Is it still fly fishing if you use live bait?

Bob La Londe wrote:
"Ken Fortenberry" wrote in message
om...
John wrote:
"Bob La Londe" asked "Is it still fly fishing if you use live bait?

Probably not but who cares? It is lots of fun and very, very effective.

Bob talked about his wise dad then he says:

I was reading something recently and thining that it would be a good way
to get a little more distance dead sticking a small minnow. (then again
maybe not. That minnow would sure get dried out swinging through the
air. LOL.
And, it you substituted one of your little plastic minnows for the live
one, you're back to pure fly fishing.
Fishing with bait isn't fly fishing, it's bait fishing. Fishing
with plastic minnows isn't fly fishing, it's lure fishing.
Fishing with fur and feathers tied to a hook, *that's* fly fishing.
Not that there's anything wrong with using a fly rod to fish any
legal way you want to fish, but fly rod notwithstanding if you
ain't fishing with a fly you ain't fly fishing.

In my ain't never been humble opinion, of course. ;-)


Yeah, whatever... from the guy with a bobber on his fly line. Oh, wait you
hoity toity fly guys call that a strike indicator. LOL. :^)

You're mistaken, Bob. I am definitely not the guy with a
bobber on his fly line. I used a strike indicator exactly
once in my life on the San Juan in New Mexico because the
guide didn't know how to fish any other way. I had to take
a hot shower afterwards to wash off the shame. ;-)

--
Ken Fortenberry

LOL

"Ken Fortenberry" wrote in message
. com...
Bob La Londe wrote:
"Ken Fortenberry" wrote in message
om...
John wrote:
"Bob La Londe" asked "Is it still fly fishing if you use live bait?

Probably not but who cares? It is lots of fun and very, very
effective.

Bob talked about his wise dad then he says:

I was reading something recently and thining that it would be a good
way to get a little more distance dead sticking a small minnow. (then
again maybe not. That minnow would sure get dried out swinging
through the air. LOL.
And, it you substituted one of your little plastic minnows for the live
one, you're back to pure fly fishing.
Fishing with bait isn't fly fishing, it's bait fishing. Fishing
with plastic minnows isn't fly fishing, it's lure fishing.
Fishing with fur and feathers tied to a hook, *that's* fly fishing.
Not that there's anything wrong with using a fly rod to fish any
legal way you want to fish, but fly rod notwithstanding if you
ain't fishing with a fly you ain't fly fishing.

In my ain't never been humble opinion, of course. ;-)


Yeah, whatever... from the guy with a bobber on his fly line. Oh, wait
you hoity toity fly guys call that a strike indicator. LOL. :^)

You're mistaken, Bob. I am definitely not the guy with a
bobber on his fly line. I used a strike indicator exactly
once in my life on the San Juan in New Mexico because the
guide didn't know how to fish any other way. I had to take
a hot shower afterwards to wash off the shame. ;-)

--
Ken Fortenberry

"Ken Fortenberry" wrote in message
. com...
Bob La Londe wrote:
"Ken Fortenberry" wrote in message
om...
John wrote:
"Bob La Londe" asked "Is it still fly fishing if you use live bait?

Probably not but who cares? It is lots of fun and very, very
effective.

Bob talked about his wise dad then he says:

I was reading something recently and thining that it would be a good
way to get a little more distance dead sticking a small minnow. (then
again maybe not. That minnow would sure get dried out swinging
through the air. LOL.
And, it you substituted one of your little plastic minnows for the live
one, you're back to pure fly fishing.
Fishing with bait isn't fly fishing, it's bait fishing. Fishing
with plastic minnows isn't fly fishing, it's lure fishing.
Fishing with fur and feathers tied to a hook, *that's* fly fishing.
Not that there's anything wrong with using a fly rod to fish any
legal way you want to fish, but fly rod notwithstanding if you
ain't fishing with a fly you ain't fly fishing.

In my ain't never been humble opinion, of course. ;-)


Yeah, whatever... from the guy with a bobber on his fly line. Oh, wait
you hoity toity fly guys call that a strike indicator. LOL. :^)

You're mistaken, Bob. I am definitely not the guy with a
bobber on his fly line. I used a strike indicator exactly
once in my life on the San Juan in New Mexico because the
guide didn't know how to fish any other way. I had to take
a hot shower afterwards to wash off the shame. ;-)


LOL. Well, I can honestly say I have never put a bobber on my fly line. So
there! LOL.

Although I have used a 9'+ fly rod with a spinning reel to serve up minnows
to baulky bass, and I didn't use a bobber. LOL.


--
Bob La Londe - Webmaster
www.YumaBassMan.com

Tornament Director
www.YumaProAm.com






*** Posted via a free Usenet account from http://www.teranews.com ***

"Bob La Londe" wrote in message SNIP

LOL. Well, I can honestly say I have never put a bobber on my fly line.
So there! LOL.

Although I have used a 9'+ fly rod with a spinning reel to serve up
minnows to baulky bass, and I didn't use a bobber. LOL.

Well, I have to say that I agree with Ken on this one. Fly fishing is using
a fly, constructed of hair, feathers, maybe some foam rubber and thread,
delivered by the line casting the lightweight "lure". With fly fishing,
you're trying to fool a gamefish with an imitation.

Using live bait, regardless of what rod/reel combination, is livebait
fishing. Sure, it's fun and still a challenge, but it's not fly-fishing!
--
Steve @ OutdoorFrontiers
http://www.outdoorfrontiers.com
G & S Guide Service and Custom Rods
http://www.herefishyfishy.com

"Steve @ OutdoorFrontiers" wrote in
message ...

"Bob La Londe" wrote in message SNIP

LOL. Well, I can honestly say I have never put a bobber on my fly line.
So there! LOL.

Although I have used a 9'+ fly rod with a spinning reel to serve up
minnows to baulky bass, and I didn't use a bobber. LOL.

Well, I have to say that I agree with Ken on this one. Fly fishing is
using a fly, constructed of hair, feathers, maybe some foam rubber and
thread, delivered by the line casting the lightweight "lure". With fly
fishing, you're trying to fool a gamefish with an imitation.

Using live bait, regardless of what rod/reel combination, is livebait
fishing. Sure, it's fun and still a challenge, but it's not fly-fishing!
--
Steve @ OutdoorFrontiers
http://www.outdoorfrontiers.com
G & S Guide Service and Custom Rods
http://www.herefishyfishy.com


But there are plastic flys. Mini-hoppers, etc.

Well now.....I can honestly say that I, as well, have never put a bobber on
my fly line. However, there have been occasions where I have actually put
my fly line on a bobber. Makes for a great strike indicator for my bobber.
Of course, I don't think I would call what I do with a fly rod even fishing,
no matter what is on the end of the line, bait, lure, fly, etc. I would
call my fly fishing technique quite embarrassing, even though I enjoy
it.....

--
Sandy Joren
Il pesce tutto il giorno. La bevanda tutta la notte.


LOL. Well, I can honestly say I have never put a bobber on my fly line.
So there! LOL.

Although I have used a 9'+ fly rod with a spinning reel to serve up
minnows to baulky bass, and I didn't use a bobber. LOL.