A scholarly read on C&R and other human sporting activities involving the natural world.

For those who might be interested in a more scholarly discertation on the
C&R issue, I would offer up the sugestion to read "With Respect for
Nature-Living as Part of the Natural World" by J. Claude Evans. The book is
published by the State University of New York Press as part of their series
in Environmental Philosophy and Ethics.

Particularly Part V - The Ethics of Catch and Release Fishing.

For a philosophy professor, he writes in such a manner that an accountant
can understand it.

It's a bit pricey in hardcover but the softcover version is $23.95 from
www.sunypress.edu

On 8/1/06 9:06 PM, in article ,
"Wayne Knight" wrote:

For those who might be interested in a more scholarly discertation on the
C&R issue, I would offer up the sugestion to read "With Respect for
Nature-Living as Part of the Natural World" by J. Claude Evans. The book is
published by the State University of New York Press as part of their series
in Environmental Philosophy and Ethics.

Particularly Part V - The Ethics of Catch and Release Fishing.

For a philosophy professor, he writes in such a manner that an accountant
can understand it.

Bah, all that reading'll just make it more confusing! :-)

It's a bit pricey in hardcover but the softcover version is $23.95 from
www.sunypress.edu

Or head on over to your local library, smile at the librarian, and say "I'd
like this book, please." :-)

Thanks for the pointer, Monsignor.

Bill

On 8/1/06 9:06 PM, in article ,
"Wayne Knight" wrote:

For those who might be interested in a more scholarly discertation on the
C&R issue, I would offer up the sugestion to read "With Respect for
Nature-Living as Part of the Natural World" by J. Claude Evans. The book is
published by the State University of New York Press as part of their series
in Environmental Philosophy and Ethics.

Particularly Part V - The Ethics of Catch and Release Fishing.

For a philosophy professor, he writes in such a manner that an accountant
can understand it.

It's a bit pricey in hardcover but the softcover version is $23.95 from
www.sunypress.edu

I'm going to reply again. Just trotted upstairs and snagged (er, sorry)
this one off the shelf. Interesting that the small line drawing
illustration at the head of each chapter is a nice and sharp looking salmon
fly!

It does indeed look like a good read, Wayne. Thanks for the, er, pointer.

Bill
(sorry to say it has end notes, Wolfgang :-)

William Claspy wrote:

I'm going to reply again. Just trotted upstairs and snagged (er, sorry)
this one off the shelf. Interesting that the small line drawing
illustration at the head of each chapter is a nice and sharp looking salmon
fly!

It does indeed look like a good read, Wayne. Thanks for the, er, pointer.


Glad to be of assistance. If you want the cliff notes version, I
started to quote the last paragraph from Chapter 9 in my post.

William Claspy wrote:
"Wayne Knight" wrote:

For those who might be interested in a more scholarly discertation on the
C&R issue, I would offer up the sugestion to read "With Respect for
Nature-Living as Part of the Natural World" by J. Claude Evans. The book is
published by the State University of New York Press as part of their series
in Environmental Philosophy and Ethics.

Particularly Part V - The Ethics of Catch and Release Fishing.

Thanks for the pointer, Monsignor.

Those of you with a Google account can read the first three pages of
this chapter by typing "The Ethics of Catch and Release Fishing" into
Google Book Search. Make sure the "All books" option is checked.

--
John Russell aka JR

On 8/2/06 11:31 PM, in article , "JR"
wrote:

William Claspy wrote:
"Wayne Knight" wrote:

For those who might be interested in a more scholarly discertation on the
C&R issue, I would offer up the sugestion to read "With Respect for
Nature-Living as Part of the Natural World" by J. Claude Evans. The book is
published by the State University of New York Press as part of their series
in Environmental Philosophy and Ethics.

Particularly Part V - The Ethics of Catch and Release Fishing.

Thanks for the pointer, Monsignor.

Those of you with a Google account can read the first three pages of
this chapter by typing "The Ethics of Catch and Release Fishing" into
Google Book Search. Make sure the "All books" option is checked.

There is also a bit of the text available on Amazon. And their interesting
"concordance" stats. Hm!

After reading most of the appendix (which is really a chapter), I scent a
whiff of something I don't like about Evans. I can't tell yet if he is just
*reviewing* something I don't agree with, or if it is his personal, er,
calling. I have to read it more carefully. If the latter, I think it might
color how I read the rest of the book. But I still want to read section 5
for the overview.

The "technical" chapters (his phrase) are what amounts to a literature
review of the topic, not a bad thing, but, well, technical, and pretty tough
reading (for me.) Kant, Nietzshe, and Schweitzer. Big apples! And him
sort of taking to task some of his fellow philosophy professors who have
also written on the topic.

Bill