If you had a choice

to fish the following hours which would you do?

2:30 a.m- 5:30 a.m or 5:30 a.m- 8:a.m


The reason I ask is, I was at the lake at 5:30 this morning and prior to it getting light I caught two good fish on a buzzbait and one on a wacky rig. I missed another what seemed like a good fish based on the splash(but who knows) With the warmer temperatures earlier in the morning now it seems that once that sun comes up the fish become few and far between, I beleive I might be better off fishing in the dark right up to daybreak. I could then sleep for another two hours prior to work. Opinions? Fish should be feeding more during this time anyway right? (Wow, this sounds "Al-Esque")
Randy-