On Wed, 21 Nov 2007 22:08:38 -0800 (PST), riverman
wrote:

I've ordered up 9-footers, since I have both an 8'5" and a 9" 5 wt,
and I find that I can cast more easily with the longer rod. But a LOT
of websites mention 8'6" 5 wt rods as the best beginner rod. I was
thinking that the shorter rod might be less versatile for the kids.

What do folks think: what are the advantages to one length over
another on a medium-fast rod? Should I change my order to 8'5" rods?

--riverman

What streamside conditions are they most likely to encounter? If it's
heavier cover on a short-cast stream, go with shorter, if it's wide
open, go with longer. And if the kids are (overall stature, not just
age) on the smaller side, I'd say go with the shorter model. Frankly, I
don't think the 6" will make a huge difference either way, but those are
the guidelines I'd use in selecting length. Given what I've heard about
your situation, I'd say that number of pieces (IIRC, from what you've
said, they will _always_ have to travel to fish, right?) would be more
of a factor than the 6" length difference, but ???

Happy Thanksgiving,
R