What kind of fish is this?

http://www.pchar.uku.co.uk/whatfish/
Feedback much appreciated
Many Thanks in advance
Dave

On Fri, 27 Apr 2007 at 18:17:00 in uk.rec.fishing.game peakstroller
wrote:
http://www.pchar.uku.co.uk/whatfish/
Feedback much appreciated
Many Thanks in advance
Dave

Looks like a very thin brown trout - probably now dead after being
exposed to the air like that. When was it caught?

--
Nogood Boyo

On 28 Apr, 10:03, Nogood Boyo wrote:
On Fri, 27 Apr 2007 at 18:17:00 in uk.rec.fishing.game peakstroller
wrote: http://www.pchar.uku.co.uk/whatfish/
Feedback much appreciated
Many Thanks in advance
Dave

Looks like a very thin brown trout - probably now dead after being
exposed to the air like that. When was it caught?

--
Nogood Boyo

The fish is not probably dead but definately as dead as the embers on
whic it was cookded. What is the best way to expose it to air?

On Sat, 28 Apr 2007 at 02:18:46 in uk.rec.fishing.game peakstroller
wrote:
On 28 Apr, 10:03, Nogood Boyo wrote:
On Fri, 27 Apr 2007 at 18:17:00 in uk.rec.fishing.game peakstroller
wrote: http://www.pchar.uku.co.uk/whatfish/
Feedback much appreciated
Many Thanks in advance
Dave

Looks like a very thin brown trout - probably now dead after being
exposed to the air like that. When was it caught?

The fish is not probably dead but definately as dead as the embers on
whic it was cookded. What is the best way to expose it to air?

:-) That's OK then. Best way..? I don't understand the question. I
was making the point that people who catch and release after taking
pictures like that are probably killing fish without realising it. They
can't tolerate very long out of the water - it damages the gills. But
if you killed it and ate it, that's fine. It's the only good reason for
catching a fish IMHO...

--
Nogood Boyo

On 28 Apr, 12:11, Nogood Boyo wrote:
On Sat, 28 Apr 2007 at 02:18:46 in uk.rec.fishing.game peakstroller
wrote:On 28 Apr, 10:03, Nogood Boyo wrote:
On Fri, 27 Apr 2007 at 18:17:00 in uk.rec.fishing.game peakstroller
wrote: http://www.pchar.uku.co.uk/whatfish/
Feedback much appreciated
Many Thanks in advance
Dave

Looks like a very thin brown trout - probably now dead after being
exposed to the air like that. When was it caught?

The fish is not probably dead but definately as dead as the embers on
whic it was cookded. What is the best way to expose it to air?

:-) That's OK then. Best way..? I don't understand the question. I
was making the point that people who catch and release after taking
pictures like that are probably killing fish without realising it. They
can't tolerate very long out of the water - it damages the gills. But
if you killed it and ate it, that's fine. It's the only good reason for
catching a fish IMHO...

--
Nogood Boyo

the coloring is wrong for browns, i presums this is sea trout instead
with colouring and inverted bottom jaw like that. Sea trout.. hope
you had a game licience to kill it?

On Fri, 18 May 2007 at 04:29:12 in uk.rec.fishing.game
wrote:
On 28 Apr, 12:11, Nogood Boyo wrote:
On Sat, 28 Apr 2007 at 02:18:46 in uk.rec.fishing.game peakstroller
wrote:On 28 Apr, 10:03, Nogood Boyo wrote:
On Fri, 27 Apr 2007 at 18:17:00 in uk.rec.fishing.game peakstroller
wrote: http://www.pchar.uku.co.uk/whatfish/
Feedback much appreciated
Many Thanks in advance
Dave

Looks like a very thin brown trout - probably now dead after being
exposed to the air like that. When was it caught?

The fish is not probably dead but definately as dead as the embers on
whic it was cookded. What is the best way to expose it to air?

:-) That's OK then. Best way..? I don't understand the question. I
was making the point that people who catch and release after taking
pictures like that are probably killing fish without realising it. They
can't tolerate very long out of the water - it damages the gills. But
if you killed it and ate it, that's fine. It's the only good reason for
catching a fish IMHO...

the coloring is wrong for browns, i presums this is sea trout instead
with colouring and inverted bottom jaw like that. Sea trout.. hope
you had a game licience to kill it?

Browns come in a wide range of colours. There's a distinct trace of
yellow in there which suggests to me that it's a brown trout rather than
a sea trout. But they are the same species of course so who can say,
without knowing when and where it was caught. Never heard of an
"inverted bottom jaw" being an indicator for sea trout. Where did you
get that idea?

It looks thin but it's a good size and has a hell of a good tail on it.
I suspect it's a brown which hasn't recovered properly from spawning. If
the OP had to ask what fish it is, the chances of technicalities like
licensing and season having been observed are remote. The fine mesh net
looks like one used by a coarse angler rather than a game angler.

--
Nogood Boyo

Nogood Boyo and PlymouthAC
I'm not seeking your permission or asking what you consider ok or fine
about taking a fish for the table. I'm not asking you to presume or
assume "technicalities" such as licensing, seasonal considerations or
heaven forbid an angler might possibly hunt for Coarse fish AND Game
fish with the same landing net. Perhaps before fishing in future I
should send you a copy of my E.A license to satisfy your high
horseishness, my driving license to show you I traveled to the water
legally and proof that my red Wellingtons have been sprayed green to
match the environment.

On Apr 28, 2:17 am, peakstroller wrote:
http://www.pchar.uku.co.uk/whatfish/
Feedback much appreciated
Many Thanks in advance
Dave

thats diffently a brown trout

shane

In article .com,
peakstroller writes
Nogood Boyo and PlymouthAC
I'm not seeking your permission or asking what you consider ok or fine
about taking a fish for the table. I'm not asking you to presume or
assume "technicalities" such as licensing, seasonal considerations or
heaven forbid an angler might possibly hunt for Coarse fish AND Game
fish with the same landing net. Perhaps before fishing in future I
should send you a copy of my E.A license to satisfy your high
horseishness, my driving license to show you I traveled to the water
legally and proof that my red Wellingtons have been sprayed green to
match the environment.


You're over-reacting a bit now.

Nogood Boyo's advice regarding catching trout and holding them up for
photos prior to release is NOT a good thing. If you or anyone takes a
photo of a trout they intend killing for the pot - fair enough.

Read his post again and you will see he has tendered some sound advice

Expressing opinion in print can be misinterpreted as there is no emotion
or feeling attached to the words. Your reaction on the other hand is
full of emotion/sarcasm which is not appropriate to the responses you
received.
--
Bill Grey

On Tue, 22 May 2007 at 05:55:27 in uk.rec.fishing.game peakstroller
wrote:
Nogood Boyo and PlymouthAC
I'm not seeking your permission or asking what you consider ok or fine
about taking a fish for the table. I'm not asking you to presume or
assume "technicalities" such as licensing, seasonal considerations or
heaven forbid an angler might possibly hunt for Coarse fish AND Game
fish with the same landing net. Perhaps before fishing in future I
should send you a copy of my E.A license to satisfy your high
horseishness, my driving license to show you I traveled to the water
legally and proof that my red Wellingtons have been sprayed green to
match the environment.

Methinks he doth protest too much... :-)

--
Nogood Boyo