Tom

Bob is right.

I know of an very good nymph fisherman who doesn't use sinking lines and
thinks its bull.

He says you'll never detect a strike in deep water. I think he meant with
any line.He just dosen't fish deep water.

It seems on a floating line on longer cast the floating section can act as a
strike indicator, while sinking line you have little indication of a strike
except by feel. and of course a floating strike indicator would defeat the
purpose of a sink tip or full sinking line.

But I use one for the following condition and have caught some hefty browns
doing it.

And think it works better in this case with a full sinking line than a
floater. It gets the nymph closer to the bottom faster longer more
efficiently.

I have not had much experience in still water but this case could be
considered very slow deep water.



Well-said Bob

Some of my experiences and I by no means an expert.

I use my uniform sink line on the slow long deep flats of the East branch of
the Delaware, fishing across and down stream on a short leader no more than
4 or 5 ft. and I'm talking 5 to 12 feet of water, I add shot and adjust my
retrive until I get the fly as close to the bottom without scrapping it, in
the place where I think fish are holding, stripping and shaking out more
line and mending to lengthen the drift then hand retrieving and pulsating a
fly back to me. I think it's near impossible to detect a strike in deeper
water and with out some line tension so it's I find a hook up is the line
just will tension up slow or you'll see a flash in the deep water and feel
it, and I lift.

This is one fishing condition I like to fish.

But also there's a time for a dead drift, or times when the fish are
looking for emerging pupa or mayflies and will take a fly at the end of a
drift when you start to pick up and it starts to emerge like a hatching
nymph. Some times they take soft hackles mid depth or a nymph right below
the surface this can be seen as a rise, or emergers in the surface film.

With a floating line and shot to me is for nymphing shorter line mostly,
Normally In pocket water and runs not to deep I add or subtract lead till I'm
scrapping and bumping the bottom but not snagging to much, some times using
an outrigger technique.

A place where I like to nymph is a place where you can drift a fly through
where the bottom current is close speed of the middle and top current so you
can get the longest drift through a run with out mending the line to much
getting too much drag. Don't forget because of hydro friction the current on
the bottom is nil compared to the middle, and the top current and a nymph
drifting naturally doesn't drag, and I think a badly dragging fly, nymph or
dry will spook fish, and the same time I don't know why a wet fly swing
works. Then if you let a nymph hang downstream in pocket water for a while
you may get a strike. Go figure.

And I swear fish take the fly and spit it out 50 % of the time and I
never know it. So often when the fly is drifting in a holding area where I
think there's a trout I lift and feel and strike at the slightest resistance
I can't say how many times I've hooked up this way. Or how many times I got
snagged on the bottom. More snags than fish but fish too.

Tom you'll just have practice and fish fish fish.

I've seen some guys put shot on the bend of the hook, or 3 inches above the
fly.

I'd love to hear other nymphing experiences.

To me it's a Zen 6th sense type of thing, I like it.

Any way my experience.

Gerard

"Bob Weinberger" wrote in message
news:ng5zh.21$H77.17@trndny08...

"Tom Nakashima" wrote in message
...
snip
I'm getting mixed users in favor of split shots vs. sinking line. I have
been currently using split-shots about 18" before the fly, weight
depending on current and depth. I've never tried a sinking line or
sink-tip line, very curious if it makes a difference in a more natural
presentation to the fish.
fwiw,
-tom



Tom,

It depends on the type of water conditions and type of presentation you
are trying to make.

I find full sink tip lines only useful in still waters. Sink tips are
useful in both still waters and streams. In streams, I find their best
use to be for any fly that will be fished on a sub-surface swing, or will
be given some action on the retrieve (e.g. streamers, wet flies, & soft
hackles). For most dead drift situations and, especially if fishing narrow
slots with nymphs, a floating line with weight on the leader will give a
better presentation.

Bob Weinberger La Grande, OR