Quick Corrode Hooks

"Conan The Librarian" wrote in message
...
No left turn wrote:

Think about it.
Gut hook a fish or break off a trophy and rest assured it hasn't
just received a death sentence.

If the idea of gut hooking fish bothers you, don't use bait. If the
fish breaks off, I seriously doubt it's a death sentence. I've caught
fish with hooks still embedded in their jaws, and I'll bet most ROFFians
have too. Some ROFFians have even told of catching a fish with their own
fly embedded in its jaw. (I.e., the fish broke off yet continued to feed
and took a fly a second time.)

'Cause I don't believe most fish survive waiting for a standard hook
to corrode, lets keep this thread on the topic of corrosion
please.

Sorry I couldn't help there. Since I don't believe that most fish die
waiting for a standard hook to corrode, I think you have a solution
looking for a problem.

HTH.


Chuck Vance

Chuck, I'm not in a ggogling mood but it seems I recall this subject making
the rounds a few years back. However, around that time I had read an article
in a magazine, addressing this very subject.

Firstly, of the things I read, most did not address the use of hemostats - I
don't know that I've ever hurt a fish, no matter how deeply hooked, when
I've had my hemostats and indeed will not fish without them.

Anyhow the article summarized by saying that foul hooked fished did not
suffer the mortality one might expect. And that it might even be better to
leave a portion of line attached to the hook ( if the fish must be released
with hook) in order to help keep the hook from sliding crosswise in the
throat.

Secondly, secondly, . . ah well, lost my train of thought.

john

asadi wrote:

Chuck, I'm not in a ggogling mood but it seems I recall this subject making
the rounds a few years back. However, around that time I had read an article
in a magazine, addressing this very subject.

Firstly, of the things I read, most did not address the use of hemostats - I
don't know that I've ever hurt a fish, no matter how deeply hooked, when
I've had my hemostats and indeed will not fish without them.

Anyhow the article summarized by saying that foul hooked fished did not
suffer the mortality one might expect. And that it might even be better to
leave a portion of line attached to the hook ( if the fish must be released
with hook) in order to help keep the hook from sliding crosswise in the
throat.

Yep, that's exactly what our F&W folks recommend. Snip the line and
leave the hook. It will corrode on its own, and it doesn't seem to
interfere with feeding.

I'm starting to wonder if this whole thread was spam, as our OP
seems to have disappeared altogether.


Chuck Vance (maybe he just quick corroded away)

In article , says...
I'm starting to wonder if this whole thread was spam, as our OP
seems to have disappeared altogether.



No, spam is unwanted commercial advertising. It might have been
trolling, which is intentionally stirring up an argument. I don't
think he/she was a troll, though, because he/she seemed perfectly
sincere in his/her mindboggling ignorance.

Kevin
(Who has the cluebat this week, anyway?)

In article ,
says...

No, spam is unwanted commercial advertising. It might have been

Damn, I thought I was in that other thread spawned by a clueless
idiot. Sorry about that.

Kevin,
who is taking a lot of cold medication lately.

You could use whatever metal they made Gremlins from.

On Wed, 16 Nov 2005 21:20:59 -0600, "No left turn"
wrote:

'Cause I don't believe most fish survive waiting for a standard hook =
to corrode, lets keep this thread on the topic of corrosion =
please.

First, turn off your html. It's a pia.

Most (all?) fresh water hooks will eventually completely erode in
fresh water. Your fears are unfounded.

Dave

"Dave LaCourse" wrote in message
...
...Most (all?) fresh water hooks will eventually completely erode in
fresh water.

So will plutonium.

Your fears are unfounded.

Well, unless you're planning on having grandchildren.

Wolfgang
who always thought erosion was a problem, not a .......wait for
it.......solution!

Wolfgang typed:
"Dave LaCourse" wrote in message
...
...Most (all?) fresh water hooks will eventually completely erode in
fresh water.

So will plutonium.

Your fears are unfounded.

Well, unless you're planning on having grandchildren.

Wolfgang
who always thought erosion was a problem, not a .......wait for
it.......solution!

That, my friend, depends on if you're the dirt or the ditch.
--
TL,
Tim
------------------------
http://css.sbcma.com/timj/

On Wed, 16 Nov 2005 21:20:59 -0600, "No left turn"
wrote:

This is a multi-part message in MIME format.

------=_NextPart_000_0083_01C5EAF3.A3E16F60
Content-Type: text/plain;
charset="iso-8859-1"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable

Quick Corrode Hooks ?

What kind of alloy would make a good hook AND corrode in fresh =
water in about a week.
Think something like Sintered Cast Iron would work?
What metals corrode in a few days?

I love to have hooks like this for my plastic worms and my =
foam poppers. So what if the lure needs a bit more care...

Think about it.
Gut hook a fish or break off a trophy and rest assured it hasn't =
just received a death sentence.

Or How about hooks lost in those mixed use areas? Be nice to know =
that hooks lost near the boat dock wont be around to snag a =
kids foot the next week.

Any metallurgist geniuses out there?
Hey - What did Chrysler used to make those K cars out of ?

'Cause I don't believe most fish survive waiting for a standard hook =
to corrode, lets keep this thread on the topic of corrosion =
please.

Steve P
Dallas FlyFishers
------=_NextPart_000_0083_01C5EAF3.A3E16F60
Content-Type: text/html;
charset="iso-8859-1"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable

!DOCTYPE HTML PUBLIC "-//W3C//DTD HTML 4.0 Transitional//EN"
HTMLHEAD
META http-equiv=3DContent-Type content=3D"text/html; =
charset=3Diso-8859-1"
META content=3D"MSHTML 6.00.2900.2769" name=3DGENERATOR
STYLE/STYLE
/HEAD
BODY bgColor=3D#ffffff
DIVFONT face=3DArial size=3D2
DIVFONT face=3DArial size=3D2Quick Corrode Hooks   =
?/FONT/DIV
DIVFONT face=3DArial size=3D2/FONT /DIV
DIVFONT face=3DArial size=3D2What  kind   of  =
alloy  would=20
make a  good  hook  AND corrode  in fresh  =
water=20
 in about a week./FONT/DIV
DIVFONT face=3DArial size=3D2Think  something like Sintered =
Cast =20
Iron  would  work?/FONT/DIV
DIVWhat metals corrode in a few days?/DIV
DIVFONT face=3DArial size=3D2/FONT /DIV
DIVFONT face=3DArial size=3D2I love  to  have  =
hooks  like=20
 this  for  my plastic  =
worms   and =20
my  foam  poppers.   So what  if  =
the =20
lure  needs a bit  more care.../FONT/DIV
DIVFONT face=3DArial size=3D2/FONT /DIV
DIVFONT face=3DArial size=3D2Think about  it./FONT/DIV
DIVFONT face=3DArial size=3D2Gut  hook a fish =
or break  off=20
 a trophy and  rest assured  =20
it  hasn't  just received a death =
sentence./FONT/DIV
DIVFONT face=3DArial size=3D2/FONT /DIV
DIVFONT face=3DArial size=3D2Or  How about  hooks lost in =
those=20
mixed  use areas?  Be  nice  to  know  =
that =20
hooks  lost  near  the boat  dock  =
wont =20
be  around  to snag a kids foot the next =
week./FONT/DIV
DIVFONT face=3DArial size=3D2/FONTFONT face=3DArial =
size=3D2/FONT /DIV
DIVFONT face=3DArial size=3D2Any metallurgist   =
geniuses =20
out  there?/FONT/DIV
DIVFONT face=3DArial size=3D2Hey  -  What  did =20
Chrysler  used  to make  those  K cars  =
out  of=20
?/FONT/DIV
DIVFONT face=3DArial size=3D2/FONT /DIV
DIV'Cause I don't believe most  fish  survive waiting  =
for=20
a  standard hook  to corrode,  lets  keep  =
this =20
thread  on the topic of  corrosion  please./DIV
DIVFONT face=3DArial size=3D2/FONT /DIV
DIVFONT face=3DArial size=3D2Steve P/FONT/DIV
DIVFONT face=3DArial size=3D2Dallas FlyFishers/FONTFONT =
face=3DArial=20
size=3D2/FONT/DIV/FONT/DIV/BODY/HTML

------=_NextPart_000_0083_01C5EAF3.A3E16F60--

Can you see why you should turn off your html?

On Wed, 16 Nov 2005 21:20:59 -0600, "No left turn"
wrote:

Quick Corrode Hooks ?

What kind of alloy would make a good hook AND corrode in fresh water in about a week.
Think something like Sintered Cast Iron would work?
What metals corrode in a few days?


Our DNR recommends cutting the line (close to the fish) when it's deep
hooked, if one is doing catch and release. Their figures (you'll have
to check with them for the basis) are that the hook is completely
corroded by digestive fluids (yes, all the liquid in fish is other
than pure distilled water) within a max of two weeks and is generally
harmless. If you're not doing catch and release, filet the fish
quickly so that you can retrieve your lure and hook before the
corrosion starts.

Cyli
r.bc: vixen. Minnow goddess. Speaker to squirrels.
Often taunted by trout. Almost entirely harmless.

http://www.visi.com/~cyli
email: lid (strip the .invalid to email)