View Single Post
  #77  
Old January 24th, 2010, 05:58 PM posted to rec.outdoors.fishing.fly
MajorOz
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 349
Default Thank you, Mr. O.

On Jan 24, 6:55*am, Ken Fortenberry
wrote:
MajorOz wrote:
"Tom Littleton" wrote:
What John doesn't see is that when it comes to healthcare, we are talking
about something that ought to be a birthright of citizenship,


It may be a great idea for some and philosophically hardwired into
them, but it ain't a universally held view, and to assume it is, or
even that it should be, is just plain stupid.


There it is, distilled into easy-to-read roffian format. The health
care debate in a nutshell. Decent human beings who care for their
fellow Americans feel strongly that health care is a right and the
rugged individualists feel strongly that it's every man for himself.


Rather than create a strawman, if it must be rephrased, please try to
do it in accordance with original intent, to wit:

"Some decent human beings who care for their fellow Americans feel
strongly that health care is a right. Other decent human beings who
care for their fellow Americans feel strongly the health care is not a
right."

I don't know from philosophical hardwires but it's pretty easy for
me to see where the moral high ground is in this debate.


The above is a textbook illustration of how a misstatement of intent
will create a statement supportive or a pre-extablished position.

cheers

oz, always willing to help