Question for anglers

I've been a fisherman all my life, but there's one observation I've made that nobody seems to be able to answer, even fellow anglers. All anybody has ever been able to come up with is "I don't know. I guess I've always done it that way. Never really thought about it".

Here goes.

Right-handed people cast their line and hold their pole with their right hand, lefties with their left hand. When trouting, right-handed people reel their line with their left hand (since their right hand is holding the pole, right?). Same scenario for lefties. Hold the pole with the left hand, reel the line with the right.

Here's my question:

When salmon fishing, why do people switch hands and reel with the same hand they normally hold the pole with? I guess I'm the exception to the rule, as I salmon fish the same way I fish for trout, but EVERY other salmon angler I have seen will switch hands when they play a fish, choosing to reel in their fish and hold the pole with opposite hands. Wouldn't it make more sense to have your strong arm hold the pole when playing a mighty atlantic salmon? Why switch hands?

This one has be dumbfounded, and like I said, even seasoned, veteran anlglers can't come up with a logical explanation.

When trouting, right-handed people reel their line with their left hand (since their right hand is holding the pole, right?).

Hrmm not me...I cast it with my right...place it in my left, and reel with my right




---
Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free.
Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com).
Version: 6.0.712 / Virus Database: 468 - Release Date: 7/3/2004

Old spinning reel which only has a one-sided handle perhaps? Fly reels can be worked from either side.
"TGP" wrote in message ...
When trouting, right-handed people reel their line with their left hand (since their right hand is holding the pole, right?).

Hrmm not me...I cast it with my right...place it in my left, and reel with my right




---
Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free.
Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com).
Version: 6.0.712 / Virus Database: 468 - Release Date: 7/3/2004

Nope, its how I feel comfortable

8shrug*

--
http://www.vinlandphotography.20m.com
http://www.nfsportsweekly.com
"Stunning Steve" wrote in message ...
Old spinning reel which only has a one-sided handle perhaps? Fly reels can be worked from either side.
"TGP" wrote in message ...
When trouting, right-handed people reel their line with their left hand (since their right hand is holding the pole, right?).

Hrmm not me...I cast it with my right...place it in my left, and reel with my right




---
Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free.
Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com).
Version: 6.0.712 / Virus Database: 468 - Release Date: 7/3/2004


---
Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free.
Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com).
Version: 6.0.712 / Virus Database: 468 - Release Date: 7/4/2004

Stunning Steve entered the world pub known as rec.outdoors.fishing and
said...

Old spinning reel which only has a one-sided handle perhaps? Fly reels can be worked from either side.

I must be a bit different then fly rods and open face spinners I reel with
my left and hold with my right, closed face and bait casters I reel with my
right and hold with my left.

I am right handed btw.

--
Jim M
posted on this day, the 3962nd of September 1993
To reply by e-mail catch the ZZZZZZ's in my addy...

"I love deadlines. I especially like the whooshing sound they make as they
go flying by." -- Douglas Adams

"Look alive. Here comes a buzzard." -- Walt Kelly (Pogo)

Save the earth. It's the only planet with chocolate.

Jim M. wrote:


I must be a bit different then fly rods and open face spinners I reel with
my left and hold with my right, closed face and bait casters I reel with my
right and hold with my left.

I am right handed btw.



Same thing here with me. I think the main reason is normally when I'm
using a bait casting reel I can use both hands to put leverage on the
fish and pull back with while both hands are wrapped around the reel.
Seems with a spinning reel if I try that I kind of push the reel
sideways with my left hand and it just feels awkward. Also when I set
the hook or fight a fish with spinning reel I'll move my left hand to
the rod or just leave it on the handle but put on force against the
reel. Reading what I just wrote I haven't a clue what I just said, just
know it works for me.

Jerry

i cast with me right
i hold it with my right
and i hold the fly rod with my right
reel with me left
i must be an exception to

adam
"Stunning Steve" wrote in message ...
I've been a fisherman all my life, but there's one observation I've made that nobody seems to be able to answer, even fellow anglers. All anybody has ever been able to come up with is "I don't know. I guess I've always done it that way. Never really thought about it".

Here goes.

Right-handed people cast their line and hold their pole with their right hand, lefties with their left hand. When trouting, right-handed people reel their line with their left hand (since their right hand is holding the pole, right?). Same scenario for lefties. Hold the pole with the left hand, reel the line with the right.

Here's my question:

When salmon fishing, why do people switch hands and reel with the same hand they normally hold the pole with? I guess I'm the exception to the rule, as I salmon fish the same way I fish for trout, but EVERY other salmon angler I have seen will switch hands when they play a fish, choosing to reel in their fish and hold the pole with opposite hands. Wouldn't it make more sense to have your strong arm hold the pole when playing a mighty atlantic salmon? Why switch hands?

This one has be dumbfounded, and like I said, even seasoned, veteran anlglers can't come up with a logical explanation.

Jerry entered the world pub known as rec.outdoors.fishing and said...

Jim M. wrote:


I must be a bit different then fly rods and open face spinners I reel with
my left and hold with my right, closed face and bait casters I reel with my
right and hold with my left.

I am right handed btw.



Same thing here with me. I think the main reason is normally when I'm
using a bait casting reel I can use both hands to put leverage on the
fish and pull back with while both hands are wrapped around the reel.
Seems with a spinning reel if I try that I kind of push the reel
sideways with my left hand and it just feels awkward. Also when I set
the hook or fight a fish with spinning reel I'll move my left hand to
the rod or just leave it on the handle but put on force against the
reel. Reading what I just wrote I haven't a clue what I just said, just
know it works for me.


I understood it perfectly. For me I think it's more that I'm just too damned
lazy to change the handles from one side to the other. The fly ride I
learned on though only had a handle on the left side, it was pretty old even
back 30 years ago when I learned how to use it.
--
Jim M
posted on this day, the 3963rd of September 1993
To reply by e-mail catch the ZZZZZZ's in my addy...

"I love deadlines. I especially like the whooshing sound they make as they
go flying by." -- Douglas Adams

"Look alive. Here comes a buzzard." -- Walt Kelly (Pogo)

Save the earth. It's the only planet with chocolate.

Jerry entered the world pub known as rec.outdoors.fishing and said...

Jim M. wrote:


I must be a bit different then fly rods and open face spinners I reel with
my left and hold with my right, closed face and bait casters I reel with my
right and hold with my left.

I am right handed btw.



Same thing here with me. I think the main reason is normally when I'm
using a bait casting reel I can use both hands to put leverage on the
fish and pull back with while both hands are wrapped around the reel.
Seems with a spinning reel if I try that I kind of push the reel
sideways with my left hand and it just feels awkward. Also when I set
the hook or fight a fish with spinning reel I'll move my left hand to
the rod or just leave it on the handle but put on force against the
reel. Reading what I just wrote I haven't a clue what I just said, just
know it works for me.


I understood it perfectly. For me I think it's more that I'm just too damned
lazy to change the handles from one side to the other. The fly ride I
learned on though only had a handle on the left side, it was pretty old even
back 30 years ago when I learned how to use it.
--
Jim M
posted on this day, the 3963rd of September 1993
To reply by e-mail catch the ZZZZZZ's in my addy...

"I love deadlines. I especially like the whooshing sound they make as they
go flying by." -- Douglas Adams

"Look alive. Here comes a buzzard." -- Walt Kelly (Pogo)

Save the earth. It's the only planet with chocolate.

Mee too. I'm right handed. Spinning Rod. Cast with right hand, switch pole to left hand, reel with right hand.
Fly, opposite, cast with right hand, reel with left hand...Weird...??
"TGP" wrote in message ...
When trouting, right-handed people reel their line with their left hand (since their right hand is holding the pole, right?).

Hrmm not me...I cast it with my right...place it in my left, and reel with my right




---
Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free.
Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com).
Version: 6.0.712 / Virus Database: 468 - Release Date: 7/3/2004