Reel advice

By next season I'm planning on adding an 8wt rod & reel to the 6wt I
already have. I'm going to build the rod over the winter (something
to keep me from losing my mind over the long winter months of
Illinois). This outfit will be for Bass & Musky. Also, this year I
fished Atlantic Canada for trout in an area that had good sea trout
and salmon fishing. I'd like to go after them with this 8wt the next
time I'm up there (I only fished for trout this year with my 6wt).

Between now and spring I'm going to keep my eyes open for a great deal
on a used 8wt reel. I'm on a limited budget so I'm going to take my
time and wait for a really good deal to come my way. My question is;
what brand/models of reels would be on a "short list" to look for?
Something that could handle Musky and Salmon.

I'm hoping to get a reel that will last me a lifetime, at a price of ~
$100 used. I could go a bit higher if I had to. This is a reel I'd
fish with 90% of the time (and I fish a LOT.....I even fish over my
lunch hour at work at a nearby lake..........and I fish two spring-fed
lakes that are short walking distance from my home (they're my "home
away from home" places)

Thanks for any help.

On Sat, 18 Aug 2007 18:15:27 -0000, mdk77
wrote:

By next season I'm planning on adding an 8wt rod & reel to the 6wt I
already have. I'm going to build the rod over the winter (something
to keep me from losing my mind over the long winter months of
Illinois). This outfit will be for Bass & Musky. Also, this year I
fished Atlantic Canada for trout in an area that had good sea trout
and salmon fishing. I'd like to go after them with this 8wt the next
time I'm up there (I only fished for trout this year with my 6wt).

Between now and spring I'm going to keep my eyes open for a great deal
on a used 8wt reel. I'm on a limited budget so I'm going to take my
time and wait for a really good deal to come my way. My question is;
what brand/models of reels would be on a "short list" to look for?
Something that could handle Musky and Salmon.

I'm hoping to get a reel that will last me a lifetime, at a price of ~
$100 used. I could go a bit higher if I had to. This is a reel I'd
fish with 90% of the time (and I fish a LOT.....I even fish over my
lunch hour at work at a nearby lake..........and I fish two spring-fed
lakes that are short walking distance from my home (they're my "home
away from home" places)

Thanks for any help.

How old are you and when do you plan on dying? About the only
widely-available reel that has absolutely proven to last "a lifetime" -
assuming "a lifetime" to mean 30-plus years - and is readily available
for under $100USD is the US-made Medalist. Are there newer reels that
are shaping up to fit into a "last a lifetime" criteria? Yep, and in
about 20 years or so, we'll know for sure. OTOH, if you only plan on
living a year or two, any number of reels will fit, new and used, esp.
for freshwater-only usage. What you might luck into, or what you mean
by "a bit higher," could make a huge difference.

My favorite "modern" readily-available reel is the Tibor/Billy Pate, but
you'll really need to luck into one OR "a bit higher" will have to mean
"at least double" to fit your stated criteria. OTOH and IMO, a
reasonably well-maintained BP would last "a lifetime," even if you are
10 years old and plan on living to about 128.

TC,
R

On Aug 18, 2:03 pm, wrote:
On Sat, 18 Aug 2007 18:15:27 -0000, mdk77
wrote:



By next season I'm planning on adding an 8wt rod & reel to the 6wt I
already have. I'm going to build the rod over the winter (something
to keep me from losing my mind over the long winter months of
Illinois). This outfit will be for Bass & Musky. Also, this year I
fished Atlantic Canada for trout in an area that had good sea trout
and salmon fishing. I'd like to go after them with this 8wt the next
time I'm up there (I only fished for trout this year with my 6wt).

Between now and spring I'm going to keep my eyes open for a great deal
on a used 8wt reel. I'm on a limited budget so I'm going to take my
time and wait for a really good deal to come my way. My question is;
what brand/models of reels would be on a "short list" to look for?
Something that could handle Musky and Salmon.

I'm hoping to get a reel that will last me a lifetime, at a price of ~
$100 used. I could go a bit higher if I had to. This is a reel I'd
fish with 90% of the time (and I fish a LOT.....I even fish over my
lunch hour at work at a nearby lake..........and I fish two spring-fed
lakes that are short walking distance from my home (they're my "home
away from home" places)

Thanks for any help.

How old are you and when do you plan on dying? About the only
widely-available reel that has absolutely proven to last "a lifetime" -
assuming "a lifetime" to mean 30-plus years - and is readily available
for under $100USD is the US-made Medalist. Are there newer reels that
are shaping up to fit into a "last a lifetime" criteria? Yep, and in
about 20 years or so, we'll know for sure. OTOH, if you only plan on
living a year or two, any number of reels will fit, new and used, esp.
for freshwater-only usage. What you might luck into, or what you mean
by "a bit higher," could make a huge difference.

My favorite "modern" readily-available reel is the Tibor/Billy Pate, but
you'll really need to luck into one OR "a bit higher" will have to mean
"at least double" to fit your stated criteria. OTOH and IMO, a
reasonably well-maintained BP would last "a lifetime," even if you are
10 years old and plan on living to about 128.

TC,
R

I'm hoping I can get a decent price on a used reel if I take my time
over the winter and look. I'm hoping to find one for closer to $100,
but definitely less than $200. BTW, I'm 54 years old, so hopefully
I'll "last" a good bit longer......40+ more years of fishing would be
nice :-)

Here are some reels I've considered, but they need to be in the 8wt
I'm looking for. Is there a good place to look online other than Ebay
for used reels?

Here are some reels I've noticed that might be in my price range used
(if I can find one in an 8wt):
Scientific Anglers System-2 Series
Ross Gunnison G2
Orvis Battenkill Mid Arbor
Orvis Mach Large Arbor
Ross Cimarron Large Arbor (and the
I see Lamson reels on Ebay that are sometimes in my range (the
Lightspeed in particular)
Redington RS2
There's an Abel Big Game on Ebay now for $127

Or are all of these decent reels that if I can get one at a decent
price, would be a good deal?

I have Lamson & Gunnison reelsw 9wt. line
They are real good and lightweight.
I even have a few xtra spools and different line for ea ...

It really depends if you are going to go sal****er exclusively -that will
ruin a reel fast
If more freshwater than sal****er
these are great
I have had them 10-12 yrs or so ...
You could probably get one for $200 or
It would be a good buy!

When I fished mainly salt for stripers & blues in Nww England
I had a $65 dollar Pfleuger 8 wt Medalist for 11 trs.

What's a long time with a reel?

A long time with a dog - 12 yrs - or so is a lifetime w that animal

Fred

mdk77 wrote:

On Aug 18, 2:03 pm, wrote:

On Sat, 18 Aug 2007 18:15:27 -0000, mdk77
wrote:




By next season I'm planning on adding an 8wt rod & reel to the 6wt I
already have. I'm going to build the rod over the winter (something
to keep me from losing my mind over the long winter months of
Illinois). This outfit will be for Bass & Musky. Also, this year I
fished Atlantic Canada for trout in an area that had good sea trout
and salmon fishing. I'd like to go after them with this 8wt the next
time I'm up there (I only fished for trout this year with my 6wt).

Between now and spring I'm going to keep my eyes open for a great deal
on a used 8wt reel. I'm on a limited budget so I'm going to take my
time and wait for a really good deal to come my way. My question is;
what brand/models of reels would be on a "short list" to look for?
Something that could handle Musky and Salmon.

I'm hoping to get a reel that will last me a lifetime, at a price of ~
$100 used. I could go a bit higher if I had to. This is a reel I'd
fish with 90% of the time (and I fish a LOT.....I even fish over my
lunch hour at work at a nearby lake..........and I fish two spring-fed
lakes that are short walking distance from my home (they're my "home
away from home" places)

Thanks for any help.

How old are you and when do you plan on dying? About the only
widely-available reel that has absolutely proven to last "a lifetime" -
assuming "a lifetime" to mean 30-plus years - and is readily available
for under $100USD is the US-made Medalist. Are there newer reels that
are shaping up to fit into a "last a lifetime" criteria? Yep, and in
about 20 years or so, we'll know for sure. OTOH, if you only plan on
living a year or two, any number of reels will fit, new and used, esp.
for freshwater-only usage. What you might luck into, or what you mean
by "a bit higher," could make a huge difference.

My favorite "modern" readily-available reel is the Tibor/Billy Pate, but
you'll really need to luck into one OR "a bit higher" will have to mean
"at least double" to fit your stated criteria. OTOH and IMO, a
reasonably well-maintained BP would last "a lifetime," even if you are
10 years old and plan on living to about 128.

TC,
R


I'm hoping I can get a decent price on a used reel if I take my time
over the winter and look. I'm hoping to find one for closer to $100,
but definitely less than $200. BTW, I'm 54 years old, so hopefully
I'll "last" a good bit longer......40+ more years of fishing would be
nice :-)

Here are some reels I've considered, but they need to be in the 8wt
I'm looking for. Is there a good place to look online other than Ebay
for used reels?

Here are some reels I've noticed that might be in my price range used
(if I can find one in an 8wt):
Scientific Anglers System-2 Series
Ross Gunnison G2
Orvis Battenkill Mid Arbor
Orvis Mach Large Arbor
Ross Cimarron Large Arbor (and the
I see Lamson reels on Ebay that are sometimes in my range (the
Lightspeed in particular)
Redington RS2
There's an Abel Big Game on Ebay now for $127

Or are all of these decent reels that if I can get one at a decent
price, would be a good deal?

A few comments on your list. If that Abel Big Game stays at that
price(ebay), most likely there's something wrong with the reel, or it's
a scam.

I've heard of problems with the initial Orvis Mach reels. I believe
there was an issue with the drag. I heard they fixed the problem. If you
go that route, make sure you get the updated model.

I'd stay away from the RS2. It's heavy, and like the Mach, it had an
issue with the drag. I think a bearing needed replacing/upgrading. It
has been discontinued for a while now, so service might be an issue.

I own a couple Litespeeds. Light, rugged, smooth drag, and reliable. I
did have an issue of some corrosion in the sealed drag area. Lamson
quickly fixed it, and for free. They recently updated the reel, so you
can find some good deals on the older versions. IMO, the "Guide finish"
is much more durable than the black/blue finish.

brians

On Sat, 18 Aug 2007 19:43:02 -0000, mdk77
wrote:

On Aug 18, 2:03 pm, wrote:
On Sat, 18 Aug 2007 18:15:27 -0000, mdk77
wrote:



By next season I'm planning on adding an 8wt rod & reel to the 6wt I
already have. I'm going to build the rod over the winter (something
to keep me from losing my mind over the long winter months of
Illinois). This outfit will be for Bass & Musky. Also, this year I
fished Atlantic Canada for trout in an area that had good sea trout
and salmon fishing. I'd like to go after them with this 8wt the next
time I'm up there (I only fished for trout this year with my 6wt).

Between now and spring I'm going to keep my eyes open for a great deal
on a used 8wt reel. I'm on a limited budget so I'm going to take my
time and wait for a really good deal to come my way. My question is;
what brand/models of reels would be on a "short list" to look for?
Something that could handle Musky and Salmon.

I'm hoping to get a reel that will last me a lifetime, at a price of ~
$100 used. I could go a bit higher if I had to. This is a reel I'd
fish with 90% of the time (and I fish a LOT.....I even fish over my
lunch hour at work at a nearby lake..........and I fish two spring-fed
lakes that are short walking distance from my home (they're my "home
away from home" places)

Thanks for any help.

How old are you and when do you plan on dying? About the only
widely-available reel that has absolutely proven to last "a lifetime" -
assuming "a lifetime" to mean 30-plus years - and is readily available
for under $100USD is the US-made Medalist. Are there newer reels that
are shaping up to fit into a "last a lifetime" criteria? Yep, and in
about 20 years or so, we'll know for sure. OTOH, if you only plan on
living a year or two, any number of reels will fit, new and used, esp.
for freshwater-only usage. What you might luck into, or what you mean
by "a bit higher," could make a huge difference.

My favorite "modern" readily-available reel is the Tibor/Billy Pate, but
you'll really need to luck into one OR "a bit higher" will have to mean
"at least double" to fit your stated criteria. OTOH and IMO, a
reasonably well-maintained BP would last "a lifetime," even if you are
10 years old and plan on living to about 128.

TC,
R

I'm hoping I can get a decent price on a used reel if I take my time
over the winter and look. I'm hoping to find one for closer to $100,
but definitely less than $200. BTW, I'm 54 years old, so hopefully
I'll "last" a good bit longer......40+ more years of fishing would be
nice :-)

Here are some reels I've considered, but they need to be in the 8wt
I'm looking for. Is there a good place to look online other than Ebay
for used reels?

Here are some reels I've noticed that might be in my price range used
(if I can find one in an 8wt):
Scientific Anglers System-2 Series
Ross Gunnison G2
Orvis Battenkill Mid Arbor
Orvis Mach Large Arbor
Ross Cimarron Large Arbor (and the
I see Lamson reels on Ebay that are sometimes in my range (the
Lightspeed in particular)
Redington RS2
There's an Abel Big Game on Ebay now for $127

Or are all of these decent reels that if I can get one at a decent
price, would be a good deal?


Sweet mother of geeziful mercsus....are you sure you didn't forget any
on that list?

OK, fine. The only reel on that list that you should consider is the
Ross (no, the other one) and don't pay a penny over $91.28USD. Don't
like that answer? Alrighty, then. The only reel you should consider is
SA System 2 at no more than $87.73. OTOH..."about the only
widely-available reel that has absolutely proven to last "a lifetime" -
assuming "a lifetime" to mean 30-plus years - and is readily available
for under $100USD is the US-made Medalist. Are there newer reels that
are shaping up to fit into a "last a lifetime" criteria? Yep, and in
about 20 years or so, we'll know for sure."

Seriously (and within reason), most any fairly recent "name" reel being
sold regularly and in good overall condition for under $100USD used/$150
plus/minus new is going to be what it is/was intended to be: a decent
enough general-purpose lighter-duty reel that will perform more or less
adequately if given reasonable care and not subject to abuse or heavy
usage. Under those condition, will it last "a lifetime?" Again, it
depends on how long you plan to live, and IAC, it'll probably last long
enough so as to be cost-effective. OTOH, try to put one into heavy
sport/client use in a busy (salt) flats guide service for "a lifetime"
of service, and well...here's hoping your (and the reel's) short life
will be a merry one...

And regardless of what, ahem, others might offer, fly (fishing) rods do
have a direct relationship with AFTMA weight, reels do not - IOW, there
is an "8wt rod," but there is no "8wt reel." Reels, basically, are
truly matched via things such as capacity, component material/fresh or
salt usage, quarry, etc. Granted, this does "suggest" a general reel
size to a general range of rod weights, but that is not all there is to
it. For example, a reel model perfectly acceptable for, oh, say,
short-range Illernoise bass fishing (an under-$100USD US-made Medalist,
for example) might have a coupla-few sizes (for example, a 1495/95.5,
96/96.5, or even 98) that would be OK on a 7 or 8 rod, yet all would be
a poor choice to use on an 8 intended for bonefish. And while a reel
that would be a good choice for bonefish (a BP Bonefish, for example,
which is, physical size-wise, a wide BP Salmon) would also be fine for
the bass fishing, it'd be big-time overkill expense-wise.

TC,
R