Absolutely right. Thanks for clearing that up guys.

Here in South Africa there has been a huge move in targeting the various
Yellowfish species, especially on fly . Shortline nymphing has been a
particularly successful method of catching them. Traditionally we have fly
fished for trout which are of course alien here. Yellowfish are a
formidable quarry and considered a serious tackle buster. Believe me they
are.

Its funny you should mention how carp is considered as trash in US. Over
here it is the same. Even Bass are considered trash by some of the "fly
fishing purists" over here.
I too was schooled in those ways until I discovered lures and bait which
opened up a whole new world for me.

Now I do it all and life is great.



"JohnK" wrote in message
...

"Steve @ OutdoorFrontiers" wrote in message
...

"mr&ms" wrote in message
...
Yup...a grass carp

Nope, not a grass carp at all, but a totally different fish. A
Clanwilliam Yellowfish is "Barbus capensis" and a grass carp, also known
as a White Amur, is "Ctenopharyngodon idella."
--
Steve @ OutdoorFrontiers

True, a different fish. But still a member of the carp family of fish, and
the physical resemblance
is remarkable, except of colurse for the distinct golden color. I find it
interesting that all over
the world, common carp is respected and in some places even prized , while
in North America we
consider it trash. Then, there are a number of other fish in the carp
family, which in their
own countries of origin are not considered or called "carp", we attach the
"carp" suffix to it and automatically
reduce it to a trash fish. That is besides the issue of being invasive
foreign species that we foolishly
brought here. Most of us fishermen now think these new Invasive Asian
"carps" are the same barbelled
mud diggers we brought here from Germany in the 1800s, which they are not.
I'm all for eliminating
the name "grass carp" and just calling it White Amur. BTW in Asia they are
just called "grass fish".