten guys standing spread out around the creek
watching a few large pods of trout swimming all around us as I cast again
and again close to them with no results--the other guys just waited.

At 9:32 it happened--TRICO'S everwhere- in your eyes- in the air -in the
water
how could you get a fish to take your fly while the water was covered with
live flies? I could not !
After casting unsuccefully for twenty minutes I decided to try a different
fly and caught a couple of 12 inch trout on a royal wuff..
as the hatch faded twenty minutes later I had to leave but shared a couple
of royal wuffs with my new friend who was still flailing the water
unsuccesfully with a size 24 spent wing tryco spinner or some sort of
thing.

Now if you want to talk about major hatches on land I could tell you about
the Love Bug hatch in Florida in 1943-- drivers wrecked their cars because
the couldnot see highway--women ran around nude as they ripped off their
cloths to get the bugs out of their underware









Rob S. June 28th, 2004 02:27 PM

fishing, casting, and recruiting
 
"riverman" wrote in message ...
[snip excellent stuff]

In Wales, all the nymphs I saw swhere I was standing were between 1 and 2
feet below the surface: I looked deeper and never saw one go by at knee
level, and (in an effort to keep my sleeves dry) I tried to find one near
the surface to scoop up, but never saw one shallower than 1 foot deep. Also,
there were no fish rising near me, but they were rising about 10 meters
downstream from me, or in the calm pool above me. I suspect the fish near me
were eating nymphs that were 1-2 feet deep, that the fish 5 meters
downstream from me were eating nymphs that were 6 inches to 1 foot deep, and
the fish 10 meters downstream were eating nymphs on the surface.

--riverman


and hence a common practice is to fish an emerger on the surface with
a nymph on a dropper that will vary based on success. If you can
identify where in the column
the nymphs are floating so much the better.

on the Delaware up in the tailwater sections, this is a killer
technique and often the only one that will work.

Wolfgang June 28th, 2004 03:43 PM

Coolest hatches (was fishing, casting, and recruiting)
 

"a-happy-up-yours"
wrote in message
hlink.net...
Frank Reid wrote:

1. Green Drakes at peak of hatch on Penn's
2.Sulfurs on Big Fishing Creek,
3.First Penn's clave, March Brown spinner fall.
4.Penn's again, April 2003, Grannom Caddis.
5. Hendricksons on Little Schuyllkill River.



I'll see your 5 and raise you the white miller hatch on either the

Potomac
or the Rappahannock River. I have caught it in both places. 30

feet out
from shore, you loose track of where you are. You can no longer

see the
shore. You need a scarf or settle on coughing up bugs for the

next week,
'cause they're so thick you can't breath.
I think the one on the Rappahnnock was the most intense as you

added
darkness into the picture. In both cases, if you had anything

white on the
end of your line, it wasn't on the water for more than 30 seconds.
Smallies, bluegill, carp, chub, anything in the water were all on

the
surface feeding.




First, I'm not easily surprised/amazed/puzzled.....

....First Penns Clave (2000), first day - Saturday, about 5 PM. I

stepped off the
island behind the Cherry Run cabin and I thought, for a few seconds,

that I was
having a TIE. There was a step function from daylight to near-total

darkness. March
Brown hatch all around me. Absolutely astounding. Never before or

after have I seen
any such concentration of insects. Had to be a hundred thousand big

flys involved,
at least. By the time I realized what had occurred, spit out all of

the bugs and
fumbled through my fly boxes, searching for the March Brown

imitations that were
still in the cabin, the event was concluded.

In the Carolinas, "hatches" are seldom seen, if they occur. This

was a halcyon
moment, for me and an event I'll never forget.

Tom


Jefferson river. As I look upstream, I can see a single remaining
cloud of early morning fog hanging over a stretch of river about three
hundred yards away. The sun is low and I can see uncountable bright
splashes as fish are rising everywhere in an astounding feeding
frenzy. It takes me a few minutes to realize that the cloud is not
fog, but millions of tiny bugs.

Culver's parking lot. 10 p.m. on a sultry June night. The hex are so
thick around the sodium vapor lamps that they've reduce available
light in the lot by 50% or more. It is impossible to take a step
anywhere in the lot without crushing twenty or more bugs.

Weyauwega. 9 p.m. on a sultry June night. Westbound on U.S 10 at
sixty miles per hour. Hit the hex hatch.....and I mean
HIT......halfway down a hill approaching Partridge Crop lake.
Impossible to tell for sure, but there must have been at least a
hundred of them hit the windshield in a small fraction of a second.
Sounded like it had been hit by several soaking wet towels. Instantly
blinded. Managed to coast to a stop on the shoulder without incident
and spent 15 minutes or so cleaning off the goo.

Wolfgang



William Claspy June 28th, 2004 04:23 PM

Coolest hatches (was fishing, casting, and recruiting)
 
On 6/27/04 12:40 PM, in article
, "rw"
wrote:

I'm going to offer a question for ROFF: What are the coolest hatches
you've ever seen?


Just for sheer humor, Saturday night at the 2004 Penns Clave. A handful of
us were gathered at Three Streamer Stan's bridge in the evening. None of us
were gonzo/brave/stupid enough to string up a rod because of sporadic but
consistent lightning and thunder. So we spent an hour or two waiting for
the rain to stop and trying to capture representatives of the three or four
hatches that were simultaneously occurring. Grown men leaping up into the
air for rising bugs, waving their caps in an effort to snag the winged
beasts. The trout must have been laughing their asses (adipose?) off.

Bill
(Tom, does Bruce have those bug photos on a web page?)


snakefiddler June 28th, 2004 09:45 PM

fishing, casting, and recruiting
 

"Wayne Harrison" wrote in message
. com...

"Mike" wrote

I have always been respectful of nature but stop and think what it
takes to make a fishery like Penns The Gunpowder The Madison Yellowstone

or you
local trickle......... Mother Nature at her finest.........


i can dig it, mike. i have often just sat on a rock in a pretty run

on
hazel creek, and just let the water run through my legs, thanking god for
the chance that i found the place.

yfitons
wayno



ah, yes, uncle wayno-
indeed; the pleasure of experiencing the water swirling around my legs,
taking in the scenery , and inhaling the fragrant air can be intoxicating.
when i go out to our streams here, particularly if it is early in the
morning, or after it has been raining, i swear i can smell every shade of
green surrounding me. and to stand in the water, and to virtually become a
part of everything around me, is a joy, to be sure.

snakefiddler



Stephen Welsh June 28th, 2004 10:09 PM

Coolest hatches (was fishing, casting, and recruiting)
 
rw wrote in news:40def7c0$0$28111
:

I'm going to offer a question for ROFF: What are the coolest hatches
you've ever seen? Here's my list:


Snowflake caddis, Goulburn Dec 2002. Good fish on 'em too.

BWO - May - Goulburn ... lotsa flys, drizzle, fish and fun.
Duns (probably rusty duns: it was pretty dark) february '97
Midges on the Goulburn. Struck a general rise to them a few years
back ... unbelievable -just- subsurface nymph fishing.

Alittle river: Caddis and Cicadas - things crashing into rod,
unnamed small river Dec 2003. March Flys: Jan 2004. Grey Stoneflys
in February 2004.

Christmas Beetles: Dec on the Yarra, back in 95 ' or so.
Soldier Beetles: Feb 98'

Damsel flys: Anderson's Lagoon ... summer '93 ... . You could reach down
scoop a nymph out and watch it hatch in your hand. Fish were belting
about the place seemingly chasing adults but there were no riseforms as
such: they were on the nymphs.

Caddis on some Tassie Lakes (Bradys) this season gone and last. Stickys.
Damsel flys on the Macquarie, the adults.



Steve





Tom Littleton June 28th, 2004 11:08 PM

Coolest hatches (was fishing, casting, and recruiting)
 
Bill Claspy writes:
Grown men leaping up into the
air for rising bugs, waving their caps in an effort to snag the winged
beasts. The trout must have been laughing their asses (adipose?) off.

Bill
(Tom, does Bruce have those bug photos on a web page?)


a perfect visual for that scene......as for Bruce's photos, last I saw they
were in large-format, unedited form on his laptop.
Tom
(who didn't have to leap for anything,thank
you)

Wolfgang June 29th, 2004 01:33 AM

Coolest hatches (was fishing, casting, and recruiting)
 

"Tom Littleton" wrote in message
...
Bill Claspy writes:
Grown men leaping up into the
air for rising bugs, waving their caps in an effort to snag the winged
beasts. The trout must have been laughing their asses (adipose?) off.

Bill
(Tom, does Bruce have those bug photos on a web page?)


a perfect visual for that scene......as for Bruce's photos, last I saw

they
were in large-format, unedited form on his laptop.
Tom
(who didn't have to leap for anything,thank
you)


Tweren't so much a matter of necessity as sheer physical exuberance in the
face of raw nature and good company.

Wolfgang
who, truth be told, didn't NEED to be there in the first place.......but
rarely declines an invitation to the dance. :)



Willi June 29th, 2004 01:49 AM

fishing, casting, and recruiting
 


snakefiddler wrote:

wow- what a day!


Sounds like you're on your way!

Willi




Tom Littleton June 29th, 2004 02:18 AM

Coolest hatches (was fishing, casting, and recruiting)
 
Wolfie notes:
Tweren't so much a matter of necessity as sheer physical exuberance in the
face of raw nature and good company.


I was exuberant and all that, I merely noted that I don't need to jump to grab
bugs way up.....just don't ask me to limbo.....
Tom

snakefiddler June 29th, 2004 02:58 AM

fishing, casting, and recruiting
 

"Willi" wrote in message
...


snakefiddler wrote:

wow- what a day!


Sounds like you're on your way!


thanks- yeah, i think so- this is so addictive. i had a pretty busy day, so
i didn't get out until about 8:00 this evenin, at which time i hit a creek
in a park on the parkway. i was in water that i knew to have some trout,
and lots of sunfish, and as the sun went down, the fish just started jumping
all over the place- 3, 4, and 5 at a time. it was really very entertaining.
i had never seen anything like it before. anyway, i knew at that point
that if i didn't hook one in such ripe conditions, that i really sucked!
they were in a near feeding frenzy. i had a slider on my line to start
with, and though they nibbled on it some, when they started jumping i
decided to put an adams on instead. it took no time at all to bring one in;
and just in time, since by now it was getting fairly dark, and the fog was
rollin in.
fog on the blueridge parkway, in the twighlight is a gorgeous sight.

jen

Willi






Wayne Harrison June 29th, 2004 03:54 AM

fishing, casting, and recruiting
 

"snakefiddler" wrote

fog on the blueridge parkway, in the twighlight is a gorgeous sight.



yes, by god, it is.



William Claspy June 29th, 2004 02:08 PM

Coolest hatches (was fishing, casting, and recruiting)
 
On 6/28/04 9:18 PM, in article ,
"Tom Littleton" wrote:

Wolfie notes:
Tweren't so much a matter of necessity as sheer physical exuberance in the
face of raw nature and good company.


I was exuberant and all that, I merely noted that I don't need to jump to grab
bugs way up.....just don't ask me to limbo.....
Tom


I don't consider myself a short man (though I've got Grandpa's bowling
shirts which are embroidered "Shorty" over the pocket and "Claspy" across
the back- he was 5'1" with shoes on but still threw a 16 pound ball), but
hanging out with Tom and Roger I must admit to having felt some height envy.

Bill
(Roger elicited other envies as well, but I think we've already gone over
that... :-)


eric paul zamora June 30th, 2004 10:41 AM

Coolest hatches (was fishing, casting, and recruiting)
 


riverman wrote:


I'm going to offer a question for ROFF: What are the coolest hatches
you've ever seen? Here's my list:




i had just started flyfishing, middle of last year. about a month or two
later, i was standing in the Kings River in central California downstream of
friant dam, when bugs started flying everywhere. kings river caddis! they
were crawling on the brim of my hat, climbing around my eye glasses, inside
the lenses, all over my legs and arms and shirt, it was cool. i thought,
OH, so THIS is what they mean... strangely enough, no fish were rising on
that october-ish evening.


eric
fresno, ca.



All times are GMT +1. The time now is 04:07 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2006 FishingBanter