View Single Post
  #240  
Old March 19th, 2008, 03:01 PM posted to alt.flyfishing
Halfordian Golfer
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 551
Default Fishery Management was Catch and Release Hurts our Quality ofLife

On Mar 17, 10:46 am, "JT" wrote:
"Halfordian Golfer" wrote in message

...



On Mar 17, 8:17 am, "JT" wrote:
"Halfordian Golfer" wrote in message


...


JT
Catch & Release fishing is a conservation effort to protect stream
viability for future generations, while enjoying the sport of fishing.


Your question is the most elementary one that is dismissed within 10
minutes of the conversation. Not sure why you hang on to it and not
sure why you keep saying I don't answer your question when I have over
and over and over.


No you didn't and you know it....


JT
Catch & Release fishing is a conservation effort to protect stream
viability for future generations, while enjoying the sport of fishing.


JT do you or Willi have anything more to add to this thread?
Specifically anything about pure C&R fishermen doing anything to
prevent toxicity in the form of mercury and others in our fisheries?


For the record:
1) JT I answered your question specifically. Multiple times. In the
last one I earmarked it as "Answer". As well, if you honestly care
about the answer and aren't just "goading" you can search the archives
where I have addressed this, I'd suggest 30-100 times in the past
decade. Which part of my answer did not address your question
exactly?


You know damn well you didn't answer my direct question.

I'm done, EOT for me... This thread over the last two plus weeks have
accomplished absolutely nothing.

Move along,
JT


JT,

You keep claiming I don't answer this question (which looks like a
statement and a question):

It's okay to catch and release several fish before you catch a fish
that meets a slot limit? What about the incident mortality in all the
fish you release before catching a keeper!?

Here is my answer, again, highly pared down to its essence.

Part I. It's okay to catch and release several fish before you catch a
fish that meets a slot limit?

If this is question than: Yes. If it's a statement than I agree with
you.

Part II. What about the incident mortality in all the fish you release
before catching a keeper!?

Unfortunate but unavoidable. Happens all the time in nature.

Halfordian Golfer